Amateur Astronomy M a g a z i n e The Essential Journal for Amateur Astronomers Around the World! How To Create A Beautiful Time Lapse Tips and techniques from author Alan Dyer Merging Images in a Binoscope Star People Get to know Pranvera Hyseni from Kosovo Imaging Venus in Ultraviolet Light Observing Deep Sky Treasures Unobserved Nebulae Focus on the Moon Looking South Sunspots Four Lessons in Optics From Master Mirror Maker Mike Lockwood Issue 86 Spring 2015 $6.50 US 2 www.AmateurAstronomy.com Spring 2015 Issue # 86 Amateur Astronomy Managing Editor: Charlie Warren Contributing Editors: Robert Reeves, John Davis, Harry Roberts, Howard Banich, Scott Rosen, Mike Smith, Tom Clark Webmaster: Charlie Warren Amateur Astronomy is published quarterly by Charlie Warren (615)-332-5555 Mailing address: 511 Derby Downs, Lebanon, TN 37087 E-Mail: [email protected] Web Site: http://www.AmateurAstronomy.com Copyright 2015by Charlie Warren. All rights reserved. Material in this publication may not be reproduced in any manner without written permission from the editor. The opinions expressed in this magazine are not necessarily those of the publisher or editors. Postmaster: Send address changes to Amateur Astronomy, 511 Derby Downs, Lebanon, TN 37087 Subscription Rates: See chart on page 4. Please see our Author’s Guidelines email us for a copy or visit our website “Article and Image Submission Guidelines. Please email your articles as an attachment (MS Word, PDF or plain Text). For larger articles with a substantial number of digital photos, please send on a CD or DVD to our mail address. AA is produced on a Dell computer using Quark Xpress, Photoshop, MS Studio Suite and Adobe Studio Suite. There are no deadlines - articles are run in the order received ASAP. Photos will be returned if requested. Addresses of authors will be printed unless otherwise requested. Preference is made for those articles received electronically by email, disk, CD or DVD Mailing dates are approximately: Winter (1/1), Spring (4/1), Summer (7/1), Fall (10/1). Delivery takes up to four weeks in the USA. In this issue: Our Star Supporters Cover: Image Alan Dyer - see details on page 6 OPT Oceanside Photo & Telescope Back cover Celestron - page 2, 35 4 Editorial ScopeStuff - page 4 7 Short Subjects Sky Watcher - page 5 10 Merging Images in a Binoscope - Arie Otte Eyepieces Etc. - page 8 16 Unobserved Nebulae- Mel Bartels Howie Glatter’s Lasers- page 15 20 Focus On The Moon with Robert Reeves Jack’s Astro - page 19 22 Shorts From Down Under - Mike Smith Replacement Eyepiece Caps page 25 24 On The Moon - Harry Roberts Equatorial Platforms - page 26 26 Star Party and Astronomical Events Calendar Meade Instruments page 31, 71 28 Deep Sky Treasures Spring Galaxies John Davis Space Images.com- page 42 RSpec Spectroscopy - page 42 36 Star People - Pranvera Hyseni by Robert Reeves Charlie Bates Astronomy - page 45 40 Imaging Venus in Ultraviolet Lightby Rick Schrantz Nightscapes & Time Lapses page 56 44 Creating a Solar Mosaic - by Craig & Tammy Temple 21 Years of Amateur Astronomy page 57 46 How to Process Time Lapses by Alan Dyer Catseye Collimation System page 70 58 Sunspots by Harry Roberts HoTech- page 71 60 Four Lessons in Mirror Testing - by Mike Lockwood 72 Parting Shots Astro men and women Please thank our sponsors for supporting AA and support them in return!! Don’t forget to mention that you saw their advertise- ment here. They are some of the good guys in this hobby who make this publication possible. Spring 2015 Issue # 86 www.AmateurAstronomy.com 3 Editorial comments and updates from the Editor Our Star Person this issue is a young college student from Kosovo who has been making waves through her efforts to expand astrono- my awareness and education in that country. I think you will be inspired by what she has been able to accomplish with fairly limited resources (initially). I believe we will be hearing more from Ms. Hyseni in the future as her passion for astronomy and outreach will undoubtably reach beyond her countries borders. We are starting a new series entitled “Focus on the Moon with Robert Reeves”. If you have been reading this magazine for any peri- od of time, or been anywhere in proximity to Robert, you know that he is not only a lunar enthusiast, but also truly an expert on lunar I features and techniques to image the moon. n this issue we have two feature length articles. Most Robert will showcase two areas each issue with high resolu- publications simply do not have the editorial license to tion images and descriptions of the lunar terrain selected. run articles that are 10-11 pages long, but I felt that both of these articles deserved not only the space allocated, but I first met Rick Schrantz about 10 years ago at the Chiefland would suffer if split into multiple parts. The cover story is astronomy village, and would catch up with him frequently by Alan Dyer. I have been a fan of Alan’s writing for a while thereafter at the Winter Star Parties. Rick is a very focused and his new iBook on Time Lapse is a tremendous resource planetary imager. He constructed a telescope particularly for so I asked him if he would give us a short course for AA. He that purpose. Three years ago at WSP he was imaging using graciously agreed. Time lapse and “Nightscapes” are ultraviolet filters, and explained that he was getting particu- becoming even more popular of late and with good reason. larly good results with Venus. He had promised an article for From an astrophotography standpoint, they are not nearly as some time and finally delivered. Venus is not an easy imag- investment intensive, the learning curve is much faster and ing target, but Rick has found a way to extract nice detail by the new DSLRs are remarkably capable of producing high imaging with an ultraviolet filter. His results are some of the quality content. If you have not tried it yet, I encourage you best I have seen from an amateur. to read the article and give it a go. If you have as much fun as I think you will have, get Alan’s iBook and learn how to We ran a couple of articles comparing mono mirror scopes be a pro at it. with bino scopes. Arie Ott tackles the challenge of getting images to converge in a binoscope so that owners can get the Our second feature article is by master mirror maker Mike most out of their instruments in his article with practical Lockwood. For those who know Mike, it is not news that he solutions. can be a bit obsessive about the quality of his mirror’s continued on page 6 optics. He is an engineer by education and trade so his approach to solving problems is quite thorough and method- ical. It is fun to watch him in action diagnosing problems. In this article, he goes through the process of testing a 28” mir- ror that was reported as having optical issues. I promise you will learn a lot about the optics of your mirror by following his search for the cause. Photo Caption Correction (issue 85): I was delighted to read Tom Clark's account of the Oregon Star Party in issue #85 of Amateur Astronomy, and to see my binocular scope featured so prominently on page 13. Unfortunately the caption for the four photos on that page attributes all of the scopes to me, whereas the two photos on the left are of Frank Szczepanski's binocular scopes. Thanks, Jerry Oltion 4 www.AmateurAstronomy.com Spring 2015 Issue # 86 Spring 2015 Issue # 86 www.AmateurAstronomy.com 5 Cover Photo Details: The Milky Way over Athabasca Glacier and the Columbia Icefields in Jasper National Park, Sept 14, 2014 on a very clear night before moonrise. The centre of the Galaxy area in Sagittarius is set- ting in the southwest behind the Icefields. The foreground light on the moraines is wash from lights on the Glacier View Inn and Icefields Centre. Other ground illumination on the peaks is from starlight though the tops of the peaks are just being lit by light from the rising waning Moon which is also beginning to light the sky a deep blue. Mt. Andromeda is at left. The Summer Triangle stars are at center. This is a composite of 5 shots, tracked, for the sky, blended in Lighten mode and 4 shots, untracked, for the ground, blended in Mean combine mode to reduce noise. The trailed sky is masked out of the ground shots and the trailed ground is masked out of the sky shots, so both ground and sky are sharp but the sky has the benefit of the longer exposures required to really bring out Milky Way details. Each sky shot was 3 minutes and each ground shot was 4 minutes, all at f/3.2 with the 15mm lens and filter-modified Canon 5D MkII at ISO 1600. Tracked on the Sky-Watcher Star Adventurer, with the drive turned off for the ground images at the end of the sky exposures. Mel Bartels is a very accomplished telescope maker with a astronomers I meet are about 4 to 1 female. From interaction long history of innovative approach. In his article with amateur astronomers online, I have been astounded at “Unobserved Nebula” he presents some challenging objects the growth in interest in some other countries, India in par- for you to attempt with a rich field telescope, but also an ticular, but many others as well. Our Star Person this month interesting alternative to using multiple eyepieces. Check out is just one example. That makes sense as many countries are his logic to the concept of “one eyepiece, multiple scopes”. becoming increasingly modernized with countries like China and India yielding a larger percentage of the population with On my Facebook page and on several other online venues disposable income and accessible technology. there have been some interesting conversations about whether the hobby of astronomy is dying or growing stale. I would love to hear more about your thoughts and experi- The evidence was the apparent lack of diversity and advanc- ence on this topic and invite you to write me (editor@ama- ing age of the average amateur astronomer. If I were to draw teurastronomy.com), particularly about youth and astrono- a conclusion based on our subscribers, which are predomi- my. I would also like to profile more of our up and coming nantly male and predominantly ages 45-75, I would come to young astronomy enthusiasts, so send some suggested can- that conclusion as well. There is no question that amateur didates. I know they are out there and it behooves each of us astronomy requires some disposable income, and astropho- to participate in activities that will encourage engagement of tography a significant amount more, but there is also some the next generation of amateur astronomers. From the brief very affordable technology currently available. questionnaires that we send to each new subscriber, a very large percentage had experiences at an early age that initiat- The interesting demographic and exception to this are a ed their interest, which they later had time and resources to growing number of new subscribers who are 18-25 and pursue in greater depth. mostly female. That matches what I am seeing at outreach Clear skies! Charlie. events as well. In the United States, the younger amateur Amateur Astronomy Magazine Subscription Information: Single issues – $7 for a sample issue pp in the US. $8 to Canada and $12 to others outside the continental US. 1-Year rate Two Year rate USA subscriptions $24 $44 Canada - first class $32 $60 Mexico - first class $38 $72 Overseas - airmail $55 $110 Electronic PDF $18 $35 Dual Print & pdf - add $10 $16 to any of the print subs All Credit cards are accepted on our website, or if you prefer, you can call in your order to our office (615-332-5555) anytime. You can also print the online form and send in your check or credit card payment to 511 Derby Downs, Lebanon, TN 37087 Your subscription will start with the current issues unless stated otherwise. Subscribe or renew today at www.amateurastronomy.com 6 www.AmateurAstronomy.com Spring 2015 Issue # 86 SShhoorrtt SSuubbjjeeccttss THINGS YOU REALLY OUGHT TO 12.Murphy's Law of Lockers - If there are black holes, and all large galaxies have one. KNOW...Laws not taught in Physics... only 2 people in a locker room, they will The one at the center of our galaxy, the have adjacent lockers. Milky Way, is called Sagittarius A* (or, Sgr 1 .Law of Mechanical Repair - After your A*, as it is called), and scientists estimate 13. Law of Physical Surfaces - The chances hands become coated with grease, your that it contains about four and a half million of an open-faced jelly sandwich landing nose will begin to itch. times the mass of our Sun. face down on a floor are directly correlated 2. Law of Gravity - Any tool, nut, bolt, to the newness and cost of the carpet or rug. Scientists working with Chandra have screw, when dropped, will roll to the least observed Sgr A* repeatedly since the tele- 14.Law of Logical Argument - Anything is accessible place in the universe. scope was launched into space in 1999. possible IF you don't know what you are Haggard and fellow astronomers were orig- 3. Law of Probability - The probability of talking about. inally using Chandra to see if Sgr A* would being watched is directly proportional to the consume parts of a cloud of gas, known as 15. Law of Physical Appearance - If the stupidity of your act. G2. clothes fit, they're ugly. 4.Law of Random Numbers - If you dial a “Unfortunately, the G2 gas cloud didn’t pro- 16.Law of Public Speaking -- A CLOSED wrong number, you never get a busy signal; duce the fireworks we were hoping for MOUTH GATHERS NO FEET! someone always answers. when it got close to Sgr A*,” she said. 17.Law of Commercial Marketing Strategy “However, nature often surprises us and we 5. Variation Law - If you change lines (or - As soon as you find a product that you real- saw something else that was really excit- traffic lanes), the one you were in will ly like, they will stop making it OR the store ing.” always move faster than the one you are in will stop selling it! now. Haggard and her team detected an X-ray 18. Doctors' Law - If you don't feel well, outburst last September that was 400 times 6.Law of the Bath - When the body is fully make an appointment to go to the doctor, by brighter than the usual X-ray output from immersed in water, the telephone will ring. the time you get there, you'll feel better. But Sgr A*. This “megaflare” was nearly three 7.Law of Close Encounters - The probabil- don't make an appointment and you'll stay times brighter than the previous record hold- ity of meeting someone you know sick. er that was seen in early 2012. A second INCREASES dramatically when you are enormous X-ray flare, 200 times brighter with someone you don't want to be seen If you don't share this with at least 5 of your than Sgr A* in its quiet state, was observed with. friends, your belly button will unscrew. with Chandra on October 20, 2014. Really... It's true. I read it on the Internet! 8 .Law of the Result - When you try to prove Haggard and her team have two main ideas to someone that a machine won't work, IT about what could be causing Sgr A* to erupt WILL !!! in this extreme way. One hypothesis is that the gravity of the supermassive black hole Amherst College Astronomy 9 .Law of Biomechanics - The severity of has torn apart a couple of asteroids that wan- the itch is inversely proportional to the Professor Detects Record-Breaking dered too close. The debris from such a reach. Black Hole Outburst “tidal disruption” would become very hot Last September, after years of watching, a and produce X-rays before disappearing for- 10.Law of the Theater & Hockey Arena - team of scientists led by Amherst College ever across the black hole’s point of no At any event, the people whose seats are fur- astronomy professor Daryl Haggard return (called the “event horizon”). thest from the aisle, always arrive last. They observed and recorded the largest-ever flare are the ones who will leave their seats sev- in X-rays from a supermassive black hole at “If an asteroid was torn apart, it would go eral times to go for food, beer, or the toilet the center of the Milky Way. The astronom- around the black hole for a couple of hours and who leave early before the end of the ical event, which was detected by NASA’s – like water circling an open drain – before performance or the game is over. The folks Chandra X-ray Observatory, puts the scien- falling in,” said colleague and co-principal in the aisle seats come early, never move tific community one step closer to under- investigator Fred Baganoff of the once, have long gangly legs or big bellies standing the nature and behavior of super- Massachusetts Institute of Technology in and stay to the bitter end of the performance. massive black holes. Cambridge, MA. “That’s just how long we The aisle people also are very surly folk. saw the brightest X-ray flare last, so that is Haggard and her colleagues discussed the an intriguing clue for us to consider.” 11. The Coffee Law - As soon as you sit flare today at a press conference during this down to a cup of hot coffee, your boss will year’s meeting of the American If that theory holds up, it means astronomers ask you to do something which will last until Astronomical Society in Seattle. have found evidence for the largest asteroid the coffee is cold. ever to be torn apart by the Milky Way’s Supermassive black holes are the largest of black hole. Spring 2015 Issue # 86 www.AmateurAstronomy.com 7 and the Chandra data are allowing near-infrared data collected by the European Another, different idea is that the magnetic astronomers to better understand this unusu- Southern Observatory’s survey VISTA to field lines within the material flowing al object. find four young stars approximately towards Sgr A* are packed incredibly tight- 300,000 light years away. These young stars ly. If this were the case, these field lines As for the G2: Astronomers estimate that the are Cepheid variables–“standard candles” would occasionally interconnect and recon- gas cloud made its closest approach—still that astronomers use to measure distances. figure themselves. When this happens, their about 15 billion miles away from the edge According to Chakrabarti, these are the magnetic energy is converted into the ener- of the black hole—in the spring of 2014. most distant Cepheid variables found close gy of motion, heat and the acceleration of The researchers estimate the record break- to the plane of the Milky Way. The paper particles—which could produce a bright X- ing X-ray flares were produced about a hun- announcing the discovery appears in ray flare. Such magnetic flares are seen on dred times closer to the black hole, making Astrophysical Journal Letters and is avail- the Sun, and the Sgr A* flares have a simi- it very unlikely that the Chandra flares were able online. lar pattern of brightness levels to the solar associated with G2. events. The stars appear to be associated with a dwarf galaxy Chakrabarti predicted in 2009 “At the moment, we can’t distinguish Lifting the veil on a dark galaxy based on her analysis of ripples in the Milky between these two very different ideas,” said Findings validate earlier prediction of Way’s outer disk. Chakrabarti’s earlier study Haggard. “It’s exciting to identify tensions galaxy’s location predicted the location of the dark-matter between models and to have a chance to A cluster of young, pulsating stars discov- dominated dwarf galaxy. Radiation emitted resolve them with present and future obser- ered in the far side of the Milky Way may by the Cepheid variable stars allowed her to vations.” mark the location of a previously unseen derive accurate distances and test her pre- In addition to the giant flares, Haggard and dark-matter dominated dwarf galaxy hidden diction. Chakrabarti analyzed VISTA’s data- her team also collected more data on a mag- behind clouds of dust. base of tens of millions of stars to find these clustered Cepheid variables in the Norma netar—a neutron star with a strong magnet- A team, led by Sukanya Chakrabarti from constellation, all within one degree of each ic field—located close to Sgr A*. This mag- Rochester Institute of Technology, analyzed other. netar is undergoing a long X-ray outburst, 8 www.AmateurAstronomy.com Spring 2015 Issue # 86 “These young stars are likely the signature of this predicted galaxy,” said Chakrabarti, assistant professor in RIT’s School of Physics and Astronomy. “They can’t be part of our galaxy because the disk of the Milky Way terminates at 48,000 light years.” Invisible particles known as dark matter make up 23 percent of the mass of the uni- verse. The mysterious matter represents a fundamental problem in astronomy because it is not understood, Chakrabarti said. “The discovery of the Cepheid variables shows that our method of finding the loca- tion of dark-matter dominated dwarf galax- ies works,” she said. “It may help us ulti- mately understand what dark matter is made up of. It also shows that Newton’s theory of gravity can be used out to the farthest reach- es of a galaxy, and that there is no need to modify our theory of gravity.” Rosette Nebula - Charlie Warren VISTA’s infrared eyes allow scientists to world. In the 1930’s two of the first to study object usually seen only at infrared and radio study unexplored regions close to the galac- these forming stars were George Herbig and wavelengths is, because of these special cir- tic plane that are inaccessible to optical sur- Guillermo Haro. The structures with oppo- cumstances, visible in our amateur tele- veys. Optical wavelengths cannot penetrate sitely directed jets ending in lobes visible scopes. An interesting consequence in this the dust and gas in these regions. This next- through their interaction with the surround- case is, because of these dispersing winds, generation sky survey helps scientists look at ing nebula were named after them: Herbig- the future star of HH1 may evolve to be less the structure of the galaxy and distant stars at Haro objects. The nascent stellar object at massive and we could be witnessing a low latitudes. Infrared surveys may help their centers is surrounded by a protoplane- process associated with brown dwarf forma- resolve current discrepancies between obser- tary disc, with material accumulating within tion. On a clear spring evening take a look vations and the current cosmological para- their cores until hydrogen fusion occurs from for this rare glimpse into star birth. digm by giving us a more complete view of the heat and pressure. When they are unable Rosette HH1: 06h 32m 20.79s, +04d 53m the structure of the Milky Way, Chakrabarti to accommodate all the gas and dust, a pair 03.3s; magnitude 14.0 said. of bipolar jets are produced perpendicular to Rector, ApJ Letters, December, 2003. the accreting disc. With large reflecting tele- “I decided to see if I could actually find the ApJ 659, p. 1373, April 20, 2007. scopes I have glimpsed the outer lobes of thing,” Chakrabarti said. “It was a difficult Dave Tosteson several of these “HH” objects but, in almost prediction to test because it was close to the Chisago City, Minnesota all cases the central structures are not visible plane, and therefore difficult to see in the [email protected] because of a thick shell of obscuring materi- optical. This new survey, VISTA, was able to al. An exception exists within the beautiful help us to lift the veil and see these young Rosette Nebula (NGC 2237) in Monoceros, pulsating stars.” known as Rosette HH1. Travis Rector of the University of Alaska, Star Birth Anchorage, studied this unihorned ungulate in 2003, and noted it as one of the few, or possibly only, times this type of stellar for- The process of star birth is one usually mation called a protostar, and its jet, are shrouded in mystery behind a veil of secrecy, directly visible. The reason we are able to see covered in layers of opaque dust and gas and it appears that nearby stars surrounding HH1 hidden from curious eyes sensitive to only use powerful stellar winds to disperse mate- the visible light cocooned within. rial normally hiding it from our view. In Astronomers with instruments sensitive to essence, we are witnessing a premature radio and infrared wavelengths have been delivery. At 14th magnitude, it is bright able to study this process, but amateurs lim- enough to be viewed in my 10 inch telescope ited to visual photons are restricted, as grand- and, from my home several years ago parents at a human nursery, to meeting the through my 15” newborn after the initial process is conclud- ed and the infant is presented to the rest of the reflector, its jet was not difficult to spot. An Spring 2015 Issue # 86 www.AmateurAstronomy.com 9 Practical Solutions and Guidelines for the Merging Images in a Binoscope . by Arie Otte T he term binoscope is often images, one entire, physical half of the lenging. Specifically, when you move reserved for a Newtonian tele- binoscope is slightly tilted in relation the ‘half-binoscope’ up and down, scope with one mirror for each to the other half of the binoscope. In images are more prone to ‘de-merge’, eye. Experienced observers claim that other words, the binoscope contains an since chances are that there is some observing with a binoscope is superior entire telescope (consisting of the pri- remaining play in the system. Indeed, to observing with a traditional ‘mono- mary, secondary and tertiary mirrors) in my hands there always remained telescope’ that has a comparably large, that can move independently within residual play in the threaded rods I but only one mirror. However, despite the space of the larger, encompassing used and that resulted in some separa- this advantage, binoscopes are not binoscope mirror box. I built such a tion of the images when moving the popular, presumably because they are set-up and it works very nicely scope up and down. difficult to make. But is this true? (Picture 1, the right 'telescope' can Merging of the images by tilting the Probably one of the most difficult fea- move a bit). The main advantage of primary mirrors tures of making a binoscope is the this method is that the quality of the I therefore opted for another procedure need to precisely merge the images. images is not compromised by de-col- that involves bringing together the Here I present different aspects of limation, since no collimation of the optical paths by means of slightly tilt- merging images and provide practical primary mirror is involved. ing the primary mirrors. This implies solutions on how these can be ade- Image 1: The right mirror box can that one moves the optical paths only, quately addressed. This article intends move independently from the rest of instead of an entire, physical, 'half- to show that an ATM person who can the binoscope. The arrows indicate the binoscope'. However, tinkering with build a mono-Dobsonian telescope ends of threaded rods that run through primary mirrors almost certainly will also be able to build a good func- the bottom of the larger binoscope mir- results in de-collimation of these mir- tioning binoscope. ror box. By slightly turning them, the rors. The result may very well be that The two independent optical systems mirror box (and with that of course the one obtains well-merged images, but of a binoscope have to produce two rest of the telescope that is built on it) these are at least slightly degraded images that are both well collimated moves in relation to the other half of because the optical paths are out of and accurately merged at the same the binoscope. By doing this, the collimation. Some binoscope owners time. In principle, merging is nothing images can be merged. take this for granted and accept the de- other than ensuring that the optical collimated images as a fact of life. It is, The disadvantage of this approach is paths of the two telescopes are brought however, very possible to achieve that the system is mechanically chal- together to create overlapping images. both: accurately merged images that If all parts of the two optical paths would be perfectly collimated and aligned, if all the angles of the scope Image 1 would be perfectly square, if all mir- rors (primary, secondary and tertiary) and the focusers would be centered perfectly, then the images would also be well-collimated and merged. Alas, no such thing as perfect exists, so images will probably initially not be perfectly collimated and will not be merged. There are two main approach- es to merge two well-collimated images: 1) you move one half of the binoscope in relation to the other half or 2) you only move the two optical paths in order to overlap each other. I’ve followed both approaches. Merging of the images by tilting an entire half of the binoscope In the first approach to merge the two 10 www.AmateurAstronomy.com Spring 2015 Issue # 86
Description: