American Society of International Law Proceedings of the Annual Meeting American Society of International Law 2010: Index & Table of Contents

2010·4.6 MB·English

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ONE HUNDRED FOURTH ANNUAL MEETING
OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
CHAIRS OF THE COMMITTEE Co-EDITORS OF THE PROCEEDINGS
OF THE ANNUAL MEETING K. Russell LaMotte
K. Russell LaMotte Hari M. Osofsky
Hari M. Osofsky Allen S. Weiner
Allen S. Weiner
CONTENTS
Foreword
An Introduction: International Law in a Time of Change
K. Russell LaMotte, Hari M. Osofsky, and Allen S. Weiner
New Thinking on Social and Economic Rights: Honoring Virginia Leary
Introduction: A Celebration of Virginia Leary
iaa ca ae ia ee ia ed 3
The General Comments of the UN Committee on Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights
Philip Alston
Remarks by:
Andrew Clapham
Mona Rishmawi
The Right to Health: Assessing How Far the Discourse Has Evolved Internationally
and Within the United States
Alicia Ely Yamin
Risk, Science, and Law in the WTO
Risk, Science, and Law in the WTO: The Centrality of Institutional Choice
Gregory Shaffer
What Can the WTO Learn from International Environmental Law?
Annecoos Wiersema
Resolving Complex Health-Related Disputes Under the WTO’s Dispute
Settlement System
DY cnciiicracdaaviscsusivscennsbeinbicnnuSosnoianmtndadlaieipatnasakmctcaiit ipaRgailtaiennasritatanaiantneesd 26
Empirical Approaches to International Law
The Transformative Potential of Rigorous Empirical Research
PI I ais acavcsctnscecicsncionsdcughioetvecbiecemnmnusslilaps aciguetubieabiisasalanseaaiiahatatalsditeteiwesaaaual 31
Empirical Modalities: Lessons for the Future of International Investment
Susan Franck
Getting to Closure: Winding Up the International and Hybrid Criminal Tribunals
International Law and the Closure of the International and Hybrid
Criminal Tribunals
Valerie Oosterveld
The Security Council’s Consideration of the Establishment of Residual
Mechanisms for the International Criminal Tribunals
Huw Llewellyn
The Role of States in the Closure of the International and Hybrid
Criminal Tribunals
Anne Joyce
The Special Tribunal for Lebanon and the Discussion of Residual Mechanisms
Giorgia Tortora
New Voices I
From International Law to International Conflicts of Law: The Fragmentation
of Legitimacy
Harlan Grant Cohen
The Limits of Legal Citizenship: Reading Aleem v. Aleem
IRE i: ce ee ee tMCRT EEE
Citizens of the World
EE ee Oe TT RE NT I ET.
Engaging Religious Laws, Players, and Communities
PERSO OTE EDL Ee A oe LEONE TE TE TE TE 58
International Human Rights Law, Foreign Sovereign Immunity, and
National Courts
Introductory Remarks by:
Curtis A. Bradley
Remarks by:
Michael J. Edney
Immunity and Human Rights? A Bifurcated Approach
Rosanne van Alebeek
The Goldstone Report and the Modern Law of War
Introductory Remarks by:
Lucy Reed
The Importance of the Goldstone Report
Omar Dajani
A Critique of the Goldstone Report and Its Treatment of International
Humanitarian Law
Abraham Bell
Teaching International Law: Lessons from Clinical Education
Introductory Remarks by:
Richard J. Wilson
Clinical Education and International Human Rights Law: Retrospective on
UQAM’s Pedagogical Methodology
Bernard Duhaime
Teaching Human Rights to Advance Social Justice in Russia
Lusine Hovhannisian
Remarks by:
NNN IIIT HIIIIINIILLT cin inssuscaisitetaiacadsnbaaiiaadsdiessscacedabenunenieeatantéeceinindiadanuatiaduenimanienniaedte 95
Legal Clinics in Continental Western Europe: The Approach of the Utrecht
Legal Clinic on Conflict, Human Rights, and International Justice
Héctor Olasolo
A Comparative Look at Extraterritoriality: Bagram and Beyond
Introductory Remarks by:
Chiméne Keitner
Remarks by:
Kal Raustiala
Douglas Letter
Sabine Nolke
Ralph Wilde
Addendum: Some Cases and Commentary
Haiti: International Law and Disaster
Introductory Remarks by:
SN UD ssecisciiic tiniesshita can e nat ii 115
Remarks by:
Muzaffar Chishti
Disability-Inclusive Disaster Preparedness and Response: Challenges and
Opportunities for Reconstruction in Haiti
Janet E. Lord
Accounting for Haiti’s Children After the Earthquake: Immediate Needs with
Lifelong Consequences
FI ENE Gidiciteniecnnnciissiicsivisicinaiaibendiiibbabiitniienieseancbniitabinpaaniaiiiinibidieaniidiadeanaalibcalaa’
Hot Topics in GATS and Human Rights
Introduction
James Thuo Gathii
Trade in Services Agreements, the Financial Crisis, and Human
Rights Implications
Jane Kelsey
Temporary Movement of Workers and Human Rights Protection: Interfacing the
**Mode 4’’ of GATS with Non-Trade Bilateral Migration Agreements
Marion Panizzon
‘*Predatory Globalization’’: The WTO Agreement on Trade in Services,
Migration, and Public Health in Africa
Obijiofor Aginam
Providing Global Public Goods Under International Law
Global Public Goods: An Introduction
Rebecca M. Bratspies
Providing Public Goods Under International Law: Of Openness and Enclosure
Sabrina Safrin
Trust, Verify, or Incentivize? Effectuating Public International Law
Regulating Public Goods Through Market Mechanisms
Anne van Aaken
Women in International Law Interest Group Luncheon
Where I Sit and Where I Stand
Dinah Shelton
Afghanistan, Pakistan, and the Modern Challenges to Use of Force Law
Introductory Remarks by:
Mary Ellen O’Connell
Remarks by:
Paul Pillar
Hina Shamsi .
John Radsan
Evolving Intersections Between Treaty Law and Domestic Law
From Counterterrorism to Climate Change: Are Treaties Necessary to Solve
International Problems?
Andrew N. Keller
Are Treaties Always Necessary? How U.S. Domestic Law Can Give Teeth to
Non-Binding International Commitments
Mallory Stewart
Teaching and Practicing International Law in a Global Environment: Toward
a Common Language of International Law
Legal Education in the Twenty-First Century
Mahnoush H. Arsanjani
Teaching and Practicing International Law in a Global Environment:
Toward a Common Language of International Law
Rosalyn Higgins
The United Nations Audiovisual Library of International Law
I a clade cietapiemeccibaieolcaoidlai ti cctiaias
Keynote Address: The Obama Administration and International Law
I I a eae a ea
Arms Control Challenges Faced by the Obama Administration
Introductory Remarks by:
Michael Matheson
Remarks by:
SD inicac e dastbasitootnseetcseninanmnanscessicuaaieeaa aedsioataaetion
David Koplow
SNE iki cclacciclemunsiesniba uae tidbits ceanicamsiaaiaidaataiimnnint
Discussion
Corruption and Human Rights
Linking Corruption and Human Rights
Se I oils cicessncennsvestlinnataiacashandieniidinanatdssdiondidintetaseuhaantinishasbanemnassese ame
Making the Link Between Corruption and Human Rights: Promises and Perils
Joel M. Ngugi 246
Corruption and Human Rights: The Challenges of Mineral Resources Stewardship
L. Amede Obiora 250
International Environmental Justice: Possibilities, Limits, and Tensions
Introductory Remarks by:
UTEP CTUIIIIITIT\shusciciepiaiipnsniniisiuiteiinbiiiedaeirscaenoalnsj ittiiieen itiiaeh 255
International Law in a Time of Climate Change, Sovereignty Loss, and
Economic Unity
TE TO
New Voices II
Developing a New Structural Framework for Parties to an International Crime:
Toward a Capacious Concept of Principalship
a re ke 261
WTO Inconsistent Countermeasures—A View from the Outside
I TN I cscsnaicnsslsissgteat aiadaictan tieD ei haaa ai d 264
Justice Administration in Meheba Refugee Settlement: Refugee Perceptions,
Preferences, and Strategic Decisions
Se I vices cai al aaa 270
A Behavioral Approach to Human Rights
Te IIIT wsicienscitecisetsestt eeniiienisnpaiiicgsntiasibtaiteinetaliailacaaepietmeibiiidan csie s: SI
Same or Different? Bush and Obama Administration Approaches to Fighting Terrorists
The International Legal Framework for Fighting Terrorists According to the Bush
and the Obama Administrations: Same or Different, Correct or Incorrect?
III ici ahha ihcnaceiccaibnllaihnen saeciabieanedvildesi taema mbaaiendaaihaadi Aped es 277
Distinction with a Difference
Diane Marie Amann ssc ceiplimeiac again nkcont io enhblienleaphediaacadanedicaniaabeaaNeiaaanieealan 280
Preventing the Next Financial Crisis: Coordination and Competition in
Global Finance
Introductory Remarks by:
SILER RS OR TR RAE EIT OAL OTT RR CR eT 285
Crisis and Coordination: Regulatory Design in Financial Crises
RIES ROTTS seb hater Ne OA Ren nena Ce OER a air eS ORT ERA AE 286
Prospects for Coordination and Competition in Global Finance
IE, sic ceccetps sac nagstmhaica iorsu na age sheng ieta came lie deeanalaamcaaaia 289
The International Law of Financial Crisis?
SN ir. IID rit excensnisdvairad cicsiginscrasisicedibvob snl sasciensiatiibodlonademsuiiealapaalcbnaic leuiaelalteadpaeanie ” ae
Updating the Restatement
Introductory Remarks by:
NUNIT SIIIIINIED sessile leichmannii daaiuiaicamnmgeamanaataanilth 301
Remarks by:
I III 5... so cnses oaasinusabecnienebinedansnoaaanaaaciemeanaenebeoeebcamniaiabatanadianedhanmiaaaiaaie 302
Jurisdiction and Immunities in U.S. Foreign Relations Law
Te, See Ge I Bs I Sassi ccccseeintincneitncaceesisinsarnevinossnaseaioeataeds 307
Remarks by:
NINE 5 censssicicnussevasititenccdlgiecbemnideaaleeaabectanmabcbaameieaM paibeed mteaeaeaaaapeaoieateeein 311
BID sinssisictinitinicssrsteaiseiiasinacsieipititaceaiilinnsbedasaeiiiiieniniiinleliiamaistimnjasibalinuaiinaneaie 313
IID snissnvistisitsisssansrsnsennsucesnnindiptiussinlsesetbeniisbadbaihap hadaadisaidneitgatneitteeatdaaptauteiatdbe 315
Vii
Non-State Actors and the Emerging Climate Change Law Regime
Non-State Actor Access and Influence in International Legal and
Policy Negotiations
EN EEE EE Ee OC OREO TR ear Ae ee rE 325
The Rising Use of International Law by African Judiciaries
International Law and African Judiciaries: The Example of South Africa
EI TR OT OR ERT PF PERT a RO A ETE. 329
Domesticating International Law Through Truth and Reconciliation Commissions:
The Case of the Liberian TRC
pT A RB pce 28 a ne en ae Ed a OE EE EEE eae Le Ee aS 333
Reform and Restructuring at International Financial Institutions
Introductory Remarks by:
INS LE CS OPOET eR e EN MTT MER ee ee ene ENO
Remarks by:
CN Rare a ea LO NC A TA TORT TORN NT OTT eT TT PTT 340
I 342
CSS EEE OLE TATE ETRE TL ATPL EN ORE 343
CN IER See ee ATR RTE EE NE TE RR OE aE TEE TOT a 345
I NN ao sci Dacatiac li amma tanned aienaanaseae aaoaaenadials 346
EERE SEE Nae Ne SPT, ee Ce NNO te) a RON FOE A SO Rn ry ee 347
Creating and Building a ‘‘State’’: International Law and Kosovo
The Case of Kosovo: Self-Determination, Secession, and Statehood Under
International Law
Ih ha caapendeei aniseed banoceeebd nbeniaeaaaeisaae aan atEnies 361
Building the Rule of Law in Kosovo
EE 8 RE SIRE eA DOS EEE RPE eo Te ID 366
War and Law in Cyberspace
The Conduct of Hostilities in and via Cyberspace
FE EEE eee eae ee cee eee a ONE EE fe teen ae eek eee coe 371
Family, Sex, and Reproduction: Emerging Issues in International Law
Introductory Remarks by:
REE TEES SARS ee Ee ce OE ee a EN EET TS MR, es eoee me 375
Procedural Turn in Transnational Abortion Law
NE is IN goede chactienseren dees segcnaetaescuaaceeaolsphdisesesdasiiccanisdasnetneleedadammiatenmanmemiiean 377
Same-Sex Marriage, Transnational Activism, and International Law: Strategic
Objectives Beyond Freedom to Marry
RR ETI ERS EOE EN TT aR SFP nT a ee RELL 380
Maternal Mortality and Human Rights
BI IN cbinci sie sacsac acicpansteldbuminssticacdticsinadecsiabsbinnennsenicaniadannnmneininienbercecenttaapeecbaaoe 383
Sexual Rights and State Governance
IU naelenct ocd a elcaaeea amaseaeciianeneiatanaeoe 385
Theoretical Insights at the Margins of International Law: TWAIL and CRT
Introduction: Theoretical Insights from the Cutting Edge
TO ON a hee dcile erica onesie a Segunda aenanedanuiuesaunbeaie 389
The Danger of the New Legal Colonialism
i wie NINN IT, 2s aancaiigseebiniebdibbudasonanssnnchevsandeaeeestsdeuamenndnaeadiaies 393
Vili
Remembering Tom Franck: What He Taught Us About the Recourse to Force
The Recourse to Force by the United Nations: The Contributions of
Thomas M. Franck
Dan Sarooshi
Thomas Franck and the Use of Force
ares Ia IIE se icicle tcc esas bles aoa aaa oa areal 403
Remembering Tom Franck
Jordan Paust
ICSID in the Twenty-First Century: An Interview with Meg Kinnear
Introductory Remarks by:
David Caron
Remarks by:
Meg Kinnear
Implications of the Global Financial Crisis on International Trade and
Investment Regimes
Origins of the Financial Crisis and International/National Responses: An Overview
Chris Brummer
International Trade and the Financial Crisis
Elizabeth Trujillo
The Global Financial Crisis and International Investment Regimes
Jeffery P. Commission
The Impact of the Financial Crisis on Trade and Investment
Padideh Ala’i
Transnational Legal Dialogue, a Human Rights-Based Hierarchy, and the Creation
of Norms
Introductory Remarks by:
RN IN Ws cccicserii ancien suisancolieieicpaicaacaiipenlcasiiald empaiesissaaibauadepabcbisnenias iasciaiadadeaanidicmabitaaabe 453
The Prohibition on Torture: Driving Jus Cogens Home?
Pe IY isiicicctsicicicesussiteiscisishiictzaitbimnacneae snlieiib lcataaieiadgipaieiei e 454
National Security Versus Human Rights: An Uneven Playing Field
IN III dacsc eisicavsnescoriniecsnsecnassamntcteeunseepictownantnsibadobatannaghaanmaicetamsisabamaiaaidaasteacece 458
Bottom-Up Constitutionalization of International Law: The Targeted Sanctions
Regime as a Case Study
BITTE scnscoscisenisinsic:ieeteiacieiibehicandiiaehniaiianindeanaeaeahatibaleaaiibpielaineedii 462
The Future of Transnational Judicial Dialogue
Melissa A. Waters
Bottom-Up Strategies for Survival and Resistance: Examples from Latin
America and Elsewhere
Good Bananas, Bad Bananas: Hard Lessons from a Soft War
Ibrahim Gassama
Guantanamo as Subordination: Detainees as Resisting Empire
Ernesto Hernandez-Lopez
Manley O. Hudson Medal Lecture
On Being Accountable in a Kaleidoscopic World
Edith Brown Weiss
Keynote Address: The Use of Foreign Law—A Comparative View of Canada
and the United States
Presented by:
Beverley McLachlin
ASIL Annual Dinner: Reflections on Change in International Law
Introductory Remarks by:
Lucy F. Reed
Remarks by:
David D. Caron
Stephen Schwebel
Edith Brown Weiss
BR SL ee ee Fee ee ee en Ne MN Snr irs Ieee 500
0 | EEE NOTE TT a PEE SERENE NITE oe ETT REET ET ETT 501
a ac fhe lete ead enka ae Sains 502
Charles N. Brower . 503
FR Ee nc aI ne a a eR Eee eRe eee tee 503
(SRE rR EE RP RE PE ee nn RE RE RTECS a TOS 504
EET OR ora TE COOTER RR Ee eRe Ue eere e 505
ES A RR I RE MEE TOI Ns en nN seb near 506
RT eee eT TE ee RE EO TEE PERT oF eRe TeE RROR Fe 507
The ICC Review Conference and Changing U.S. Policy Toward the Court
Introductory Remarks by:
RSC RAE RE Rist cee rer eee eR eee Te TR RTE EME Te IES Ay Meee eon eae 509
Remarks by:
BISCO on CERO re PC Re MRE sn Oe Eee Re 510
The Office of the Prosecutor, the ICC Review Conference, and the Way Forward
rE IS 7 salons dh nensnptu vactlbeneslsndahitbebiumennaaavaabauniamndeoeahts :
Remarks by:
Stephen Rapp
I ihlal ciia Ai eMC NN
China and East Asia on the World Stage
The Socialization of China, Japan, and Korea (CJK) in International Economic
Law: Assessment and Implications
Saadia Pekkanen
China on the World Stage: A Trade Law Perspective
The Road Forward from Copenhagen: Climate Change Policy in the 21st Century
Introductory Remarks by:
K. Russell LaMotte
Remarks by:
Daniel Bodansky
Jeffrey M. Klein
Ann Petsonk
Advancing Women’s Rights Internationally
Constituting Terms for International Change: Reflecting on Strategies for
Women’s Rights
PU MRI, acctthiictaicasnasuintbsncnanancdinecctionsatsuiil osaslaiaiiooseneatoruorenaicl oaems aimaibuhessmtmauadsibease s 561
Lessons from the Cotton Field Case About Gender Justice
Advancing Women’s Rights in Conflict and Post-Conflict Situations
PIII, CINE UNTIIIIIITEN cvsnisa::éciunssconinnicaeheeahiceamtisnsedn daeiaritahiatttmdacandiinniceaeliidnitnbeiits 568
Treaty Bodies and Beyond: The Practice and Process of Translating
International Norms into Domestic Law
Introductory Remarks by:
eI 5cicin 1s scutes cascades at ponea abasaeeese Seasia emiaavaadentaaaeamaedeuesitaces 571
Iterative Engagements: The European Union and International Normativity
SR I cts 5cscasisoncatecnenietoniewnssuiachsernaascuersacvbiacesidanataiaileseadaliedaslincsimedbuisaial 572
The International Labor Organization and the Translation of International
Norms into Domestic Law
SP I I abies cisckisssancina senrsesneginit ack denaeonimaenkan ues emsadeiliaensdatesae tanan abanaaaaeai 576
Poster Sessions
Judicial Review by EU and Domestic Courts of the Al Qaeda and Taliban Sanctions
Regime: Counterterrorism, Due Process, and the Search for the Golden Mean
I icine senile enbseeaiecianidaatacagalaidigaiitiondids 581
Releasing Captured Documents
IIR ictbloateda tama egtoldaavinn +c adanenpba laaiaiakaseeiann 584
Laboratory of the International Community? Role of International Organizations in
the Re-establishment of the Rule of Law in Kosovo
IN I isan ve icernstinsncdccasbciconilanecutiantjeensssaiiel eaaiseahdeadna sshieea itosnineemieaaisnaht s 588
International Arbitration in Times of Change: Fairness and Transparency in
Investor-State Disputes
ES RI AE OE RI TIE SN REE EN te ore TT 591
104th Annual Meeting Theme Statement and Program ........c.csccccscsesesseeseesenssessnseseeeenes 597
Fifty-First Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition
Appendices
Minutes of the ASIL Annual General Meeting
os 5c cscecssnssaeciggbaaccsa shine etre asain linaliialhcbdpagiee dish dea RAR 635
ASIL Officers and Executive Council
American Journal of International Law
IN MA III oc sseicnsiicansivonnstncxvssdcsabnsicontiphenesakonsbienkassnnnaeiieesoioiuaiaaennasr h 641
Se I INET INNES NOIIIINID naciiinesccenscsessseiseenreenciicinstictensieiisinseetninnniiesieciiiatcnianstbiaagid 642