Across the aisle: opposition in Canadian politics PDF
Preview Across the aisle: opposition in Canadian politics
ACROSS THE AISLE Opposition in Canadian Politics How do parties with official opposition status influence Canadian poli- tics? Across the Aisle is an innovative examination of the theory and practice of opposition in Canada, both in Parliament and in provincial legislatures. Extending from the pre-Confederation era to the present day, it focuses on whether Canada has developed a coherent tradition of parliamentary opposition. David E. Smith argues that Canada has in fact failed to develop such a tradition. He investigates several possible reasons for this failure, in- cluding the long dominance of the Liberal party, which arrested the tradition of viewing the opposition as an alternative government; peri- ods of minority government induced by the proliferation of parties; the role of the news media, which have largely displaced Parliament as a forum for commentary on government policy; and, finally, the increas- ing popularity of calls for direct action in politics. Readers of Across the Aisle will gain a renewed understanding of of- ficial opposition that goes beyond Stornoway and shadow cabinets, illuminating both the historical evolution and recent developments of opposition politics in Canada. david e. smith, frsc, is the author of The People’s House of Commons (winner of the Donner Prize for the best public policy book by a Cana- dian), Federalism and the Constitution of Canada, and many books on Canadian politics. He is currently Distinguished Visiting Professor in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University. This page intentionally left blank Across the Aisle Opposition in Canadian Politics DAVID E. SMITH UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO PRESS Toronto Buffalo London © University of Toronto Press 2013 Toronto Buffalo London www.utppublishing.com Printed in Canada ISBN 978-1-4426-4736-7 (cloth) ISBN 978-1-4426-1547-2 (paper) Printed on acid-free, 100% post-consumer recycled paper with vegetable- based inks. Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication Smith, David E., 1936– Across the aisle: opposition in Canadian politics / David E. Smith. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-4426-4736-7 (bound). – ISBN 978-1-4426-1547-2 (pbk.) 1. Opposition (Political science) – Canada. 2. Canada. Parliament – Powers and duties. 3. Representative government and representation – Canada. 4. Canada – Politics and government. I. Title. JL167.S65 2013 328.71'0769 C2013-900572-2 This book has been published with the help of a grant from the Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences, through the Awards to Scholarly Publications Program, using funds provided by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. University of Toronto Press acknowledges the financial assistance to its publish- ing program of the Canada Council for the Arts and the Ontario Arts Council. University of Toronto Press acknowledges the financial support of the Government of Canada through the Canada Book Fund for its publishing activities. Dedicated to Ralph Goodale, Roy Romanow, and Brad Wall This page intentionally left blank Contents Preface ix Part One: Introduction 1 Opposition: ‘Somebody Has toDo It’ 3 Part Two: Parliamentary Opposition 2 From Coalition to Coalition, 1867–1920 23 3 The Liberal Ascendancy, 1921–1956 42 4 Majorities and Minorities, 1957–1992 62 5 The Mill of Opposition, 1993–2011 83 Part Three: Challenges for Parliamentary Opposition 6 Opposition, More or Less 101 7 Opposition in the Federation 127 8 Whither Parliamentary Opposition? 144 Part Four: Conclusion 9 The Problem of Parliamentary Opposition Today 161 viii Contents Notes 169 Bibliography 197 Index 219 Preface To say that the public is disillusioned with Parliament is to state a com- monplace. Claims of a democratic deficit, verified by forms of democrat- ic audit, are by now a familiar topic in discussions of Canadian politics. Critics claim that strict party discipline in the House of Commons, cou- pled with an electoral system that awards everything – which is to say, the single seat in contention in each constituency – to the candidate who wins the most but not necessarily a majority of votes cast, has distorted and suppressed representation of public opinion. It is also said that prime ministerial domination (or worse) of cabinet, public service, and Parliament has increased the gravity of the democratic deficiency. What is to be done to right what appears to be a serious imbalance in the ar- rangement and practice of Canadian political institutions? This is too large a question to be answered in a single book. Instead, this study examines the evolution and present condition of the political corrective to concentrated power that the system already provides – leg- islative opposition. Like its Westminster exemplar, Canada’s Parliament (and its provincial legislatures, with occasional variations) is divided into government and opposition. In the United Kingdom, the adjective ‘loyal’ by tradition describes the principal opposition; in Canada, where for nearly a century more than one party has sat opposite the govern- ment, the practice has been to use the word ‘official.’ The important point about the arrangement that for the purpose of this discussion is the one found in the House of Commons is that notwithstanding there being two sides, a sense of oneness holds them together. While it is true that each Member of Parliament is equal because each is elected by vot- ers in a single constituency, it is also the case that voters go to the polls aware that their collective action will normally determine who will form
The list of books you might like
