A life in school: What the teacher learned

124 Pages·1996·12.122 MB·English

by  Tompkins, Jane P.

AL ife in School
OTHER BOOKS
BYJ ANET OMPKINS
WHAT THE TEACHERL EARNED
WesotfE verythTihnIegn :n Leirfo efW esterns
SensatDieosniagThlne sC :u ltuWorrakol fA meriFiccatni on
Reader-RCersicptiomisn:Fs roemFo rmaltiosP mo st-Stru(cetduirtaolr)i sm
JaTonmep kins
., A..d d.,i son-PWeusblleiysC hoimnpgaI nnyc,.
ReadMiansgs,a chuMseenPtlators Ck a,l ifoNrenwYi oar Dko nM ilOlnst,a rio
HaorwlE,n lgnadA msterBdoanmnS ydnSeiyan pgorTeo kyMoa driSdaJ nu an
ParSieso uMli laMne xiCciot Tya ipei
Excefrropmt" sT hHeo llMoewnA ,s"h -WednTehsedWa asyt,eu mda,n "dLa F igclhiea
PianignCeo "l lePcoteemd1s 9, 09-b1y9TS6..E 2 l,ic ootp,y r1i9g3bh6yHt a rcBorucear t
&C ompacnoyp,y r1i9g61h49t,6b 3yT .S .E liroetp,r ibnypet remdi sosfti hpoeun b ­
lisahneidrnC ;o mplPeoteema nsd P laoyfTs . S .El irote,p ribnypt eerdm iosfFs aibo&en r
FabLetr.d,
Excefrropm't T mi naH ur(rAyn Ddo n[K' nto \w1/ hyb)yAl, a"b amcao,p yr1i9g9h2t
MurrMauhs Ciocr por(aBtMilo)nW/ aVnannMe urs (iAcS CAP)/MSuaswisco ng
(ASCA/PPar)t rHiidMlgules (iAcS CAIPn)t.e rnactoipoynrsaielgc huAtrl erldi .g hts To mym othmyefi rr,s t teacher
reserved.
Thef ollocwhianpagtp epresai rnee adrlv ieerrs iinto hnfoesl lowpiunbcgla it:i ons
"PostfcraotrmhdE esd gienT"h e/ ournoafAl d vancCeodm posi1t9i9o"3nL,;e Gte'ts
Losti"nC onfessoifot nhCser itNiocrstA:hm eriCcraint Aiuctso'b iograMpohvie(csNa el w
YorRko:u tle1d9g9"e6Th);e,W ayW eL ivNeo wi"nC h angAe M:a gazoifHn ei gher
LearniNnog,v ember/De1c9e9m2b.e r
LibroafCry o ngsrC eastaloging-inD-aPtuab lication
TompkJiannPse.,
Al iifnse c ho:o wlh attht ee aclheearr n/e Jdae nT ompkins.
p.c m.
Inclubdiebsl iogrreafpehr(iepcn.ac le )s.
ISB0N- 201-91212-0
l.Tompk,Ji annPse.2 .T eachersS-United
3.Teancgh-i-nUitSetda t4e.sE .d ucation-U
methoId.sT .i tle. J;!/
lA2317.T6159A936 --n /?
371.1'0092-dc20 cf_.!
[BJ ,/&S� 96-31326
/13 CIP
;c;<;&
Copyr©i 1g9h9bt6yJ n aeT ompkins
Alrli grheetrvsse dN.op aorftt h piusb limcaaybt eir oenp rodsoutrceiednad ,r etrieval
systoertm r,a nsmiinat nftyoe mdo1,rb ya nmye anesl,e ctmreocnhiacnp,ih coatlo,c opying,
recordoitnhge,rww iiostreh t,oh puert i worri tpteemn1 iosfts hipeou nb liPsrhienirtn.e d
thUen itedo fAS mteartPieucsab .l issihmeudl tainnCe aonuasdlay.
Jacdkeestbi ygS nu zaHnenies er·
Texdte sbiygM ne rrick Hamilton
Seitnl O-pBoiitnsttT rreaanms i5t2ib1oy Mn earlrH iacmki lton
I 2 3 49 D-O5H -60 099978 987 96
Firpsrti nSteipntge,1m 9b9e6r
CONTENTS
Pre.fa.c.e. .............x.i. ......
ITh.e D reoaAfmu tho.r i.t y.. . . . . . . . . 1
2.P .9S.8.. .............8. ......
3.F oy.e.r... ...........3.4. .....
4O.t hPeero p.l e. . . . . .5 1. . . . . . . . . . .
5.T eac.h.e.r.s. ..........5.5. ....
6.T alkiinCn lga. s s. . . . .6 2. . . . . . . . . .
7.H igEhdeurc a.t i.o n. . . . . . . . . . . . . 66
8.M akiIn.tg. .....,..,,... . .....8.5.
9.A sWhe dnes.d.a.y. .......1.1.4. ..
10Th.e D aIyW alkOeudt C loaf.s .s. ..1.3.2
11P.ostcfarrotdmhE sed g.e . . . .1 4.1 . . . . .
12R.eve.r i.e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . l 53
13K.a rLeastseo .n .. . . . . 1.5 6. . . . . . . . . .
14Le.t'GseL to s.t. ..........1.6.2. ..
15T.h eWayWeLi.v.e.N.o.w. ...1.8.1.
16C.of.f e.e . . . . . .1 9.5 . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17T.i mOeu .t. ............1.9.8. ...
18Th.e C loria snttdeh Hee a.r.t. ....2.0.7.
EpilCohguaeTi:ar b,Ll aem,p . . . .2 2.5 . . . . . . .
LiosWoft r kCsi t.e d. . . . . .2 2.9 . . . . . . . . . .
AL iifnSe c hool
PREFACE
Att haego eff o rtyh-anvsiipnneemgn,o t so tmf y c onsyceiaiornusss i de
thwea lolafsc adienmsitci Itr uetailIoi nlznsoeo,nd h g aemdru cuhs e
fotrht eh iIn'lgdes a dir snnce hBoyot lhI.id so nm'etat nh wahtaI ht a d
learwnawesod r thbluteths tasht,se u bjIhe' acsdtt su daintedad u ght,
adnt ehw ayI h asdt udaintedad u ghtw etsrheeec mo,tn dota hrryee al
cnoceronmfsy l ife.
Thriesa lifzoaltluiopowoanepn de roiifon dt ecrnhaalns gtgeio,li ln g
oni,nw hiIcg hr adybu eaclaalmweat rhela itwf aens o atsI h aadl ways
takiettnbo e b usto mhenitgv edriyf fHeordwei nfettfn.w e arosn jluys t
begintnodi anwIgnbt .e mceac letaomr et hIaw ta nso itmn y l ife to
makace a rfeomeryr s beulttfog isvoem etthhionuwggh,ha t, specifi­
calIdl iyd,yn tek' nto Icw .o utletdlh lsa cth woaonslol ontghepearl c e
from eA.n edv wehni Icl oen titnodu reaasdw a laantrydae c hc laisns es
thuen iveIhr asidisn,to yms,ee n sger,a daunawdta elsdi viiannn go ther
wodr.l
Thbioslo ko obkasoc nkm yli fiesn c hwiotoahlne yteuon derstanding
altes asto moeif tr :e cowrhdaiiwttna gls i fkomere,t , bo e at eacahnedr
at usdeTnhto.um guhco hwf h aIht a tvsoea iyps a inmfyiu nlti,ens no tt
torp euidatthela itbf uett oe x amiinitean w atyah mta bye u seful,
1
XI
A LIFE IN SCHOOL Preface
especitaotl hselow yh woo rwki tthehi pnr esedeuncta altsy istoenm. Inso maer seo alfi pfeer,h iaitpps so si,sb tlole e awrhatno nneee dtso
Becsea auIma p rodoutfch ta t iswtyo sutbleeudm n ,g raatneedevfn u l knofwr oramed ianbgo wuhtao tt hpeero hpaldveoe n Peer.h sat paech­
dsihosntfe omret ot umrynb acokni tI.mt a dee w hmaIat m S.t ill, inisgo noetf h eBmu.ft om rev ,e freybw o oIhk asrv aeedo nt eh subject
mucohfw h aIht a vteosa yisc ritfioIcar ma slt,is mlalr tfirnogm :/a pproiaitcna hw eatdyh aspto kteom yc ointdioInn.d etehede a,rer
wousn usdstaloinnageg dMo y.c hiceoefnr cnist ahto uedru cation!aoln floyuP rao:oF lreiPerdea'gosoftg hyOe p psrseePda,er rPk alsmT eor'
sysdtoenemo sft o counts h ien nleeisrov fst udoerhn ettlsehpm to IKno:aws W eA r.Ken owSn,y al Avshit·on-WaT·eranceharenr'�Md,sa ria
acqutihsreee l f-undtehrisats teht b aainssf doaisr na sgft yiileni.Ngf o r, MonstseorTiheA' bss orbMeinntdA .ls lh aavr siieo onfl itfahtet arn­
bya nldag erd,os e tip rovteih sdaeafn edn urtuernivniergno ttn hmat scesnt dhceo enrcnosafn ypa rtiecduulcaartsy isemota nnashdla epst he
peope nleedi no rerdt og roMwyt. e asch haevnreob teen o tfh ueusa l ! authcoornpt'ciseoo wfn ha ta ne duciastF.ir oesbni or oestk'r sia bk leow
kinad d-oag c,o rsue ofm assaAglezsher,es' ip tmaise,hn otmeses l , fopro lijtuisctPaialcel resm'h ;o dlsu pa ni mea ogtfr e cuommunity;
peopBlued,sdt mh eiditaant oidneonno,m aitniocnhaaslmr,aii ct Ashton-Wsi adsre nidecrat'tofe rdsee leexf p-srsieoann;Md o nstsoeri's
Africaicna-cnAh muerTrche ehx.erp enictehsha atev m eantte h most tot hger oowwfth ho hulmea bne is.Whn agtt hheaye iv cno mmisoa n
tome haetv akfeonrt mhsaa rtae n titthowe htawitemc eaalwn h ewen committmote hsneat c rseo dlfni aefnseadf, a e relssensst osp eoankis t
reerft olea rniinann ga cadseemeni.Osc v ericnomgmyr e sistantcoe behWahlafItt. a e fkrotmh eimcs o urtaospg aeket hter uatbhom uyt
tehsen oinntelalmleo cedsto ukfn owhisab neget nhw eo rokmf y l eii fn exepernicaned t hheo ptaehtw haIrt e choerwrdie rel nld tehree xe rp-i
recyeenatWr hsaw.tas l aciknim neg- resfpoterehc w the o hluamn enocofet hmeorrasel ive.
orga,nem iostmsi,bo on,da ynsdp itra,isw ealsmli n d-wihs aits Wh aItw oluldi tksoee e eme rgietn h iwcisoa um noetr hrosytl iiwca y
lacikAnim nergi cedaunc aatsw ieolnl . ofc onceeidvuicnagt iwohniI-cm bheay na woafty ec ahianngd
Imta sye esmat nrgteh taehtra er seofe w r eefnecrheerste bo o ookns lenairntgh iansto jtsut t a-soeknrtiebdua tl ws laoyokoievrni sgt
educatthieosonorl yi,tat temltpett os et m ye xerpieangcaeit enh st shuoldaeetrv eryttahthi gision gngo na rodu.Sn uca mhet howdo uld
backgorcfol uansdps rraoecoa tmissi t d c'ersicbientd hl eir taeet.Fu orar nevfeatriot l a ikneat coc otuhnsatttu dsea nnttde archsha ebvoed s ie
lotnigem I w aasat l otsoes x ptliahsmi ysne lAflI.kl n ewwa Ish ,an do thaartme o arlth,e atrhtcasnat e b broksepsnit ,raht in teetdob ef eIdt.
destiopr ieuc pkab oooknte a chinfga-Ichi tan,ad p oseia tvievrsion woubleid ne rtseteiden x perasim euncacshi e bn o okkn owel,ae ndidgt s
tdoo ison-gan dIc ouldnm'utesr th eetevn eerngt yof e elg uialbtoyu t ressipboinwloiubtleytd h ger ohow wft hohluem baeni s,in nhga rmony
itN.o Iwe airzlet htahstr ei fsuatlor eaabdo muyst u bjwaemsc yst b u­ witthhpe l eatan nlwoienta hn other.
jectI.ct a me af eerndot mof ialnltyr ustI wmtasy t somey ol wfen.x pe­ ThRea leNeiwgashn dO bserpvuebsrhel dai na ricetl ae wf eayrbs ack
rietnhtca neIee de dt otu frno ern ligenhttF.eoi nrwtm a tseh f aieo lfu r repoorntas i onlgnu t toti hdoeur gp roebm.Al ne udcantmaoerDd r .
mye dutciatootn u mryna tentitont ota htex eprieen,soc t hIam ti ght GeorBguesie !o fN icshM oidldel Schiono lE vaInlnslost,iiho and,
knomwy saenltdfh buesa btlroeel oynm ysiewtlas ft ;hsf iaiwlhuirceh, staratp erdo gfrocarhm ie nlc darlOlpeedr aStnwiofolen.aH kes a"idI:
wasu lteilmmyay ot wnt,h Ia eten detdoc oem toter msw iatnhid n, thiwnhkah tae pnspt oal otk isoi dtfsh tahtne evyre r ealealrnlh yo two
writthsib inogot koc, o mpefnosra.t e hnadet lhestiersrst ,h eainergrI .na ddointt doi rueugdac tiotanhti, s
xii xiii
A LIFE IN SCHOOL Preface
whawte a rter yitnodg o t,og ivteh esmo msek ills ttoeh htahnidnlges Andh erre latitooJn oshhni-pt whaawsth awta sso i ntereIsk tnienwg .
thaatrc eo miunpgi nt heliirv es." shhea tdo ludst hliist sttlotero sy h ouwst hahters ocna rfoerdh ert,h at
"Tog ivteh esmo msek sit lohl andtlhete h intghsaa trc eo miunpgi n she lwoavswe idt htihnbe o soomfh efra mitlhyas,th eM,r sH.i ggins,
theliirv iesas s"h elpful a assItc aatinem maegniotnft e h peu rpeoo fs desphiertc eo ld,t hwleau sc kiesti ntp hewerh soowlnoer ld.
ane ducatIitiosb n o.tp hr actaincrdae lv olutionairnyt :h aiptnra ­cticalI d welolnt hiisn ceindbte cauistse y mbolsiozmteesh itnhga t was
steoafid g nortihsnegt roenmgo titohnacstr eaptreo blfeomtrsh s et u­ missfirnogem d ucataisIko nne iwt t:h ree aloifpt ryi vlaitfTeea .k ing
denitat, d mitthse amn odff ehresl rpe;v olutiinto hnasatcry h omoolr,e showresh,a vian gn abkoedddy r,i nkoirnagnj guei ce,a m beemibneogrf
oftetnh anno th,ab se etnh pel atcheac ta ussetsra ensadsn gienpr e ople's afa milnye,en dgti ok notwh ayto aur leo vendee,d gti ont ealblo iuttI. t
livienss,t oefra edl ietvhie�Amg .f ew daagytoshs ea mnee swpapreer­ watsh see nosfle i iftes tehlawfta msi ssiofns ge,n saonredym otieoxn­al
_
porttehtdat wot eengaigreil nCs a rNyo,r tCha rolhiandca o,mm itdt e perience nuopti ndt"iosv uibdjeedc ts"p-shyycghioenlnuoetgy,r, i tion,
suicliedaev,ia nn go tteh aatp ologfoirbz aegddr adaensdd i sobeed.i enc famirleyl atioenmsb-ebdudtie nadn arraptairovtfae l ,i vheids tao ry,
Wouladne ducadteisoing tnohe edl spt udeunntdse rdst thaeniinrn er histIco oruyrl elda ttome y h istaonrtdy h hei osrtioefts h pee opalreo und
turmhoaivlpe r evetnhtcieasdt astrophe? me,h oww ef elwth,aw te r eally atbhoouwuthg,ahi ttwt a lsi fkoer t ou s
I'smp eakhienrogefa na ttittuodweal reda rntihnaagtc cetphtiesm ­ bea-liavnegd o itnhgur goht hweo rld.
portaonftc heie n nleirfA ena. p protaotc eha chtihnaagtc knogwelse d Thest orayb outths eo ann d the asnhdtoh woeear rn gjeu ilceemt e
thheu mannoefbs ost the acahenrsdst udeInr tesm.e mbwehreI,nt ryt o knotwh aMtrs .Hi ggwianassh umanb eilnigmk ee, a nd tahtse a me
rechaalrlda,ln yiy n stainnwc heismc yht eachtoelrudsss omethaibnogu t timteh aitmt a dmee e nvio(uhsol wo Vesdhe w as!i)tg, a vmee h ope.
threo iwnl isv.Te heo nly instsatnacneod ustt hawtat sh igrirdna de, What the hfoopuen dowenIad as cn 't sqauyi-ftaee e loifcn ogm mon­
wheMnr sH.i gginmsyfa, v ortietaec thoelrud,sfo ,r r easIo hnassnl elv er alipteyr,h aapk sn,o wletdhgaMetr sH.i gghiandns e eadnsd t hahte r
knotwh,a tth amto rnihnesgro nJ,o hhna,bd r ouhgehartgl asosfo range neeadnsmd i nmei gnhtob te a ll dtihfafte rent.
juiwchei slhee iwnta hsse h owIethra .sd o methtiodn owg i thhe hra ving SchoaosIlk neiwtt augshotc sitauld firoet shm ea knigo fg oocdii t­
ac olTdh.ef eeltihnaagtc compatnhitieisdn a yn ecdwoataseb undya ntl zens;i tta ugahrti thmseott hiawcte c oulleda hronwt om akceh an,g e
cleparro:up dl easMurrsHe.i. g gwianbsso astainnedgn joyhiebnrog a st, holjdo bisn volcvoimnpgu taatnidpo anty,a xIetts a.u grheta diwnrgi,t ­
andIe njoiyatel dm oassmt u cahs s hdei dIs. a twh set eamy bathroom,in ga,n sdp ellBiunitgnt .e vteurr noeudgr a ztewo arodu rseolrev aecsh
fetlhthe e aatn mdo istiuntr heae i sra,tw eh o ranogfte h gel aosfos r ange otheIrnt. e vseurg getshtawetedm ighrte aocuhtt oo naen othDeera.t h
juihceelo du tto watrhdse h owsetrab lytl h hea nodft hmey sterJihoonu s wanse vmeern tioTnheredew. a ass ontgh aatc compaans ikeidp ping
(imny m inadt aylolu wtiht bhr owhna iArn)db. e hitnhedc lodug dleass gamwee l earnienkd i ndergarten:
doowra tsh nea kebdo doyfM rsH.i ggiennsj,o yiitnsge lf.
Howd oy oduo m,y p artner
WhatIr emembtehrki innagt tthiemh ead nothitnodg o w ith
Howd oy oduo today?
Freudriealna tioRnasthhiIewp ras,a.s m azaendpd l eatsoel eda trhna t
Wew idlaln cineac ircle.
MrsH.i gghiandsaf amilliyjf uesa tsId idIp. i cetduh rebra htromo
Iw islhlo ywo tuh wea y.
being mvuecrlhyi kmeyo wnh,e arp artmaennott vheerrs oifoo unr s.
XIV xv
Preface
A LIFIEN SCHOOL
Thisso nbgr oumgeh tam nycd ls samasfat ecteo f acitetal; ekd a obut headsa,bc ehdetwteintgi-snhhcgaoo la,n ndo utn derstwahnIyd ing
ctsltghhBaoAkoieooouwsnirhwn i ptwwtaat hstonellt nohnoww 'moldee ltyed adre tvaoeiicao n ne nrbtheg amsvtpt ,tdr,oeee,oiwonnowotiIepgoh olrg ta r ditd idtdtorr eurabel chsywhatit ohht nce'tnoi t htdlroghIme ehia . wee ra hv swtten.n vf aodseospoee oh wd teu enuusa esalruat ia o nqdlc satnor e ltohpw ,u da depeahad to le i tu d levono saheltsvitaocreaietwotsehnoluh raoo nfo,eac n a flw hkrt peeainlindm c h lb om eno,ywo rct neone iwc lo vaty h i o;o tywnu enol fued hozluta gt eotradrgueo,detoweailhpoohsu otnbs n drt. w w tvdasuarllf sd utgp pe ae ultedc tp osoe caknseba ar oholu eialrre tcvnn'lsowamt.deem rke t yu pel i nouaieet r hslrofcbl cn eeie-tg .s- a mr,smasal mhmtioOecsnteue�elmnaethd dhmnnlv.,ahilslnSo as masocrlse Ih a,s cyicolclytiioood asvft h onhetuo rgw pcwee tgolwagdhnsm ohltssha eio a stot ogoetyao wmfosstntls h h ufs n, u cmyoaoso ia eleglo gbi gthe rlmmori hdnhefphomtT poitwefta leelaohwhrlhtAa.e ti;atlImtaaehiee fs h.afsoe etcu sta ne amt edie agefheco l v rslfwei nrpr .i,calri htoortdloa e eisa,rpahrl e au oseniI f oeryltoovllocnhn rsd ctwteonad dinatecehvd s gwe .mgdiahtp i eIe tendp b mml iwhrcI n t e ,leiIelhaoh'uesbhlr iyeg,t daditsf dnavdawetmto r h lsr ueta ce srolsr omseschcareeniw eufgy tn shetusss tedhtattuxb u;o ru h etiyhihnisen rrcaoi :ds­t,ehtr a­e d­d
me atti hmti ghott gbnooeda bto otmt.
Bufti niadtli olcdyc tuo mre T.h eea lyrm eomriweoskm eeu pto who
Tfrheeibownsoat ktyI ed. tli nhldsotes sto eo ortfhyu t o to cIw cah nagmtmeeovy v i iseecwoewoh xslirpi; aner e canecd hiadcniafgl­eldy oIw baesyr-tieluarsne rA.gni dpfIgr e ifaeoidrarn- nm eaweednp tdeow r hsapsotecon coth thhlfiae erbvd Ie aefe ne al lbatoto une tr­
ofmttIcmimtmomdnonfgoAtooi eeee ehmshast e lc laosen nor mlhleyermsebaxwfd olc ,hwoaid f aunebva mesrmenpph ohno oh euoms ,eedg ima e mcIedbeoirwIedremhin orisd hnoflwh;e rh arnklS naw ta.iyaeti etne oa apoos esciai, dbhmt bah sds osb Asadffm tkenna hea reataoes esn eweiahss t mwyh t ndtsInoade bg sehurl l pieeasetletp oyhg omch ou o exneota iofunx nt s oa w aoopee ldtmIIpofl l sf ct,pa e,d fn tumsyttohta. etttlptoaddteho mi essr a ty hhre s wI hoa,rd e,.ia iitenrG toaysw myeolt aaers eo ndtnael o dso iiefsttarmi yprshhats to isr hn dum omrlurri si Rri esowfke e te nlotee nclesigironoirot atcoaed tuaigyt rdt:phnfhgi Ibobnheyhhrd hdsncto c ho ii ab cote if umfel t e owtetathtcalesoiyoebe nitl,tisI dhioihnhtoeoaur ahnn tvdxtdsiobaeh rrb lwerlleto ar mlgeat seeep ienecnlbmdeesoeymhe a lt ,ula waelhed yrpwe msglht tjTh tot es rkk goonctic itd ot irwsays eehui nm .gaa oihnfsresnthdv caosfhtmtio nefre s.pm rroatotg wcht ehnfe hayheu od t rmegefnfp, hh p do i et lnr eoaroasdode haooisn.cRna tdcmovmkm.tyteur an oe aegeneniepa tselnddlcl­,m's ntn­Ie frd el pt,ge ­ ­­ t d asiwsDlipcaetmhfgosnsaaIdfoeiruehnb rymoaoedtua c nt roeatsagbsaoo edowt,ar,dtenih kddathb gaelleShdMeem ocdle ntoei ui hutfhiaeiab a tdaatl iweaae nanle fetnsorxdri yrh chnnwazharirrgsItm aadhhl.p cddn ttteeha hmaesnb,ig owo tt ooildwh el eol sthieo r,tftddaos gnoamn uda.a lre eeclcin.ona ?a cii sen ndripr tsei u ik gtgnna IkncE ncaHlldliimc?gVEBnrmmnrin Iscr gasntgooheyoi eno meinyuebeyfJo oethotrl tghu aa fmt fuy rg cp w a rft. eao, hmhoellsrn yhw al ragflthr msa bht u nytii A hdddseenodf�i ii Aroectxnoeenm -dseng" mtie e inoodlismerfsIlop ocIdhasl r tTr rllwo'r a ohelet'c aryeke' fleeaeheoifbaBnktcmdls, fasnsss f'a dht.mdleradaoe sea oaan atl nosa ssais o ul dewteTg alwb ttddoicmdsratnmiFooas he t srau boypuic d thoeo yenrtu l it ipIGo-stneuersoheot nea hp-bneIonile w ts eclaJoyneormo nttttIe aet en grmymihwobBaadruf, lfta.oaeoca e h u wk m p tIlho.eucm rsnpe otp rytai hhh iOercl ,famrm haar itghnn gsglsoucd,aofstndlbah " n ety or ,lsts ianutsErrle ds t f w i ob tiom siotbecsnteee arsuiar.o; etheIao eocaga.anrydrk ednruey­r dd­e aats rys
mistafkuoelftsl h, p ehy siscyamlpm sto ofds itresomsa-cshtas,c he upt ot hrees otmf y l ife.
xvii
xvi
Preface
A LIFIEN S CHOOL
rmalcoowfpoonoenrherTMleocrdmsc aaahyehIrmlevmawe eetsrcp esaa aioaxe ra fte isdtcdognpnenpuirln iF.biashdeetetalmca vietcnet xrpuarer aeIosmtin,oal . dpiaat-dtn tffahtta le iiesmstltd e u ekehyl ansrusehlteiranbnai e,lr tcirsenryemnitnoeitn yonroometIsdto aptvt eodvug,cf ts tvte utb osuctoeexk r sd h hiehrnd ea gh nai deouwasalktryeteg hi csei mramrttctenyei anin nwhtpdiyytwihoh es rdnttnogti.ee swn shnio wwtse gisst et inrtahdgl itno au a o hrostsrbai iIQIcgilsrlno rr iolukotsf O h m ni uitwgianognus cedt ie tzttohattl.msngetmoo r dpae o,e enho otltw amnweablni b ax rierev e ketiawtuad nmteoilez ye t tsttmhaitc mvyenfsl eh soahohhsann ey eai It doma eeclt et tmdg, scg wonnaf cee h y thnacIm ode oolaoshltmi l or mrouyocuaeeahena­riy fn hfgdls engsen tih fs t s gsnt sg , tow;iA.ifSwsi ukhS�sn n hamlaooucncordhkn. rss eya uSfpoh -onr' pooo ruo-so awoooyt in,w bebSomorliol;hdure njyil eoeouftmdetl eeezi sd dstn rio k yaeds vxtubeg1penettoes r"s ufgl eiuy nm sao,hefr " taiaeplsa set"y t •ar hdhn1t e•w"iotlene cTw n moice r etoMnpoe f.tvhhda eirtorf ruo mfnat eteeos liin eiuwtmie cvhrh r; iotodcsnreaesietnoeoeey ehta!fynit oaef tyninn tr,or osw ahfa ,ti guc h cddt t s rnoasuettj ioamoseoie otle mesy eeuoniog p uv oele beOt sr.sdn,mnnueirTt afa ethn s ges espirvdahhv.nl ef "mcm wnt tfeugiatoedip ow ouhetet iueraesetthf eharafsstonh odicy,ls r ht"var,wyt hiontatfneft . eie evahh n sotlto t.ho c � n�in ed m1olt osea,t zf erfitgas .s oc i. ia ea et euiri do htl �ix ss ternu t snoueneets� o t eeo�ete e d uaa ruotesttt r o x�� c_hl 1;puohera hye bgaw:ep0nse . rn:r re.- ll nc n y ,
reasIoh nasgd i vfeontr h eImt .h ouigth st fw oamry s tudents' beneefnicsptee ak.
thaIwt a cso nucdtitnhge tsrei bayll isb erfaotrsi aohIwno ,ws traitjack­
etdet hewye rbeyt hnee etdop leaanstde o p erffoorprme opilnae u­
thorBiutitywt .a sno'ntlf yo r tthheaItmt o otkh ersies Bkyts h.r owing
outth wei ndaolwtl h e usuala nssdtt arnudcaItrw udarsase l sts,ryo i ng
tof rmeyes eflrfot mh aeu thorittraaritinhaiahnnta gf d e ttmeerr,ee d­
bellaitan ltglh ahtab de edno nteom ei nt hwea oyfm ind-nuamnbdi ng
spirit-dbirsecaikIpni leniegnd teeol.d e g too ft hceo nventthianoton rs­
malbliyn cdl assbreohoamvu intoiIrcl o ugledbt a ctkoa p lawchee re
thewreern eos bndafrodra mnsly o ngate irm,ae n sdp abceef osrceh ool
began.
Int heen ,dm yc lasserxopoemr iamnetdnh tmese moroifeP s.9 S8.
lemde t oag limopfst ehp ee rshoandb e eIn b efoIwr een ttos chool.
Thes earlcethdot hpea rotfms y s etlhfas tc hohoalds ideloirsn uepd­
presesmeodt:ii omna,g insaptiirointr,ue aslpfieottcrhyt be, o dyn'ese ds.
I hlaodv tehdle i offie n tellsetcrtiuovafisl nc gh,o larlyc hianlq­uiry,
lenagnedd,e babtueth, a Ild e aransAe rdt,h Kuore stleirnD awrrokt­e
neasNtso onp,l aIary e afdoE rn glcilsamhsy ss e nyieoaorrfh igshc hool,
thattob eg uidbeyrd e asaolnoi nssea ilwiitnhgob uatl lIaw satn.tt eod
becowmheo lYeem.to riem poretvaentnht a tnhd ei scoovfae nrpyya r-
xix
xviii
1
THE DREAM
OF AUTHORITY
I'imnfr onotft hcela sosnt hfier sdta oyf s choaonlfod,r s omree asIo'nm,
totaunlplrye pa(rHeoddwi. td h ihsa ppeThnr?)o atti gIhfa tk,ea s mile,
grafobrw ordst,ea lnla necdaontyet,ht iohn oglt dh eaitrt enBtuittoh ne.
stranignre orwsis nfr onotfm ea renha'vti anngyT .h esyt atrost uh ffle
anmdu rmutrh;et yu rtnh ehiera adwsa y./cJhhaeisnrc sr abpaeca kn,Id
realiitaz'cest uhaallpyP eTnheesd t.u deanrwteas l koiunotgn m e. I have
finalgloyt twehnaI td eserve.
Thidsr eaimno nfeo romra notihdser re ambeydt housaonftd esa ch­
erbse fotrhee begoifnt nhifena sgle lm eesrSt.o mder eatmh atth ey
canf'itn d ctlhaesisrra onoadmr rsea cifnrga nltylti hcraoudgahr kened
haloltsh;et rhsat th eayr peo ntifiicnna atsitanolgn oenss ubjetchtesy
knwo notihnagb ouott;eh rsse teh emsetluvrennsgti o wornit thee
balckboaanrdfed e tlh cel alsesa vbienhgit nhdeb iarc kTsh.ed reaimss o
commotnh amto spte opIkl neo dwi scoiut"n.Ot h e,v eryhbaotsdh ya t
dreamt,h"esy a dyi,s mistshsieun bgj Beucttth .de r eaimns o dti scount­
ablIeti. as b otuhtfe e oarff aiel-utrhfea iloufor nee a'ust hority-and
ipto inttsh hete oao rfwt h aitmt e antsob ea t eacher.
\Vhen Ih atdh dirse aIm'b,de etne achfioonrvg e firf teyeena Irw sa.s
af uplrlo feastasr oerp utable ruengiavraedrsaegs doi ottdye ,a cahnedr