A WORLD ELSEWHERE A WORLD ELSEWHERE Europe's Encounter with Japan in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries Derek Massarella YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS NEW HA VEN AND LONDON 1990 TO THE MEMORY OF MY FATHER AND MOTHER The Publication of this book' has been generously assisted by a subsidy from The Japan Foundation. Copyright© 1990 by Yale University All rights reserved. This book may not be reproduced in whole or in part, in any form (beyond that copying permitted by Sections 107 and 108 of the U.S. Copyright Law and except by reviewers for the public press), without written permission from the publishers. Set in Linotron Bembo by Best-set Typesetter Ltd, Hong Kong. Printed and bound at the Bath Press, Avon, Great Britain. Library ofC ongress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Ma11arella, Derek, 1950- A world elsewhere: Europe's encounter with Japan in the sixteenth and SC'VC'lltC'C'llth centuries/Derek Massarella. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. 1. Europe-Foreign economic relations-Japan. 2. Japan - Forri~11 rrnnomk relations - Japan. 3. East India Company-History. 4. NedcrlamlNr Jl~l"lnrU 111 Japan - History. 5. Hirado-shi Oapan) - Industries - History. 6. Eururra11M - Japan - Hi•tory - 16th century. 7. Europeans - Japan - History - 17th l'C'ntury. I. Title. tlfll532.19.J3M37 1990 337.4052'00'031 - dc20 HIJ-22639 . CIP . .., .. Contents Acknowledgements Xll Glossary lX Notes for Readers Xl Introduction 1 6 CHAPTER 1 FIRST ENCOUNTERS WITH JAPAN Earliest Contacts 6 1 The Portuguese reach Japan, 1543 15 11 The Empire ofJ apan 24 111 The Portuguese in Japan 35 lV 49 CHAPTER 2 STRIKING OUT: THE ENGLISH AND THE AGE OF RECONNAISSANCE From Privateering to Trading 49 1 Company The Establishment of the East India 58 11 , Trading Company 71 William Adams and the Dutch in Japan 111 89 CHAPTER 3 THE EAST INDIA COMPANY REACHES JAPAN The Eighth Voyage 89 1 The Establishment of the Hirado 11 Factory, 1613 107 131 CHAPTER 4 FIRST YEARS IN JAPAN The Trading World ofJ apan the 1 ~nd Organisation of the Factory 131 vi CONTENTS First Steps, 1614 145 11 The Changing Situation in Japan 160 lll .180 CHAPTER 5 HOPES, ILLUSIONS AND DISAPPOINTMENT Hirado, Treasury of the Indies 180 1 Trade Restricted, 1616-1617 201 11 217 CHAPTER 6 LIVING AND SURVIVING IN HIRADO Private Trade and Private Lives 217 Years of Drift, 1618-1620 242 11 267 CHAPTER 7 THE MANILA VOYAGES AND WITHDRAWAL FROM JAPAN The First Manila Voyage, 1620-1621 267 1 Between Voyages, 1621 283 11 The Second Manila Voyage, 1621-1622 298 lll The Closure of the Hirado Factory, 314 lV 1623 329 CHAPTER 8 FURTHER ATTEMPTS AT DIRECT TRADE 1623 AFTER The Hirado Factory and Knowledge of 1 Japan in Seventeenth-Century England 329 Japan, The Summum Bonum of the 11 Indies 335 The Return to Japan, 1673 355 lll Notes 371 Bibliographical Essay 430 Index 435 Acknowledgements My debts in writing this book are many. Imai Hiroshi first suggested to me the importance of worlds elsewhere during an early stage of my stay in Japan and encouraged me to explore the subject with the attention it deserves. The late lwao Seiichi readily shared his formidable knowledge of Japanese and European sources. Leslie Le Clair, the Librarian of Worcester College, Oxford, has taken a keen interest in my work since my days as a research student. She provided the essential link in the chain of events which made this book possible for which I am grateful. I would also like to thank a number of friends and colleagues whose encouragement, support and help over the years has been invaluable: C. R. Boxer, Alexander Bruce, Michael Cooper, Guy Faure, Leslie and Susan Fearns, Sheelagh Fullerton, Genevieve Guth Kitts, Philip Healy, Christopher Hill, Robert and Sunae Hinton, Kanai Madoka, Oba Torno, Geoffrey Parker, Ivan Roots, Michael Strachan, Tamaura Hideo, Mariko Yandell and Austin Woolrych. My colleagues in the Faculty of Economics at Chuo University have been generous in their support; my students have taught me more than they realise. My editors at Yale, Robert Baldock and Elaine Collins, have been immensely supportive. Robert suggested that the seed of the original idea for the book should grow into something bigger and has nurtured the project to see that it did. Elaine cast a 'sharp, objective eye over the final typescript and saved me from a number of infelicities and unclear modes of expression. Thanks are also due to the Japan Foundation for awarding a grant under its Publication Assistance Program and the staff of the various archives and libraries where the research was undertaken, in particular the India Office Library and Records, especially the Deputy Director, Anthony Farrington, the British Library the Public Record Office, Chuo University Library and the Shiryo Hensan-jo of the University of Tokyo. viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS My obligation to my father who many years ago crossed the seas which figure so largely in this book is evident from the dedication. Finally I would like to acknowledge the huge debt I owe to Gerald Aylmer. Although this book is about a subject removed, but not entirely so, from army politics during the English Revolution I have tried to maintain the standards which he would expect. Any short coming is entirely my responsibility. Glossary bakufu 'tent government', the shogun's government or shogunate daikan deputy. The Nagasaki daikan was appointed by the bakufu and governed Nagasaki. The English referred to him as the Nagasaki governor or bongew, a corruption of bugyo, magistrate. daimyo feudal lord godown warehouse itowappu or itowappu nakama, silk yarn allotment guild, established in 1604; regulated the purchase price of silk brought by the Portuguese to Nagasaki. The Portuguese called it the pancado. jito land steward jurabasso interpreter, from the Malay jurubahasa, language master mestizo a Eurasian nanbanjin southern barbarian, original name for the Europeans who arrived in Japan in the sixteenth century. During the course of the seventeenth century it was used only for the Roman Catholic Europeans, that is the Portuguese and Spanish. nfo ndo do trato, great ship of commerce, or carrack as the English styled these Portuguese ships which varied between 600 and 1,600 tons. nihonmachi name applied to the communities of Japanese who formed the Japanese diaspora in southeast Asia. pancado see itowappu pangeran Javanese prince x GLOSSARY roju elders, the senior councillors of the shogun shuinjo vermilion seal document, important documents bearing the shogun's official seal. shuinsen vermilion seal vessels, Japanese authorised to sail overseas because they carried a shuinjo. voc Vereenigde Oost-Indische Compagnie, the Dutch East India Company. wako Japanese pirates or bandits, the term applied to Japanese pirates who attacked the coastal areas of China and Korea from the thirteenth to the seventeenth centuries; from the Chinese wo-k'ou.