An Average Azeri Village

28 Pages·2006·3.87 MB·English

An Average Azeri Village (1930): Remembering Rebellion in the Caucasus
Mountains

Brnoe Grant
Savie Review, Vol. 63.N0. 4 (Water, 2K), 705 751.

Stable URL:
packs or onghissh O27 67PIMLaNORIES 206

ec 2CISSIARAAYS2NReAL 20 COR IBZ

Slave Review is eurely published by Tue Suserica Associa fr le Acvacetne of Shi Sue

‘Your se of ie JSTOR ative iaioaes you accepence u: SOR Tern nd Cols of Us, ashe
been jsorongbuoeras tua, ISTOR's Temas nd Cnn Use provides, pul, Ua es 0
ke oblaned poe permussen, yoo aay no dake a entice se ol jou ole ees fables, ad
yo ny oor cool aU STOR anhive vy Lue Poe pel, aonecencunrcal ie,

Pleas cuattel ke pobllerveandin ay free oo Us wo, Buber vil ube ray be ue a
pas jurul A

el cony ay pat oa ASTOR raessnsvn na cul Hae sm vomit auc tha apes the sree ot
ne gen ach winsasn,

{STOR ea independent color po ngaizon dee. xen preserva al wie of
Schularyjoumal, Lue tore infonuatug reganing STOR. plese nlc! supporto

epstre itr cy
Mon Boh 27 ISH 2
ARTICLES

An Average Azeri Village (1930): Remembering
Rebellion in the Caucasus Mountains

turuce Grant

Tron he end af 1120 0 Apel uf 184 che police siuaton in. our region
sets gov In Al ty le tl Pande aed 4 commotion ad sca
haoment, Canents, hover. our political mation ¢an I ¢oncakal
iseeage

~Palieal epson Brom worthivex Szerbaian. November 1038)

‘hut did it mean tw be average in the Sovier Union al the exzly 295th?
This war the question confronting mc as 1 si it prosincial archive 1m
Azerbaijan in the atumann of 3007, iu dhe sonal ily of Sbeki, sfx honors’
dre northsseat of the capital, Bako." Housed ia dan stone balding,
the archive had a single eadiny soca that filled exch day with men aid
women working threngh property registers frora before, during, and a:

ter the Sevier pesiow) Us ae eliien to paper fcagmenes thar would alleviate
then ue burtens or aseretheie propery rights in the bustle reuing oF
life the peet-Sovier republic had couse 4 look for somnces am the his

Asses fori we wansoppont he Ani Gal Lear Sait Te
lic Hurkkants eeahip Me eran melo ftertona anion the Se
‘malta es Cen, et Stbacne Coleg qe arkncmedge heeled
"note asa a Neda aacne mee ange he Sena
{ngcnd comment sated be Sites Absulgen le Rens, fesue Vira ty
‘hin Pavia ana, duu Hore et iar Vga header Aue aon,
Pat Wmsing, Anse Bal Hint inberie: Revel Menno Ses Se
{isi Onthaine Tie ewes Nay Iie, Li Sangean, Sete aa ease
Fin Wgner-baevie ad Lie Sale ies. Tt peat Une 2 Jn
srsimof the Roan sala Uaropan reng rick ese na eth
Sera Mn Urner taunt race lent cian lee de
tira bee

he epigaph ahem en Maan Lagom 286 Caotad
Jeriyes Rite Matra Lecce ie revo €1404 entry ag
‘Acai lara ak Pin Catedral Archive Aris, lca Branch hee
SUMARATBI.E 1c Li the a acroalen achiral oe Rasa pr aed
(pi oud hb Os the oespnnting rer fv wot tea an Por
ecu reeves sor aguge monet enn tees caps dee Lan ube
‘adopa by Le pu of fein i) tr tera hod of he weal rae
sede Gea iain ber shah Ba a Sater

Tr Thi ot Sek ard moni ald ave divisors Fro ae Stns
nvderhe Risa ad Heater sateetogs ought ones ne gel
etargahiy Wrought tbe pes from The lite uae onthe hel the
Ut cetiry fyaetiymnae Sh kaa 90S

Depa seh

Shr vs 1 nes 208)
70K Shee Revie

cy of a mouncain vlage where Thul been doing echnographne fielt-
stork, where rhe grandson a a Sufiare sain hae ler a rebelons against
Soviet power in, 190, ‘The sioy a what became kaos locally wo "Ue
Shek eel” (al yu) nll tdan, a6 it igh ave et, et
amples whodunit. Wasita tamphant sign of lire Aer ensstance
amananislyrannsoF a gater amet-led ehavade toexpexeanti-eniet ele
rents? Was the movement driven by charismatic leader with busi
posers, or bya palially inesperienged young ova why Fopud hia
1a tap Inevitable uta ual pastisus, evidetee Cove publidied, utc
wal, aud eoateniporary oral accounts suggests all of thse things. "These
Tater enuliple aad Lively cewrilings of the Sheki rebellion, dating from
amore than seven, years afer ietoak plara, demanterate Hs ondaring 5
tus as both evenc and metaphor tor thate who reconstinte i Todas
Secording 10 some reporis, as man as 19,000 men and soren.
cnvire Families ol farmers and Wiesiaet, Maslin deviesand Comnnnisr
Party members lock part it one aighLof skeet burles followed by rece
‘daysol ecrie eal ie April 1980.* Rebel leaders empried the prisons and
eganived a cabinet, a sual silitia, and everva ude office. Mtoe the Hea
‘Army azvived we retake dhe ely. lumreds were arrested, acne inn exile, oF
Jilled. Yet only aouths later inthe ratletaffces of the Shek adninisten-
Goo, the telling language of memorandien worked with is lamiliae lip:
SPram the ene a 1929 (a Api of W880,” an unnsuied secretary of the oe
real disin repores, “ihe political aiwatioa fn oar region was goo
April, 9 few hulaks and! Tnaudis razed a conunotion ant spreach disco
ren.” Bult whi does one waite about the scare of political lie when anes
neo predecessor has been execnted ar gunpoine only menus euler?
“Curren,” he wroce, “che political siartan in au dsl could be cam=
sidered average Torta hesabcomah iin

2 Besnard eof cginaly ayutcra a
‘endian ot uel eo gees by bi ase ene lp
‘Mow tare thnne 92-18 Mest, ™
“haan ic ealeancscie Ugus nn Mise RGR ers aC 2700
rian ine Shed exc alung Bar RC Re mare Hi sana he
Prep inicate Ut use 2000 Conran Fen S Reel ues sone ed
ante coustersetolutonary merrmant. © B Danie thy sa, Tiger nati fe
ton Kline retain De Fea 3 teh, 9 1099 Sh
[Bosc 1u'o~ aus 250 Mire Rag, bblal won cht
Nibbe-Zakatdon Grae ipo ti a tai NI gS ls Pe
Thuy Ss Avaranean Repumtse Vshiv uc Mawr nf Ninna Sey Se
ale of Suetasian Pree the Aucioe dhe ROR Svea SER) neal
STURAE 1 G5 Thr ets enetngucd ag P12 Le alread
pesons nc ile it ere end ‘exe dele ooh 29 war
Tad Reeves oud at 2th Serene BGA and U0 wee seed Ite ne
Sri vent Iphis octamer. “ia, fame at Foyle Rehan Ser ar
in Taehain, Soto 1825 prctnird o enlahop. "Raney Hacasat Worl or
fear Tnogae ne Men BGreg” cepeced by ne Sasa Sten Rosen
‘Gronci and nue Users, Apri 201, Rese ics Acar Roser St
Dora Fuad Haakadar Hose Dini Avan Coated Sue Artie af Pe
urecand Sci evens Ue Repen Aoetien dle Pet 4

wi
Ave Auvemge set Village (1936) 707

Wis esidng to vend dh archival moment as Aevapian eupheroinm for
‘war could anf he described as chans in the eounteysee, a8 local party
‘fire king eine in ve ggg a Pavers Tigre a al
rotind Tadged, iri los han river yea allsing Ortober 1817, Me

Tims in the eastern Caneasis had witnceted the speetaeular collapse of the
Russian and Oliaman empires, vigorearsimuerecnticns Ty dhe British aN
the Tuske iu the nous that followed, # suuehly natiouabst period of
antlependence led hy the Misavar Party (1918~120}. and the escabtsh-
neal of Soviet gosexaneo iat pil TORU, Given he pace wt whieh eves
‘cauined to unfold Miraughout the 1920s suis a tectonie recapping
tol political, econuuii, und social Leraine—from the sundacdation of
plideal rue und new commumicancmsteelunologies meet hy neve political
Tlerato the banning ot the veil, zheintradnetion atthe Ladin alphalse. at
the expense ol the Arai one, and the coleetvialicu of Whe counteyside
Insel isnot hard io imagine chatanyone’s sense of he “avenge” would
‘ve love at best

Bul instead o€ dissing dhe wervoue blandaess of the Sheki pre
ouuceaten, shal would happen ifwe took die report quit lrerally, on
dts own terms, to interrogate averageness itslY? Where docs che mCeage
came From? Hos iris mace Ard, moet importa wat de we sake of
§i? The inerage. dhe everylay, the ordhnare: there are the measures by
‘shiek losterans, sociologists, and anchropologists hate long made pat
fem out Of chaps, sameness ont of dierence, and memars pul of his
tam! suc da these terms signilf the same thie?

Long alter Hegel famously prulessed Ua deze is on history wigan,
surugglh ("Periods bf happicess are enspur payes in fustory">. colar: of
Ablgaecsite have lahred w produce chronicles othe normal and the
‘dirt, wile equally uumierous volurags have bren dedicate! roeiting,
Une very dull gages of dae everyday! We the concept of “avrrage” hae
seemed lo bear a nove complicated sera asaclacionsy noc Teast on oucu-

4. Forth husoente stleton tp pions eedengs and wlkeideut a
‘ba le ang are wrk Bae x ik Bi
"Rana luc Seca Lilac Not sng Soca 0 Hoa Br ae
aL Bao te arene titantron Patees Datla 25 4 a
Sepa Reh, the ente-—Te Tr Ue Mtoe, achive leigh”
oaeo Btn (fanny 0 35

Biss Yo ecard of dang” reach soba Maunce bic gue
‘wrote Morey Mpromtant i tad a bans” Mourre alonach coe
re tory Oe Wr, 8), bh

(2G Tegel, uta ety of uy te Sens fone ti Ph
io ba rae ben Rage Peay, LIRR Alec nt ty a
cere re prominent opts ia A Lies me Pe ty Pos ee
Remon Heol Papi td ty of aah Uinomane Hb) Sed See
Conta Tie eno era fe eke 88 ou mone rn ee ee Sy
Fn iuhenptngy ane te Heese er Gm Tore,” As Sry Hy 3
Esto Tas Hath he Sit ote, Ue ie bes ineanen fos Sheds ar
Pats eet st Root Stine Chivers dae mothe Pre St Ase
tho ae Yk Honor abe focus ons eaiarbnay everest 5.
epee al niveineraring eS ere
a Stove Review

ology, where the Focus om canural difference lang ago eemulted in the
Abandanment oF nosions al ypical” un Tavoraye” etural capers.

Tay om br the nineteenth eeutury: dhe Belgian stbolur Adolphe
Qveeelel insisted Gait averages sol ouly abe dntegeal w scholinabup
Troadly conceived but are in fact only meade knowuble by the al-ws
Wut fabors of edhotus ibetmelves, "When ven ure divuse iogedier ia
society sued Une various sizes conte togeder in te nest unlikely cou
aio, eye is between diese ssc iok that alles us io eemder
each indivitual asa necessary pre of hile ach ha na phil eteure
‘ad sraper us ithe indvidyal incanee.aerd which can only be perceived.
Uhrragh the eyes of science

Meraphysica, clesive, and fictitious how is ic dat Quetelet’s eurly
sense of the average 60 quickly became loot ix Uhe rwore forma sien
lie renderings of fac, even "Ippicalig.” Uy which averagemess has since
Decome known? The mayaery of averageness may be laid hare, of comes,
sehen we take moments aich #4 he Sheki pronouncement and map th
provenance and cheir coneest. Hot perhaps Geter is offering te uve,
Asha would happen if se were tn Teclaitn this carly sen a The (ern,
rot through the typiealigg bn thrangh the mpwers that proxies the ue
for later arta of sense-making and persis? For. ay we fd m che
chronicles af the Shri rebellion, Uke very elements that are narmally
‘wept aside in hisorical recomnting—che metaphysical, tue elusive, atl
the Eucetious—are central wo the events andrance. Wheve laut pre-
ily religous fit, and political design meri, uotesies such a3 Urome
surrounding Shake rehel Ieader Motla Must emerge am venucions
responses co events hat serm lo sist logic: Uageries on che scale of
Sealinism, de rise ane Fil stiles wa the silence and the hapes that
go with them

1 this arccle £ map ce Le of ome Aver lage cheenigh che inks that
ic has maineained to the Sheki rebellion of 1930, which als maek Has
parcot the lager Siviet Lion ata ime whem Losi Stain was ceemestion
his ponccr and rolling « sweeping program of callectviratian actuce he
eleven ime zones ofthe enormous new alate, drut on oral Mains
Teeted through ethnographic lieMlwurk i dhe natal village alee! the
sebellion’s organizers, Molin Mwstali Suey: om public archival of
Terings: on popular hisrorical accounts emergent since pores kay and
tu the Byzantine reasoning offortuer KGB intelligence cdocusuents. Tu che
fie section. "8 Mountain Sry” Tec the rst crime tere of debate
‘over the fife of Molly Mustafa, whose very Tis pi is auderstnod meh
like Queteter’s euaking of averagencns inset: metapligseally ehuvey, Ft
‘idonsly: In the secnnl section, “Rememhering Molla Mustafa," lexamine
luow contemporary residents sf Molla Masta village remeroler and te
ousttute hit tory In “Idiom of Rebellion,” the third sertion. pave bee
youd the Cole War frames nf Scniet time and space by snsiderion, how
‘Ceuturies of cuccessive Inceiga rule in the Caneat st the riage for waves

7. ucttein Fringe Es, “Noo, Wcglng an dhe Law Kobe oa
ow ab ie ee} Cute Deni 1001, 145. Exo aed
‘An Avemge Azer Vila £1939) 708

of rebellion against seeuniagly disinterested metrapoliia aloes In the
Foneth section. "Reading Molla Shurafa,” U examine how widels varying
Fimblished andl archival snares eamapere tor penmuasive force among Ae
‘vores autiances. By ming oral and teritunn narrative to renter the story
2s Tally a8 | ave leaencel 3. chs approach looks to move beyond the im
parse found in so much Kertamure om the Cauearus, where politics hee
Teng beoa rendered exelustecly a8 state life, hislory as state rence, and
ethawgraplis us cabinet of cusiosiy, The long lie of Uwe Shehi rebellion
shows how wally polices, history, and culmal frame hecame intormined
fshappens when any posserlal event heaomes spmbol.*

Br imeadacing readers 19 (hie iallucntial episod neural Azeri his
lweysmuy ged is tu explave lew Ue "couuaun property"seprevented in the
storytelling of specific national pusi iflevis andl refashion our eoriven-
tional nnderstandings of early Neviet history. "lo speak ot ressance to
callectvization campaigns in ¢he la 184k, for example, caneentionally
"immone the contexal kagie of ehe eign cxarmples ihe lepavins ofthe
omenieal wi, the ceanrimireatthe peasanl howsehola,and waves 3
toneatie rule, Bul not all eviot cities a the vas slaw cle sense of he
force and speed of event seound Usean iv the same wavs. Te this exsay
after a portrait of an antisterict rebellion in Azcehaljan that 88 99
auch perlenasuve as protest iva location, due oulern Caucus where
“inde of eebeliou” hve eeu + oug-stacading factor in local rulet where
clllenges Wo private propery and public spheres were incerprated
througlt archetypal rooral und religions frames; and whese Soviet lead-
crs found themecleex competing with Turks and Persians serass the bor
dlezs dor rhe politcal imaginarians af" iheir new proletarian euustituents

A Mouonain Story

On the night of Apsil 1990, Molla Musa Sheyktyade Teft his heme in
the uorliwvesl Averhaljani village of Tush Shahalid and ceacies! far an
armed assault on the nearhy city of Sheki, 9 sik-peuduciug eenler nce a
amon ernottinls of medieval ade conutes, Vor at leasta year anda hall
Molla Museila, together will evo other proramene leaders —kemall Hang
Bfeodi_a Turk and Bebram bey Nebibeven, highly decorated Aces il
itary iicer in che saree armny—had hoch lying the youerdivork for de
osertheav of che eonamnise government snl Hae establishuvene of an Ts
lac sate on the tertiary of Sowict Aver nije

In epping peal goby, rope Kb Very he sar
ou Chass Sunes rir rare tog De Beet pose ge rete ie
Sot dew pe neg ln ass ck te
Toe Raabe our 128 m9 £100)

3 Tua se lon "mmo peop” Fo By, mri Stn, 8

1. Thar seh rie poplar inves acon te het Pete,
‘tsi age “Soire ey UL Ament Bh) (1s AM:
‘obit Manat, Sa Reon Bak Sours Nea asin
Galt pata, esr dasa gors 2 Spr HR ge Uo ke ApuLeUNS pee op
tos pus 3:8 93 fe 19 Sp 309 pub UO as BOE Gp
se 208 pe ed Me pe eA T Mp0 Eee] an Ep 30,
a0 Stowe Revs

‘The thcee een snd eis Fullowers summed snd funded ia past by peo
Tarkiah agente schom chey understood ta he froma tae underground uc-
sills mnevement. Lihud! vo erage! {Union sux pougren}, scted onthe
‘widespread discontent with Sontet rule in the eri countryside!” Opper-
fang om die belief dha as ony 45 7,000 Turkish woope were statioaed
the forests of che Greater Cancusus mosmeon, and thal Atalérk binwelf
would take Rrku weeks later in Ma, over 2,01M Aver from in and aroun
Sheki armed chemaeives Gor ata

The Febellian al been iarended forthe tenth anniversary of Sesict
Fale in Azerbaijan, 24 April M430, be local events avertok the platters
‘shen nnerst in neighboring cries gave rie fears ol eliseaner. Ses 6
fad on the night af TL April, as Molla Murata and his men readied fr
3. moing asl, Pon paicamen who had bran tippeeull fied ots 8
Molla Mostals’s Headqeuters, Molkt Most retuned lize, Killing bo,
‘men, and eventually seized a third, Qusimo, head of the poliieal affairs
tlission ofthe Seki Distriet Exeentiee Comraisine nigndian), whom he
huge and escent. Sheykhzare's compatriots, king the gan volleys
1s a signal, began ro gather ar the village council alice i nelah bering
Ashaghi (3ynok ancl organized their marel on Shel, Thi wight, Fears
ing al the death of his deputy ollcer at sassiooy Ria Bulge, fre rc
setry of te Sbeki Conumuuist Party office telephoned Mir Cufar baghi-
‘oy, Auevoajuts power coonuissar for inerasal uffairs {U2 (~ [24S and
lager heed of the Conunumist Party of Azerbayjan (18319933, to alert
mt Guat 500 arated mien were advancing on He cits. ‘Done Rather wirh
i" sas Baghiren’sfarued sespanse. repeated in almest every papular joue~
ulate uctount and moumesintop retelling. i's jst a provocation?”
Theset roramista'ejrolased disterestiu the workeftebelion makes
case Tene is believe ibe aia of popular lore and government intelli=
genceaserving Chat Bahru far from harm been caught unaware, may
fiave Deen dhe etal spouse of the rebellion Irom the amis. ‘These
sources nia that Baghiens, working closely with Caveat] Beri,
Then head of intelligence in Georgia, se Decne who pat Molla Mustafa
Ju contact with agents eho poweel a6 Azer} atiaalistspaupatbizess fa or

[Ea a Das pm: 125 ve as pe ER Map DG, EAL
ip tat kp Cul foie Spe Fn a 75, 198, eat
Malate, eninge gan 0s, HA, 37-59, Wk ane Gna aor sie
{ail portray Ms ri ean aly ssn. aera wiht ncn
‘Stray srperied hr Vola Mula vs bigraity Ue on Mee Ui on Sn
Fvnnn gota deed aac

Ui te woe (et kvl ves whether the dag oe Lscouy a ion
sex the moyeraot foe sky Th ese by ted Losin he ao
[puceef Adi Prey ican, TW Hob nr onmot e ge fo Maen
a, aecrting to Dalen cade fran emt nen aM ok wei
Slee Memalgson SS bade Wisi Sin oben! Ceara ihe et
{sine Tasmry Sung frshe eas Bod (Chieager 1, Ei
‘eta jal of he Ereatne U9 uur Inui nee et ay, gre
bomen ma fo Cohen) pat panty 417-1489 Sec Polase
Seicstamsit ad em C2. Callin, Baansat Drbmary 9 jon (Taba, Ba,
wean _

12 oad ne, ponatonu” eS sarge Alla, “akin
Ane Avonage eri Vilage (793 m

ler 16 fomeu rebellion and roar one anre-Sovie clemente.® Why ele,
anne have asked, would Baghiro bave waited slong Wo retke Shek?

‘An equally prasneative question concerns the. fate of Walla Mowat
hires: Despite his youth —only twenty-four acthe tne of che uprising —
he enjoyed enurmous regional support as the grandson of a Suf-stle
saint, Sheskh Ghmed. Miia Mustata butl been active io maintaining his
grandtichers shrine (or pi} in Hash Shahalid, a mered site attracting pil
rime [roan ag Jaras Turkey and Wan. tu the wake of the rebellion, Mala
‘Moustafa fled into the steep hills worounding Shcki andl Bash Shabald to-
erhar with his ce-ronepitanr, Wr Mola Wstala vos the anfy ane nl Ihe
Fobelons adders ra aareive arcar andl cape. alter alot @ dull gear of
interrepatiom in Bak’ Ballona prisun, he wos xentenecd (os labor comp
inn Ute uoctheru Russias Republic’ Sclovetak Ishuids mul saved for exe-
‘cation, Ceemtoally his surviving children im Shek! received nore chat he
had brem killed by tring squad in IST, However in I, fllemsing Ihe
death of Sealin. shen Baghirar hirsellsae ied in Bako for his amps
repecssise measures, a KGB agent tate ihe cont chat Melle Musi Hal,
in aer, never heen killed. Inisligence souwces it Sheki winesined dea,
Molla Mustla wa alive and sell, convespoadiag egulacy wigh his cela
lives, Way, then, became of Mulla Musca after the wehellion?

These questions develo pein thzee snmier vl [anade to Bass She
bali since 1429, sche LuSt vised he pir of Sheykh Ehmed, legendary
inghe segion, At che dine, ny goal vas 10 Lhiok of ways by which tural ox
pevieuce in Uke Caueusas anighe huform compararve amderstandings a
onflitsaceuss the region, particularly given the paueiry of eras side
themactropoles. Fhe amd atietizalion in Averbafi hiss been favored
with a namber ol excellant monographs. Yel be dial of reuictons on ac-
ess. foremost For western schenes ci by restelons on de kinds of ques
tine that com be asked, Foremost for Soviet schulaty, there has been
relariely like dy the Azeri coun teyide.* Dering the commas pc
rind, the loug standing prosceptions againac even talking <I antiSuviet
rebellion further bmired histaries a priical lie ia the countryside

There was plenty got to uh about. fo the year 1880 alone, et least
30 incidents a anti Soviet disurlacices were recorded! fn the Catcass
Fegion, paut of a Layer 13,74 disturbances across the Tociner Soviet
Uni, *Netit eas et uu 1589 thae accounts a sebelliaa ia Shek und

1 aban, "bin": i Tse
14 Aawug in beckon tnghemirigvage wanna Aude Shh
sua Tat te ood nat nae sen Pee ean, AEN Ronald ig
Stine Trt Comoran Pal? 70 Cay and omaha edna etc res
(eos tates Stach a ar dah OIE epg Rte
‘io mu Seon come (Now Yn TDS ad Scie, asa oho
& tbe nt a Wn Rog oe of ees pane
ie of ain tal ie uN an grants fang fp a
iS Bo 1534 - ”

TE Lae Ys, He So: Calman a eof ha Ri
sina Ren voc. hy ib. borcomporse semen Seenu ee odd eos
ir Madge aman ein ren, TOT, aap or wap on
sire tsbtics ta ev inher Se pfs Dazain Ree Pingo
‘owe Shia spas, Say Penn Pstocced Spe a
m2 Stacie Review

lesthere were firs plished The rare often Hart the same or sim
ilar scories of "mssieal mountain life” repeated, however, dhe mite 38
suck dna deeper wtcans of polite sente-aaking were being losin de
cousigmaeut of rund Kuosledge lo eduuvgraphie cativs, The memories
‘of Molla Mustafa aud dhe Seki cehellion olfer exuaerdinary eveute om
fevervlay life in wubuliuous umes, DUC Uiev also suggest bow particular
southert Caucasie codes of poner snd authority illevted the tecepuon
‘of curly Soviet cule

Remembering Malle Mastafa

“To reach Past Shab om Shehiie 1809 or 2002, panseryers could ike
jeeps trucks, ora haltiug bus wo onike Ute Ioag clnub into dhe bills, Cau
tion on the precipieuus, winding roads und mauch grinding of gears ro
saleed in this ovengy-Kilamencr eip taking juse ower an hvur. Past che
neighboring villages of Ashagh Shahalid ana Bash Gaynik, several hun
dre square meters of namiral floodplain lie atop the hill. Phe plain ie
spread with foor-thick, white-grey boulders. so uniform in size thal they
Sppear almost to have: heen quarried lara tall stone builling aud the
Ted behind ‘This volte vealed, ising snl abillig Ws season, separates
Tash Shabalid froma is neighbors ane from ¢he vsiora who came in the
pilgrimage: sir (vara ot Sheykh hmed, ar as he ie kre fn the =
gion. Shevkh Hah." At Bree sight. this mountain Inearinm ean resemble
theserdant slopes ofa Syietcansion. [0 the somuner, meisiove fet moun,
tain ennall makes che sell secm te explode with geuwth alou every pada
The vichness of he loud is owe reasou shy it hue been eultiated for 0

{ieee Caer Tew Wh, EA an Low Vila om h Satin
‘hia Pe nl Pie Rne 0 ld, 30),

ina Bape std unericw ilar LU nonsense, Hohn
pow tba ade Aut ste: guonps la ter ace the aha SS
So 1388 vale uonpe cts Mand 2h Ansherseentem on had
‘ese ts bere xara Cage iene be ate pb Ia Le,
Seamed of rringgroopinge iy ll SR Mana and ona onsen
igh Nove, Terie, Saco, adele ua Latease Siew bea oy
[ahi arom he pi hi ideale ad rsa ot mee Are
Fajen rove eg let” 189 Soe Alta he Ane Mok Se
Bordo fionajon ad Rusa ad Santo hl the mot engl see
‘an a Set tbls Asa aber, Da noo boomy
{i Roney (kt Avr av tea mi heehee aceon ssc
‘beioy of 280 ur stauby Newbiv wt Pane ak, An, S18

Th feds estan Cazares sea arm lone ight koe a
Tiga omen ae uv reaches ie verted Weng Ta ab cee a
arya more fob pelea satan Ttwh Shot ve dey el
Srsomndanto he Popbet Malan, hea fi refered a Myths
Steet pr itr he honor ae aes ste eonngr song Soe MUSLaa pe
loon martes tac sles rane her tone cook
Shri Mts aca estes Atul Warn Tia au ah Sey
$e To Sua pi Patt Sacra f Keres tandem, VRE: pre 9 tae
‘eon af the Brg ots tesa in fren srtng Win cats en by he
‘ro mala em ledge ods pues Kongai flame sence ee
“aroun pw fon at hes ut el Slants suse nent aes
‘ie taacStedreempoais of he Moab a
Ar Avorage Ast Village (1930) 73

loo. Faumets ploughs souinely chun up ky. gots. numa bone
ttndenground trea Cita ates Canale and carved) ck sitive
Sinatended by archacringin bo Rav hire sac iste
tovrach locaons-—ava const reminder ate ong ecen f m
‘rosuputon of che Rl

Tredieseoner of AN, when wllagers wer calle 9 he leva shook
hou oat ballon a elerenenm thar wld shang lector Lam
Allin the presidents son tn becoate te nea fa Tue to cade the count.
Bush Shabald regicved some 12 hones wh an extras arma po
lain of nc BR. the aera ppeation mas cloves to 490, grea dee
“emigration ot fathers, hnshand wine, and dudes slang work
Sthewhere amide the como ivwabliee of Ue mt de new repuli
Hove young monten reed imdier than She but sone every ait
Jus su uncle or sou wlio had moved to Kus, plang they ang Oe
catinated nore das one milo er omen we hee her ep
ithseareh of economic opportanien nce the colar of the Toes So
set Chon

‘Whit the vanous collective frenshorth or shel folded decade em
lie severe Randel 0 quidaton commis who parece out and
cauipment nd sniqals in serangeusete Gt exe mone on aan
cous ody to eomitcerormes chemaclves Sine thes dost ll rex
Slents have worked ax smaleal fame sn horas, rang
fu, segetbley and annals Trent ermeclen an vay af ae care
troy fora the sale of Rone, hcl, waaay cheamek and, hen
Shey dey he aha, the wgulvous aay eal Vk ron he
Ft of mullrres, Mem nh had burses ao works gewtrovi 1 cll
neato tes fro he fore draw them hack teh yay a ie
them in coveted pit (0 atake charcon, 3 backsbreaknfob Gnat could
‘arn them a cha beequnaleot of for daar es Susiued Evin
Inter ies tas respect ath Shabala had enya couaon
‘sh ber sora comcunics aeose the Contemporary. Cancun, For
thse fom che oie who ele dese, lames, Bash Sabai as
Darden garded tris religin ign, veladiag tee mausoleum
Si Sheykh Fbmed, the grader of Mla seats, f vao emer
feed at centr of cee.

Th hiv set 1 oer shore crac ram interviews cade in the
somenerael lof 02 magestingthevicious configaranns he an
‘ithe 1820s eealon inrememDbered and yecomaited nthe toma
sve theveanceni leader To be sme dese were the Lindo tohes

18 tte sige a ate ele psa er vss Fra. Ubvus at
loc anche nee ree oe or sagh ome ines a He ubs
Stevinele thf. lu ial problems, jn, te soe ste ay a6 opt
‘uw forest Hoy sale set oF he ral ol psi cenetsjenny rece
iPr Medhchaaaan Lire Aenbaithens” Ero owtantnnts Leta
itary A1ORAT 1, 4d Bak Suna, orn Atal ee ety
asta nent rm tLe Beds 1
Tn Topcon uous Serban th ours ove en 068 2061
"akong Ueno in Baa Saad props. Uheheasemsn Ths ecuo ee
‘deiner unacagons ilo asian fen oat ei many a cd
tee usin when ey sted ne Ser nck pn ule Pele