Anti-Oedipus

194 Pages·2013·5.28 MB·English

THE JOURNAL OF A GROUP ANALYZING THE POWER MECHANISMS WHICH PRODUCE AND
MAINTAINT HE PRESENTD IVISIONOSF KNOWLEDGE.
Anti-Oedipus
FroPms ychoantaoSl cyhsiizso politics
semiotextte
ANTI-OEDIPUS
"Beneatthh eb eacht,h ep avings tone.s. . "
SEMIOTEXT(E)
522P hilosopHhayl l
ColumbUinai versity
NewY orkN,. Y.1 0027
SEMIOTEXiTs(t Eh)es elf·supnpoonr-tpijrnoogfiu,tr o nfaa l g rouapn a­
lyzitnhpgeo wemre chanwihsimcpshr odauncmdea inttahien prdeisveinsti ons
ofk nowledge (psLyicnhgouaiLnsiattlieycrssPai,hts iu,rl eo,sa onSpdeh myi otics).
EditorCioamlm titeDe:e niHso llJiaemreL,se ighS,y lvLoetrrei n(gGeern eral
EdoirtR)o,g eMrc KeoJno,hR na jch(mSaenc reMtiacrhRyeo)ls, e nfeld.
ArEtd itoGri:El i sner.
ManagEidintgoT rh:o smG aora.
AssistEadnitt oPra:t rTircukh n.
TranslatSitnagf( fAl tlh ter anslpautbiloinhsseh reheda v e rbeeveineb wye d
fufeo llowJioneCg a)s:s iEdlyiG;zh ai Pla;t rLiozmibaa rRdoog;eM rc Keon
(TransEldaittiMooyrnu) n;g PsaucnMk i;c hReols enfeld.
ProudctioSnt afJf:o eC assiEdlys;pF ertahs Seurs;a n FlEeltiGczhhaie lr;;
WaynGeu ymoGne;o rgHionrav aBfeut;Kt ayn eL;o uMiasr viEcikl;eM eunl ­
ladDya;nM oshenLbaenrgg-;H PohaanmS ;y lvRiiec haArdddsiR;eu sso.
SpecEidailt oSry:l vLeorter inger.
BenefactGoerrs:aB rudc hKeart,h lDeuednaS ,y lvLeorter iDnagveNired,i ger,
JohRna jchPmaamne,Tl yat elL
SponsoArns;nB oweIrasBn,o weSruss,Fa lna Wtaoy,n Geu ymoMni,La o trin­
geT, RMiibcahlekla .
{Contriobfu$ t5i0o.0no0srm oraer lei satseB den efactaonrd$s 2 5.a00s
SponsoAlrlsc .o ntribaurtteai xo-ndsae bdluec.t]
IndivSiudbusaclr i$p7t.i5po0en vrso :l ume; In$s1t8i.t0Tu0h.tr ieioesn ssu:e s
comproinsveeo luAmded.$ 2.0p0e vro ulmef osru rfacoeu tmsatiihdUlee. S.
and CanaCdhae.cs kh oublemd a dpea yatbolS eem ioteIxnct.{ e),
Semioteisx itn(dee)xi enMd L AB ibliograFprheyn XcXah Bn idb liography.
Pleacshee ck forthcoimsisnuge sw ritaetn odt heS pecEidailt Aolrl.
Our
manuscsrhiopubtlesad c companais etda mbpsyee dl f-adednrveeslsoepde .
CovGeirEl i sner
© by SemioInlce.1x 9t7(7e ),
SEMIOTEXT(E)
ANTI-OEDIPUS
VOLUMIEINU M BER3 1,977
SylveLrOeT RINGER
LibidUon bountdh:e P olitoif'c Ssc hizophrenia' 5
Jean-Fra�noiLsY OTA RD
EnergumCeanp italism 11
JacquDeOsN ZELOT
,A n Anti-Sociology 27
JohnR AJCHMAN
AnalyisinPs o we.r. ......,. .., . ...,. , , , . .,. .4 5, . . .
AntonAiRnT AUD
The Bodyi st heB ody. .' .,. ...,.. .., .. .,, . . .. .. 5 .9 .
ToH aveD onew itthh eJ udgmeonftG od ...., .,'.", 61
FeliGxU ATTARI
MaryB arnesT'r i.p. , . ,,. ... ....,.. . ., . ...,.. ., . . 62
Freudo-Mar,x. i.s..m. .............,. ... .. .... .7 2.
PsychoanaalnydSs cihsi �oana.l,.y s..i .s . . . .. .. 7.6 . . . .
EveryboWdayn tTso B ea F asc.i.s, t .. .,., . ., . ., . ., . 86
GillDeEsL EUZE
ThreGer oupP roblem,s , , .,. ..... .,., . . . .,., . .., 99
.
IH aveNo thiTnogA dmi.t. , . .., . ............". 1.1.0
DELEUZEjGUATTARI
BalanSchee et-ProfgorDrae ms iring-Ma.c.h.,i. n.e, s.. 1 17
May1 4,1 914O.n eo r SevWeorlavl,e . s .,. ....,. , ... 1 .3 6
GuyH OCQUENGHEM
FamilCya,p italAinsums.,, . .............,.. ....,. 1 48
RoberDtY ER/R.AB.R INKLEY
...r eturnhso me( MytholoDgiiaelse, ctSitcrtsuu,cr es):
Disrupt.i.o.n..s. ....... .................. 159
. . . .
SylveLrOeT RINGER
TheF ictioofAn n alysis 173
Inde.x. ................... .. ...... ..... . 190
. . . . . . . . .
BackIs su.e s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1 9.1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
ForthmcionIgs sues. ...... .......... ....1 92
. . . . . . . . . . . .
FrancPiisc abi"aM:a chinTeu rnQ uickly("1 916�1918)
Inscrtiob"peM da chTionuer nez 1V.i"1t1.eF "e;m me2/ H omme"
LibiUdnob ound:
The Poloif't Sicchspi hzroenia'
SYLVEREL OTR INGER
"IfM arxism and Psycahroeat nhaetl wyosb iisgl oseorfst hel ast
fifteyeena rist,i sn ots om ucht hatth eys oltdh emseltvoet sh e
clasisnp owerb,u tt hat tphaeryt icipina tthedev ermye chanisms
ofp ower"
-MicheFlo ucau(l1t9 75)
I
fA nti·Opeudshi*a dm ereltyh rowpns ychoanailnytsqoiu se stiaosni ,t s
titwloeu lds eemt oi ndicaittwe o,u lnde vehra vaer ousine dF rancteh ek ind
ofp assionaatttee nttioow nh icsho meo ft hep iecceosl lechteerdae t test.
Sinciet s incetphteip osny choanalytical eshtaasub nldiesrhgmoennet
quitae n umbeorf a ttacbkust,i ta lwaymsa nagetdo m odifiyt msa ke-up
som�whalti,kt eh ef luv iruisno, rdetroo utlitvheem orep owerfaunlt idotes.
TheA mericaEng o-psychoglroagyd uaelnlsyh eatihtesde ilnfa neo�behav�
ioricshta in-mwahiilc ht ieddo wni ntra-familialt ot bheeht ahveioororyf
communicatIinotne.r pretpaotwievrme a intaiintegsdr iopn t hes lyt,h rough
binary lOong itch.eo thesri deof theA tlantoilcd,F reudianwishmi,c h
hadn'qtu itmea dei tt hef irtsitm eg,r ewa seconmdo,r eg loriosuksi,n by
jumpinognt heb andw agono fS tructuralism. Lhienlgpuetidhs etriecasft toe r
justitfhye" retutrno Freuda"d vocatbeyd J acqueLsac anO.e dipuasn d
castrawtieornet urnedi ntion controvesrctiiebnlteti rfuitcha nsd t he uncon­
sciouisn toa n objecotf purek nowledge reservefdo rts etcrhincot­ly
academiTchsi.si sw hy Deleuzaen dG uattafreili tt n ecesstaord yi reicnt
respontsheeb runotf t heifri rasttt acakg ainpssty choanaalnyds" ipss ycho­
analysi(semfJ".a cquDeosn zelo"tA:nA ntisociology").
PROJEFCTO RA REVOLUTIIONNN E WY ORK
Yett her easlc opoef t heiart tempitst ob e founde lsewheirnet ,h e
moreg eneral otfi Catpliet alainsdSm c ihzophrPesnyichao.a nalisyt shies
specifyiectr, e strictive, apploifc aa rteifolne-cptotiihonantta ctualelny­
dorsetsh ee ntire economy, asl wieblilad si pnoalli tiocfa il,n dustrial
societAifetse.tr h eb atterdienaglt to p sychoanablyyW siilsh elRme ichi,ti s
thew holper obleomf trheel ationosfh idpe stiotr hee s pheroef socfioracle s
thaDte leuazned G uattaartit emtpotr ecahsetr ien a newl ight.
Anti-Oedciompeusts ou si nt hew akeo fM ay '68a,t a timew hent he
radicaloifst mh e6 0s seemtso h avev anishoerdr ,a thhears e xhausttehde
­
"'CapitaanlScdih simz ophrenia: AbynG tiil-DlOeeelsde i&up zFuets H,Gi uxa tt(artranis
latbeydR obeHrutr lHeeyl,eR n.L anaen dM arSke emA) R,i chard Seatvheer Book,
VikiPnrge Nsesw:Y ork1,9 77.
5
Lotnrgier
moste xpedieanntda ll-encompfaosrsmiisnt ga ssumeidnt hec onditioofn s
acutseo ciowpolcirtiis(cicasil v riilg htVsi,e tnawma r,et c.E)c.o nomince u*
rosisc,a refuelnltye rtaainndee dx ploitneodwp, r evaAitlt sh.e m icro.political
levetlh,o ugsho,m ep owerfeunle rgyi ss till sbtliirnrdfilonyrgc hangaen di t
is precisientl hyi rse spetchtaA tn tOie�dicpaunbs e p utt og oodu se.
Itosr iginaolnit thyeF rencshc ene residient sh efa alcsttoh aitn steoafd
grudgingly remaasiJ neianng-,PS aaurlt hraed t od o,t heu neasbye dfelolfow
bureaucrsaotciica liitst mu,r nsso mewhapta radoxictaolwlayrt dhse U nited
Statteosd iscover afnaoctoehf er re volutTihoantw. h iccha nn o longebre
expectferdo ms ociacloiusntt raipepse asrusd denaltyt hev erhye arotf t he
capitamlaieslts trAomme.r icwai,t h firtese .floaantdis nhgif tbionrgd eritss,
impenitpernatgm atiasnmd i tusn restraeinneerdgya fforad bse ttveire wpoint
onm odern industriatlh asmno ocsitEe utrioepse caonu ntrsiuecsah,s F rance,
whichha vleo nbge ens edentaanrdyc entralTihzeeg da.m bloef A nti-Oedipus
is tor eformulraetveo lutiopnearrsyp ectfirvoemts h es tronpgo intasn,dt he
weakl inkosf,c apitalNios ml.o ngemro vinagg aintshteg ran,ib utr ather
pushintgh el ogiocfK apitfaulr thtehra ni te vearl lowietds etlobf e l ed-to
itbsr eakipnogi1 n.
THE NEUROTICS MOKE-SCREEN
"Thosweh o suffferro mt heO edipus-comaprlene oxt s ickt,h ey
makeu p theq uasi-tootfat lhiept eyo pl.eT ot hec ontrairsyo,l ated
anda ffectaesId a m bys implaenxt i-oedIic pouusl,pd a, raphrasing
Saint-Thehroewslla i,k ae b anshee It shuaftf er tonsu oftf e.r "
. .
-ReneC reveElt,e s·tvaouu(ss1? 9 29)
Freunde vecro nsidetrheerd elationosfhd iepssi arned s ocieetxyc epitn
termosf de-sexualization: sublimated fhoorhm iomst ehxeu ality remains
vercye menotf s ocicaolh esi(oCnfG .u yH ocquenghem: "FCaampiiltya,l ism,
Anus")F.u rthermhoere ex plicrietcloygn izmeodd ersno cieatsye ssentially
repressainvdce o,n sequenbtoluyn da ndb oundetdo n eurosIifns e.u rosiiss
thei ntrilnaswit,ch en onno fa liln dustsroicaile twiheosc ,a nd elivuesfr r om
thinso rmality?
Surelnyo tp sychoanalwyhsiiccshu, r else ss tihtra eng ulanteeusr osfoirs
thes implree ason itnht ahte,f mala nalyspissy,c hoanaalnydsn iesu roasrise
twos idoesft hes ame coin.
Whot henV?e rtiginmooumse nti:fn ormaliitsya bnormatlh,e nt hev ery
notioonf " patiebnetgi"n tso v acitlel.Na evertheFlreesuscd o nclud"eAss:
regarthed st herapeuatpiplci catoifoo nu rk nowledwghea,tw oulbde t heu se
of them ostc orreacnta lyosifs s ocinaelu rosseisn,c neo onep ossesses
authortioti ym pose sau tchhe rauppyo nth e group?("O vilizaantidit osn
DiscontTheen tthesr)a.pe uctoinct raicsta sociacoln tratchte:a nalyst
derivhise sp ower·to-fcruormse o cietFyr.o mh ereo n,n o onec anw rest
SOcietfyr omi tnse uros"iBsu.it n s pitoeft hese diffiFcruelutadid edssf,,o" r
thes akoef a rgumeHnwte,m aye xpectth aotn ed ays omeonwei lvle ntutroe
embarku pona patholoogyf culturcaolm munitiWese. s"u rely nae ed
6
LibiUndboo unTdh:e l iPtooif<c Shsci zonpihar'e
Supermafno rs ucha superanalUynsliessa.sn alycsainsd issociitasteefl rfo m
anya uthor.i.t.y
Freud's reasoning reliperse suopnp osciettrhitaoatsni hsno uld be
elucidda itfew e aret o escape atphpiasr einmtp ass(e1:T )h ereex isat s
"correcotb,j"e ctdiivsei,n terkensotwelde dogfem an;( 2T)I rkinso wledcgaen
be" applieodrn" o ta ccordtiont gh ea uthorwiittyhw ltiocnhe i si nvested;
(3T)h erseh oulbde an appointreedp resentwahtoi wvilel " imposet"h e
theraopnyt ot heg roup(.4 S)o cipaalt holoigysd efinbedy", a nalogya,l"o ng
withi ndividdeuvaell opmeinntt e,r mosf n eurosis.
To thiIs willr epltye,l escotphienf gi rtstw op ointtsh,a ftr omt he
outset knowolfem dagne c onstitaunt "easp plicatoifos no"c iaault hority.
Powern eedtso e recatn i dentifioabbjleeci tno rdetro e xerciitscseo ntrol
overi t.K nowledgeev,e ni ni tsp ositiavsep ectisn,v olveexsc lusiaonnds
repressiofo nasl lk indsI.t i st hee xerciosfe p,o werb y otherm eans.
Consequentthleiy n diviedxupallo rbeydt heh umanS Cienicsecs o rrelattoi ve
a specififco rmo fs ubjugatTihoens .i ckneosfs m an isn othinbgu th is
individuaalni tuyn,t encaobnlset ructthiaotrn e quirae cso ntinual libidinal
inv�stmoennttor epressTioo bne.o neseolrfn othintgo,p osseosrst od ie:
paltErryo st rappine da ne itherd/eosri gnteord o ckh imb acka ndf ortihn to
anguiosrha nnihilaThtei ovne.r dye mandosf t hep ersopnr,o ppeudp a st hey
areb y thea ffectdievaed locokfs c onjugalaintdy t heO edipafla mily,
tributtahreym selvoefsa certamianc hineorfym eaninmga.k eu pa ni nternal
policfeo rcfea r more potwhearnft uhlea ctuaoln e.O ned oesn otc ure
neurosoinsec, h angae sso ciewthyi ccha nnodto w ithoiutt.
Certaibnulyth, o w?H erew ea rea tt hec losepsoti ntto ,a ndt hef arthest
remove ftrhoemp ,o sitioofnA sn ti-PsychainadRt ardyi cTahle rapFyo.r m y
thirpdo inits t hati ti sn'etn ougtho t ransftehre rapeuatuitch oristtyi,l l
conceivbeyd F reuind personlailb etrearlm tso,a ne xtra-facmoimlmiuanli ty
(eL
bento n securiannge w,m agnifiOeedd ipuast t heg roulpe vel Felix
Guatta"rMia:r yB arnes'Tr ip"o)r t os impleyq uatteh erawpiyt hp olitical
struggTlweo. e xcesstihvaeit,s m aladjusrteeadc,t itohnaspt a rticulaanrdi ze
reduc(em icro-repreosrs giloonb)a lainzdet ransce(nmda cro-strtughgel e)
complexiotfyp ower-relatthiaostnt sr atsiofcyi eTthye.d iscontoenfot usr
civilizraetsiuoflnrt o mt he faitlour receo gniazned connectd itfhfeesree nt,
specidfiimce nsi(obnets h ey somcaotnijcu,g faalm,i lial, proeftecS.S)i onal,
Freudc onceivseodc ial patahsom leorgeyla yn extensioof tnh e" pri­
vaten"e urosoifts h ei ndividIutia sla .tt hitsh,e f ourtpho,i ntth aDte leuze
andG uattairnit ervmeonsetf orcefuwliltyh refleocntt ihoegn rso uopr t he
horde( "ThreeG roupP roblemasn"d " May 14,1 914On.e or Several
Wolves"S)u.c ha n extensiiosna ctualal sye condopaeryr atiao nm,e re
opticialllu sisoinn ce dtihset incbteitowne etnh estew o" entitiaelsr"e ady
partakeosf r epreSSTihoeni .n stituitsin oontf illweidt hi ndividluiaklaes
fIsbho wlw ithf ishN.o ri st hef amiltyh em icrocofsomr s ocieftoyr,i th as
no moreu nitsya vaet t hel eveolf i deologriecparle sentaAltlio ofnt .h ese
trumped-aUnpa logiceosn stitau teb asic logico-mpaonliiptuilcaatbliy o n
whiccha pitalsitsrma itonc sh okoef fi tosw no verflowing.
7
Lotnrgier
Fort hem ovemenptr opetroc apitaldiosemsn oti n awnayy a nswetro
neurosiitps :r-oducneesu rosoinst he ,ls iikadene a rchaiisnmd ispentsoa ble
itss urvivaa lle,s ser peervfielc dtelsyi gnetdo k eept hep sychoanaalnyds ts
theipra tienit.se,v. i rtuaelvleyr yonbeu,s yB.e hintdh en eurotsimco ke­
screetnh,o ughe,v erm ore powerfmualc hineosf a differkeinntd a re
churninmga,c hinbeesf orweh ichF reuds itssi lentCleyl.i batmoarcyh ines,
nomadipcr,o teaenl,u S,im veeaninglSecshsi.z ophrenic.
ACTION-ANALYSIS
"Psychoanaliyts'lisis k,te h eR ussian revoylouutc iaonn't,te ll
wheni ts tarttosg ob ad."
-Anti-Oedipus
Whatc apitalseitssmd irectilny m otioins a prodigiporuosc eosfs
decodiwnhgi chu nceasinogpleyn esv erythiinni gt sp athS.i nceev erything
becomeisn terchang(elaabwol fev aluen)o,t hinogr,a hnosnto thinrge,s ists
the flowo fc apitwahlo see conomiys o nea, tl eapsottt eina,wl iltyht haotf
desirSec.h izophrdeenfiian leodo selayn,dn otc linicaalst lhye,u ncontrol­
ablep,o lymorphmoouvse menotf d esiermea natifnrgo mw ithitnh es ocial
producticoonn,s tituttheusst het hreshoalndd t het hreaotf industrial
SOCieHtCya:p italtihsrmo,u igthp sr oceosfsp roductiporno,d ucaensi ncred­
iblsec hizoplucehnaircgo enw hiciht d umpsa ltlh ew eighotfr epressbiuotn ,
whicnho nethelceosnst intuoees n gendietrs ealstf h el imiotft hep roce.s.s.
Capitaliinssmt itourtr eess toarleslso rtosf r esidaunadla rtificial territorial·
itiebset, h eyi maginaorrys ymboloincw ,h iciht a ttempatssb ,e sitt c ant,o
recodteo,p igeon-hole persofnrso ma dbesrtirvaecdt quEavnetriyttihesi.n g
returnosrr ecurSst:a tensa,t iofnasm,i li(esAn.t"Oi e-disp)Ru.ep ressiisno ont
jusitm posegldo ballayn df romt heo utsidieti, sg eneraattee dv ersyi ngle
levoeflS OCietya fbuyn damentaanlalyr chaincdi ntensrievgei mael wayosn
the brinikt so owfn dissolutEinogenru. meCna iptal(iesJLmea n-Fran90is
Lyotard's article). wPhsiycwchah sot ahnefa ilrytssotir se,c ogntihzete h rust
ofl ibiadsos uchh,a stenteode ncloistei na formatioonf p owerm eantt o
patchu p thei ncreaSionbgsloyl estter uctuorf et hef amil(ye f.J ohn
Rajchman: "Ainn aPloywseirs" w)h,i lMea rXism-Lenionnicsev mi,c torious,
crushead llr evolutioennaerryg iuensd ert heh eelo f State-nation-family.
Therwea sn o mored istortoifo Mna rxt hanp erversoifoF nr eudE.x itth e
Freduo-Marxailstte rna(teiLvF ee liGxu attariin'tse rviaenwd"s E verybody
Wantst oBe a FaSCist"r)e taunNrndi etzs(cohuenr e xti ssue).
Thee linmaitioonf socpiatahlo lotgyh erefroerqeu ires paradoxically the
radicalizoaft tihoen" schizophrpernoipc"e nsoift tyh es ystemr,i ghtly
perceibvyeR d. D . lainbgy,c alliunpgo ni tmso stm arginealle menStisn.c e
capitalism tohpreoruaghat ecso ntinuonuest worokf micro-contthraotl s
simultaneopursloyd uacned d ifferentthieia ntdei vidaunayll o,c aslt rugagtl e
itspe akc ane ventualilnyt ensibfyy, c onnecttihnegm s trategiaclatllh ley ,
pointosfr esistaanndcb ey s od oing aftfheewc hto loef t hes ocifaalb ric.
Antl-dpOiuesob viouesclhyo eisn th atr espetchte " eventosf"M ay' 6i8n
8
LibiUdnboo unTdh:Pe o liotf'i Scchsiz oph'r enia
FrancAe .h andfoufly ounmgi litadnitsst rusotfaf luhlli erarcahciteeassd
schizol-urteivoon"aarnya lyzaenrdss "u cceedienmd o bilizsitnugd enatnsd
workearlsi kteo,t hep oinotf b ursttihnrg outghhe d ikeasn ds tratifications
builutp by tbec apit"aMla:n yp eoplhea vea sketdh emselhvoewsi tw as
possibtlhea ts o vasat movernersthto ulhda vee ruptferdo mw hatw as
apparenstolu yn importaanne tv enats t hec losuorfae univerasnidtt yh e
intervenotfti hoenp oliicnes tudenatfsf aiIrtis s.t herefiomproer tatnot
explahionw a relatisvmeallnylu mbeorf s tudenstuscc eeidnebd r oadening
thes truggle against poHscuec ahrn ee xptreetnshtsa iitotc n u ltmoi naitne d
theo ccupatoifot nh eu niversaintdti heest otarle jectoifio tnfs u nctiionn
capitasloicsite Lteya.r nitnhgr ouagcht ipolna yas b asipca ritn t heg enesis
andg rowtohf a lrle volutimoonvaermye nFtrs.o amn alyzwihnagt c lioss est
ath anwde, ccaonmt eou ndersstoacniadetl ty ag re.("Da niCeolh n�Bendit).
Thicso nstitau rteessp ontsoFe r eud's inveosftt hiegraatpieoaunut tihco rity.
Ther emedtyo s ocienteaulr oissin so t" imposefdr"o mt heo utsiodnet he
collectiovuitot fya ny" corretchte"o riyti; sa cure-in-tahcatftio ornc es, for
once, antaols yisdwieis t dhe sire.
Revolutailowna ycso meass a surpriIsnet.e rpretlaatgbiseo hni nTdh.e
eventisnF ranchea vep rovetnh arte volutiispo ons siibnle ev ena highly
industriaclaipzietdas loicsite Btuyt.t hey shoubledh na'itl aesd another
ready-mmaoddee tlo b ef ollowbeldi ndFloyr.e venM ay' 68c anb ecome
Oedipal ...
THUSS PAKE TZARATHQUSTRA
"Develtohped esimroet or., "
,
-MarcDeulc hamp
We cannocth angseo ciety wsiitmhuolutta neuonuhsilnyg tihnegi ndi­
vidual antdh ep aolwle rm echanistmhsam ta intahiinsp ositi(olno gic,
dialecmteiacnsi,n g).
Therwea s alrae awdayr ninmgor et hanh alaf c entuargyo e,v ident
wherietw asl eaesxtp ectIendt .h eD adaM anife19s1t8To,r istTazna rwai,t h
a rarleu cidviitoyl,e nattltya ckleodg iacr'bsi trartihneee xstse,n uartuisneg s
ofd ialectiCS, the soifcp ks yscpheocaunlawalhtyiisco"ihnps su ttsos leetph e
anti-objeicmtpiuvleso efs m an and systemtahtejb zoeusr geoiDsaide.a"
understvoeordy wtehnalt o gica,n " 'orgadniisce asiest, h"em osti nsidious
weapon of (pio"tw hearsi nflicutsew di thp assiviintt hye p resenocfe
policem)eSnu chi st hev ery logic, hiheorlairscthimicaz,de edi ,nt 'h e
" .
imagoef t heo rganiwshmi cAhn toniAnr tauwdi lplu lveriinzt eu rnb y
productihnegb odwyih touotr ga(nCfs. "BTohde yi st heB ody"a nd "To
HaveD oneW itbth eJ udgmenotf G od")I.ti sn otb yc hancteh aDte leuze
andG uattari tbheeisgrti und wyi tah wholdee velonptmo ent hes yntheses
oft heu nconSCiouisst, h ert ehaa"ltl ogicaoJr,r "a thaelro giocpaelr,a tioofn s
desirIeti. s p ossibwlrei,tT ezsa rtao," perform contratroyg eatchteiro ns
whitlaek ionngfeer sguhlp o fa irL.og"i dco esnb'rte at"hiet:cs h aiknisl l."
A non-exclduissijvuen ctive Osnty hnetc hoenstirsoa urtyf ladnikasl ecatnidc s
9