Ancient Scholarship and Grammar: Archetypes, Concepts and Contexts (Trends in Classics - Supplementary Volumes - Volume 8)

601 Pages·2011·19.11 MB·English

by  Stephanos Matthaios

AncienStc holarshianpd Grammar
TrendisnC lass-ics
SupplemenVtoalruym es
Editebdy
FrancMoo ntanaarnidA ntonioRse ngakos
ScientCiofimcm ittee
AlbertBoe rnab.Me a rgareBtilhlee rbe.cC kl audCea lame
PhiliRp.H ardie. S tehpe nJ .H arrins oS.t epheHni nds
RicharHdun ter. C hristiKrnaau s. G iusepMpaes tromarco
GregorNya gy .T heodorDe.P apanghel.iG si ustPoi cone
KurtR aafiau.bB ernhaZridmm ermann
Volume8
De Gruyter
AncienStc holarship
andG ramm ar
ArchetypesC,o ncepatnsdC ontexts
Editbeyd
StephaMnaotst haios
FrancMoo ntania r
AntoniRoesn gakos
ISBN 978-3-11-025403-7
e-ISBN 978-3-11-025404-4
ISS1N8 68-4785
Library ofCongms o,tIIlDging-Daita:n -PublkllliDn
Ancieostc holarship and gnnunar :arc hetypes.c oncepandt >c onteXtS I editbye dS teph.­
n ..M.. tthai.. ..F ranco Monunari and AntoniosR en�.
p.c m.- -(Trendsin classics.S upplemenvotlaumresy ;v .8 )
Inclubdiesb liographirecfale rencanesd index.
ISBN9 78-3-11-025(4hard0c3ove-r7: alk . pape-r)[ SBN9 78-3-11-0254(e0bk4-4.)
1.G reekJanguag e-Granunat. Hiotorical.I .M atthaioSst.e pha..n..1 1M.o ntanari. Franco.
IllR.e ngakos,Antonios.
PA251.A2f>0311
4RS--dc22
2010050347
Bib/iDgWlphici nformAtipub/isImoJn bJ the DeutscNhellIiD nIllbibliDthelr
TheD cuncNahtico oalbibliothclik, ttIris> public.tiionnt heD cunchc
Nationalbibliografie;d etailebdi bliograpdatahi can: .vailable inth e Internet
ath ttp://dnb.d-nb.de.
o 20W1ait1e rde GruytcrG mbH &. Co.K G.B erlin/New York
Typesctting: Mich.Pcscbkcel. Berlin
PrintinHg:u bcrt&. Co.G mbH &. ('.0K.G .G 8ttingcu
DO PrintedO Da cid-m:cp aper
Printed inG ermany
www.degruyter.com
Contents
Introduction
1." Philolgioap erennis":
Histoaryn dN ew Perspectives
FrancoM ontanari
AncientS cholarshianpd Cla.�siSctuadli es... .............. ................1.. 1.. ...
H.T heAn cienStc holaartWs o rk
RichardH unter
PlatoI'osann d theO rigin�o fS cholars...h...i...p... ............................ 27
MarcoF antuzzi
ScholaPralnyi TTcav: lKOcpS6 l3osH,o meriPchil ology
andt heB eginninogft heRh esu..s . . .. ... ... ..... . .... . . . .. . . .. . . . .. . . ... . ... . 4. 1 .
StephanMoastth aios
EratostheonfeC sy rene:
Readinogsf h i's GrammarD'e finiti.o.n. ..............5.5. ..........................
FilippomariaP ontani
ExH omegrraom mat.i. ...c. .a.. . . . ... . . .... . .. . . .... ... .. . .. ... . ... . . .. . .. . . . ... . . . .8 7
ReneN iinlist
Aristarchaunsd Al legoricIanlt erpreta.t.. .i.on. ..................... .. . .....1..0 .5
Martin Schmidt
Portraoiftan Unknown Scholi.a.. s.t.. .... ............ ... ............ .1 1.9. .........
John Lundon
HomericC ommentarioensP apyruAs S:u rvey ............1.5.9. ..............
BruceK arlB ra.�well
Didymuosn P indar. ........................................................... .......... 181
vi Contents
PeteBri ng
Afterlivoefsa T ragiPco etT:h eH ypothesis
int heH elleni�tRiecc eptioofEn u ripides 199
SteliCohsr onopoulos
Re-writing the PersonJaolk e:
SomeA �pecint sth e Interpretatoif6o nv ocrIJraKlW IJ�5Eiv
in AncieSncth olarsh..i...p.. ..................... ......................... ............. 207
KonstantiSnpoanso udakis
AncieSncth olainadL osItd entities:
TheC ase ofS imichida.s... ............................................................. 225
IllT.h eAn cienGtr ammarians ont heG reeLka nguage
andL inguistiCco rrectness
JeanLa llot
Didth e AlexandriaGnram marian� have
aS en�oef H i�tory? 241
LouiBsas set
Apollonibuest weeHno merican d HelleniG�rtiece k:
TheC a�eo ft he' Pre-posArtiictilvee' ........ .................... ............... 251
PhilomePnr obert
AtticI rregularities:
TheiRre interpretiantt ihoeLn i ghotfA ttici..s. .m. .................. 2..6. 9. ..
InekSel uiter
A Champioonf A nalogy:
Herodian'sOn LexicalS ignulari..t....y.. ......................................2 91
IV.An cienGt rammar inH istoriCcoaln text
Alfon� W oute-rsP ierrSew iggers
New Papyri andt heHis tory ofA ncienGtranun ar:
Theb rippC1hWapat einr P .Bero9l9.1 7. ..................... ................. 313
Contents vu
WolframAx
Quintilia'nG'anunars r'( Inst.and1 .it<;4I -mp8o)r tance
fort heH i�tooryf R omanG ranun ar ............................................. 331
FrederiLcaru bert
Syntaxb eforSey ntax:
Useso fth e Term o"VvTCX�linS GreeGk ranuna rians
befoArpeo llonDiyussc ol.u...�... .................................................... 347
Guillaume Bonnet
Syntagmisn t heA rtigraphiLactin Grammars ........................ ........ 361
LouisVei. �ser
LatinG ranuna ticMaaln ualisnt heE arlMyi ddlAeg es:
TraditainodnA daptatiino nt heP articipClhea pte.r.. . ............... .3.7. 5.
ValerviaenE L�t
Theodosainusdhi. �B yzantine Successoonrst heP articiple:
A DidactAipcp roac..h... ............................................................... 405
MargaretheB ilelrbeck
TheO rus Fragment<;in theE thnica
ofS tephanoufB� y zantium... ............ ............ ............ ........... ......... 429
v.A ncienGtram mar inI nterdisciCpolnitnearyx t
CaspeCr. d eJ onge
DionysioufH �a licarnasasnud�t heSc holia
onT hucydidSeysn't a.x. ........................4.51. .....................................
Ann eliL uhtala
ImpositioofnN aruesi nAn cienGtr anuna ran d Philosophy.. ......... 479
Maria Chriti
NeoplatoCniocm mentatoonrsA ristotle:
The' Arbitrarinesosf t heL inguisStiigcn ..'... . ............... .................. 499
V1l1 Contents
LisotfC ontributors 515
Abbreviations 523
Bibliograp...h...y.... ....................................................................... 527
GenerIanld ex 563
PassaIgnedse x 573
Introduction
AncienGtr eeks chol:mhip--tyhpea llllCl'TT1EK)(vftTli n i tso rigidnea­l
signation-antdh elin guisticth eoriewshi ch wered evelopine dt he
frameo fthi s disciplarien ceu,rr entinl yth e centorfea multifacetanedd
steadilgryo wingr esearacchti viwityt hinC la.�siPchilaoll ogy.T his activ­
ityis oftesnh areadn ds upportebdy r elatefide lds�u cha sp hilosophy,
rhetorliitce,r aryth eory andm odernlin gui.�tiTchse.a ttractiventehsast
ancienstc holarsahnidpgranuna r enjoaym ongc ontemporary researchers
isa pparefrnotm recesntta ti.�wthiiccssh h owt hedi. �tributoifot nh er ele­
!
vanptu blicatdiuornin.gth� e nineteentahn dt wenticeetnht uriWehsil:e
thefi rsth alfo ft het wenticeetnhtury reveaal cso ntinudoiussr egfarodr
thes ubjetchte,w orksp ublishesdi ncthee 1950isn dicaat ceo mtantly
growingi nterecslte,a relviyd entth rougah s urprisiinngc reeasspee alcliy
during thela. �td ecadeAsp.a rfrto m the intemiotfyc urrenatc tivity,
howevear ,g eographiecxalp ansioonft her esearcihn terceans ta lsboe
observedAl.t hougho rginalily a.�sociaalmtoesdt exclusivweiltyh G er­
man Clas.�iinct ihsenints e teentha nde arltyw enticeetnht urtiheess ,t udy
oft hey pallllCl'TT1EKXftVn oTlw figurea.s� o neo fth e centralr esearch
areains th e Westernp hilologitrcaadli tiionnE ,u ropa.e� w elals i nt he
UniteSdt ates.
Froma historiographipcoali notfvi ew,t hem ain impul�feo rt her e­
cendte velopmoernitg inadtueridn gth e middleo ft hetw entieth century
from thep reparawtoorrkyo n the newe ditioofnt het wom osti mpor­
tantc orporoaf an cienstc holtihae,S chovleitoaen ra th e fliaedd,it ebdy
H. Erbs(e 1969-19a8nd8t )he,S chooln Airias tophanpeusb,li. �heidna
joint-prwohjiecchwt a. �i nitiatbeyd W .J.W.K ostearn dc ompletbeyd
D. Holwerda( 1969-20O0n 7th)e .gro undo fan exhaustiivnev estiga­
tioinnt oth e formationa ndtr ammissionp roceosfsth esec ommentaries2,
Thes tatisrtiecf.e rtroear de includiendH yman'rse vie(w2 0084,2 5--42o6f)
Dickey'bso ok( 2007F)o.r thi . purposeH yman meamred thea pproximately
1000 publicatliiosnti.en dD ickeyb'isb liograpih.yea,. c hronolocalgliy andi n
terno,.f.c ontewnetll r epresentaatimvoeu notf p ublicatiMoonsst.r ecenrte ­
searcha ctivityan d bibliographoyn the fielodf an cienstc holarsanhdi pgra nl­
mar ic.i teidnM ontanati 2009.
2 On thehi storyo ft heS clwolin ath efli ads eeE rbse1 960an d van denV aIk
1963-1964Aft.e r thew orko fvadne rV aIk 1949a,n cieanntdB yzantines chol-