This page intentionally left blank ATheoryofEconomicGrowth Thisbookprovidesanin-depthtreatmentoftheoverlappinggenera- tionsmodelineconomicsincorporatingproduction.Inchapter1,the authorsinvestigatecompetitiveequilibriaandcorrespondingdynamics: existenceanduniquenessofequilibrium,globaldynamicsofcapital(in- cludingpovertytraps),andvariousextensionsofthemodel.Chapter2 analyzestheoptimalityofallocationsinthisframework,usingboththe value function and marginal approaches. Optimality with unbounded growth is also analyzed. Policy issues, including the Second Welfare Theorem, pensions, government spending, and optimal taxation, are discussedinchapter3.Thenotionofpublicdebtisintroducedinchap- ter4,andthesustainabilityofpolicieswithbudgetdeficits/surplusesis examined.Thelastchapterpresentsextensionsofthemodelincluding altruism,education/humancapital,andhabitformation.Methodolog- icalemphasisisputonusinggeneralpreferencesandtechnologies,on theglobalstudyofdynamicaspectsofthemodel,andonfurnishingad- equatetoolstoanalyzepoliciesinvolvinginter-generationaltransfers. David de la Croix is Professor of Economics at the Universite´ catholique de Louvain and Research Associate of the National Fund forScientificResearchinBelgium.Hehasservedasavisitingprofes- sorattheUniversityofCalifornia,LosAngeles.ProfessordelaCroix’s researchinterestsinmacro-economicsincludedemographics,overlap- ping generations and human capital, and growth and cycles. He has published articles in leading refereed journals such as the Journal of EconomicTheory,EuropeanEconomicReview,JournalofEconomic DynamicsandControl,JournalofAppliedEconomics,ReviewofEco- nomicDynamics,andJournalofPopulationEconomics. PhilippeMichelisProfessorofEconomicsatGREQAM,Universite´de laMe´diterrane´e(Aix-MarseilleII)andaseniormemberofInstitutUni- versitairedeFrance.HetaughtpreviouslyattheUniversite´ deParisI. The author or coauthor of six books, most recently Monnaie, Dette, etCapital(1999),ProfessorMichel’sresearcharticleshaveappearedin prominentjournalssuchasEconometrica,ReviewofEconomicStudies, JournalofEconomicTheory,JournalofOptimizationTheoryandAp- plications,andInternationalEconomicReview.Hisresearchandteach- ing focus on politics and modeling in macroeconomics and dynamic theory. FurtherPraiseforATheoryofEconomicGrowth “Theoverlappinggenerationsmodelandtheinfinitelylivedordynasticmodelare thetwoworkhorsesofmodernmacroeconomics.DeLaCroixandMichelhave writtenawonderfullyaccessiblegraduatetextbookontheoverlappinggenerations model.Theycarefullytakestudentsthroughessentiallyeveryvariantofthemodel, provealargenumberofknownresults,andofferafewnewonesaswell.Thisbook isanessentialadditionasateachingtoolandaninvaluablereferenceonevery economist’sshelf.” –V.V.Chari,UniversityofMinnesota “Inrecentdecadesoverlappinggenerationmodelshavebecomeacentral frameworkofanalysisintheresearchofeconomicgrowth.Theauthorspresenta comprehensiveandlucidexpositionofthedynamicstructureofthebasic overlappinggenerationfeatureswithproduction.Highlyrecommendedfor researchersandgraduatestudentsinthefieldsofgrowththeoryanddynamic macroeconomics.” –OdedGalor,BrownUniversity “Someofthemosthotlydebatedgovernmentpoliciesarethosethatinvolve redistributionacrossgenerations,suchassocialsecurityandpubliceducation.Dela CroixandMichelprovideamanualofeconomictoolsforevaluatingthesesortsof policiesbasedonsimpleoverlappinggenerationsmodels.Theirpresentationof thesemodelsstrivestocombineapplicabilityforpolicyanalysiswithasolid foundationindynamicgeneralequilibriumtheory.Theirbookshouldbeofuseto economistsfromthelevelofadvancedundergraduatestudentstoresearchersand teachers.” –TimothyJ.Kehoe,UniversityofMinnesotaandFederalReserve BankofMinneapolis A Theory of Economic Growth Dynamics and Policy in Overlapping Generations DAVIDDELACROIX IRES,Universite´catholiquedeLouvain,Belgium PHILIPPEMICHEL GREQAM,Universite´delaMe´diterrane´e,France The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK 40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011-4211, USA 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia Ruiz de Alarcón 13, 28014 Madrid, Spain Dock House, The Waterfront, Cape Town 8001, South Africa http://www.cambridge.org ©David de la Croix and Philippe Michel 2004 First published in printed format 2002 ISBN 0-511-02891-1 eBook (Adobe Reader) ISBN 0-521-80642-9 hardback ISBN 0-521-00115-3 paperback ToAnna,Cle´mence,Elo¨ıse,Franc¸oise, Mathieu,The´re`se,Timothe´e, andallfuture,yetunborn,generations. Contents Introduction pagexiii OverlappingGenerationsandMacro-economics xiii OverlappingGenerationsinOtherFields xv OutlineoftheBook xvi Acknowledgments xvii 1 CompetitiveEquilibria 1 1.1 TheModel 1 1.1.1 Two-period-livedIndividuals 2 1.1.2 Neo-classicalTechnology 3 1.1.3 Firms 4 1.2 MainAssumptions 4 1.2.1 TheAssumptionsontheUtilityFunction 4 1.2.2 TheAssumptionsontheProductionFunction 6 1.3 TheBehavioroftheAgentsatPeriodt 10 1.3.1 TheYoungIndividuals 10 1.3.2 TheInter-temporalElasticityofSubstitution 11 1.3.3 ThePropertiesoftheSavingsFunction 12 1.3.4 TheOldIndividuals 15 1.3.5 TheFirms 15 1.4 TheTemporaryEquilibrium 16 1.5 TheInter-temporalEquilibriumwithPerfectForesight 19 1.5.1 ExistenceofEquilibria 20 1.5.2 UniquenessoftheInter-temporalEquilibrium 22 1.6 CapitalDynamicsataRationalInter-temporalEquilibrium 27 1.6.1 SteadyStatesandStability 27 1.6.2 Dynamics 29 1.6.3 TheBehaviorNear0 34 1.6.4 AQuickLookattheEmpiricsofGrowth 37 vii viii Contents 1.7 ComparisonofMyopicandPerfectForesight 39 1.7.1 TheSteadyStates 41 1.7.2 LocalStability 42 1.7.3 UniquenessoftheSteadyState 43 1.8 ApplicationsandExtensions 45 1.8.1 MyopicandPerfectForesightinanExample 45 1.8.2 ADemographicShock 50 1.8.3 Non-separableUtilityFunction 51 1.8.4 HomotheticPreferences 53 1.8.5 HeterogeneousAgents 54 1.8.6 TechnicalProgress 56 1.8.7 ImperfectCreditMarket 57 1.8.8 Three-period-livedHouseholds 64 1.8.9 BorrowingConstraintsintheThree-periodModel 66 1.9 Conclusion 70 2 Optimality 72 2.1 OptimalityofStationaryPaths 73 2.1.1 FeasibleLong-runCapitalStock 74 2.1.2 TheOptimalStationaryPath:TheGoldenAge 77 2.1.3 Under-andOver-accumulationofCapital 80 2.2 OptimalityoftheDynamics 82 2.2.1 DynamicEfficiency 82 2.2.2 ParetoOptimalityofDynamics 86 2.3 ThePlanningProblem 90 2.3.1 TheObjectiveFunction 91 2.3.2 PropertiesoftheValueFunction 92 2.3.3 ExistenceandMonotonicityofOptimalPaths 95 2.3.4 LimitoftheOptimalPathandOptimal SteadyState 99 2.4 MarginalAnalysisofOptimalSolutions 101 2.4.1 TheOptimalityConditions 102 2.4.2 ThePlanner’sStationarySolution 106 2.4.3 LocalDynamics 106 2.4.4 AGraphicalExposition 108 2.5 UnboundedOptimalGrowth 112 2.5.1 ExistenceofOptimalPathsWhenσ >1 112 2.5.2 ExistenceofOptimalPathsWhenσ <1(andγ ≥1) 114 2.5.3 ExistenceofOptimalPathsWhenσ =1 115 2.5.4 GeneralResult 116 2.5.5 TheLong-runGrowthRate 116 2.6 ApplicationsandExtensions 117 2.6.1 PropertiesofthePolicyFunctionsWhen f(0)>0 118 2.6.2 Application:TheOptimalSpeedofConvergence 120