Agri-Culture Reconnecting People, nd Nature Jules Pretty This is for Gill, Freya and Theo and for Mum and Dad for the pictures and advice and time too for a mention for Chris, Dawn, Fern, Joss, Tom and William; Annabel, Mike, Jasper and Felix; Pat and John Agri-Culture Reconnecting People; Land and Nature Jules Pretty raaigiifflHHaigi Earthscan Publications Limited London • Sterling, VA First published in the UK and USA in 2002 by Earthscan Publications Ltd Copyright © Jules Pretty, 2002 All rights reserved ISBN: I 85383 925 6 paperback I 85383 920 5 hardback Typesetting by JS Typesetting Ltd, Wellingborough, Northants Printed and bound in the UK by Creative Print and Design (Wales), Ebbw Vale Cover design by Adrian Senior Cover illustration by John R Pretty For a full list of publications please contact: Earthscan Publications Ltd 120 Pentonville Road, London, NI 9JN, UK Tel: +44 (0)20 7278 0433 Fax: +44 (0)20 7278 1142 Email: [email protected] Web: www.carthscan.co.uk 22883 Quicksilver Drive, Sterling, VA 20166-2012, USA Earthscan is an editorially independent subsidiary of Kogan Page Ltd and publishes in association with WWF-UK and the International Institute for Environment and Development A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Pretty, Jules N. Agri-culture : reconnecting people, land and nature / by Jules Pretty, p. cm. Includes bibliographical references (p. ). ISBN 1-85383-925-6 (pbk.) - ISBN 1-85383-920-5 (hardback) I. Sustainable agriculture. 2. Agriculture—Social aspects. 3. Agricultural productivity. I. Title. S494.5.S86 P73 2002 333.76T6—dc21 2002009735 This book is printed on elemental chlorine free paper Contents Acknowledgements vi Glossary of Specialist Terms viii Preface to a Revolution xi 1 Landscapes Lost and Found I 2 Monoscapes 27 3 Reality Cheques 52 4 Food for All 78 5 Only Reconnect 102 6 The Genetics Controversy 126 7 Ecological Literacy 146 8 Crossing the Internal Frontiers 170 Notes 18 9 References 221 Index 254 A ck nowledgem ents I am very grateful to the many people who provided invaluable critical comment on earlier drafts of this book and advice on related material. I would like to make special mention of Ted Benton, James Morison and Norman Uphoff, who went well beyond the call of duty, together with Curtis Absher, Jacqui Ashby, Richard Aylard, Neil Baker, Andy Ball, David Beckingsale, Phil Bradley, Lynda Brown, Susanne and Simon Campbell- Jones, Robert Chambers, Nigel Cooper, Ed Cross, Jan Deane, John Devavaram, Amadou Diop, Tom Dobbs, David Favis-Mortlock, Bruce Frank, Phil and Susie Grice, Julia Guivant, Jilly Hall, John Hall, Brian Halweil, Hal Hamilton, Justin Hardy, Sue Heisswolf, Rachel Hine, Ian Hutchcroft, J K Kiara, John Landers,Tim Lang, Howard Lee, David Lort- Phillips, Simon Lyster, Joe Morris, Phil Mullineaux, Eri Nakajima, Hiltrud Nieberg, Kevin Niemever, David Orr, Roberto Peiretti, Michel Pimbert.Tim O’Riordan, Mark Ritchie, Colin Samson, Pedro Sanchez, Sara Scherr, Dorothy and Walter Schwarz, Mardie Townsend, Hugh Ward, Drennan Watson, Jane Weissman, MarkWinne, andVo-Tong Xuan.The views represented here are, of course, all my own responsibility, as are the mistakes. As ever, I am grateful to Jonathan Sinclair Wilson, and to Akan Leander and all at Earthscan, for valuable support and advice, and to Marie Chan for administrative support. The illustrations in this book, including the cover painting from northern Nigeria, are all painted by John R Pretty who is a professional painter specializing in marine and landscape watercolours of East Anglia and France. He is a member of the East Anglian Group of Marine Artists with whom he exhibits at the Mall Gallery in London, and he has been guest of honour at various Salons in France, being the recipient of ten medals for watercolour. He has exhibited at the Royal Society of Marine Artists and the National Society of Painters, Sculptors and Printmakers, and, in France, at the Gallerie du Musee, Les Baux-de-Provence, and the Salon of the Societe International des Beaux Arts Paris and in Salons at Parfav Acknowledgements vjj Mosley, Le Poingonnet,Tinchebray, Argenton-sur-Creuse and Mongermont. Annually, he exhibits at the Salon du Val d’Or of the Association Inter nationale Plastica Latina, with the Merite Artistique Europeen France, at the Salon in St Florent-sur-Cher, where he is a member, and at the Salon des Amis de Montemartre, Issoudun. His work is also in collections in Europe, America, New Zealand and South Africa, and can be seen at www.johnrpretty.co.uk. Glossary of Specialist Terms Terms that appear in the glossary are italicized on their first mention in each chapter of the text. Adat Indigenous cultural knowledge and rules system of Indonesia and Malaysia Agroecology Ecological relationships in agricultural systems Antimicrobial Substance toxic to microbes and administered to (also antibiotic) humans and livestock Apomixis The production of exact clones of the mother plant through asexual reproduction Autopoiesis Self-organizing and self-made character of living systems Bioregionalism Integration of human activities within ecological limits Biotechnology Molecular changes to living or non-living things, involving the transfer of DNA from one organism to another, allowing the recipient to express new characteristics Carbon Capturing or locking up of carbon dioxide from sequestration the atmosphere in sinks (eg soils, trees) CBD Convention on Biological Diversity Cloning The production of individuals with an exact copy of the DNA of another organism Common property Resources used in common by a defined group of resource people, usually with locally developed rules for their use Cryptosporidium Pathogenic organism arising from domestic livestock and wild animals, and pollutant of water Glossary of Specialist Terms jx CSA Community-supported agriculture farm DFID Department for International Development (UK) Diverscape An ecologically and/or socially diverse landscape Enclosure The changing of large commonly managed open (also inclosure) fields in Europe to produce smaller individually owned fields enclosed by hedges or other boundaries ESA Environmentally sensitive area Eutrophication Nutrient enrichment of water that leads to excessive algal growth, disruption of whole food webs and, in the worst cases, complete eradication of all life through deoxygenation Extensionist Agricultural professional in regular contact with both farmers and researchers Externality Any action that affects the welfare of, or opportunities available to, an individual or group without direct payment or compensation, and may be positive or negative I;AO Food and Agriculture Organization (UN) Fen Grassland by river, occasionally flooded Food security Access to sufficient food of appropriate diversity for a healthy diet Foodshed Self-reliant, locally or regionally based food systems comprised of diversified farms using sustainable practices to which consumers are linked by the bonds of community as well as economy GM Genetically modified Hectare Measure of area equivalent to 2.47 acres HFS Hartford Food System (US) ICIPE International Centre for Insect Physiology and Ecology IFPRI International Food Policy Research Institute Integrated pest The use of a variety of methods and approaches management to manage pests and diseases, usually minimizing or even eliminating pesticide use