Also by Harlan Lane As Author The Wild Boy of Aveyron When the Mind Hears: A History of the Deaf The Mask of Benevolence: Disabling the Deaf Community As Editor Recent Perspectives on American Sign Language (François Grosjean, co-editor) The Deaf Experience: Classics in Language and Education (translated from the French by Franklin Philip) Parallel Views: Education and Access for Deaf People in France and the United States Looking Back: A Reader on the History of Deaf Communities and Their Sign Languages (Renate Fischer, co-editor) Also by Robert Hoffmeister Discourse Processes in American Sign Language (James Gee, co-editor) Also by Ben Bahan American Sign Language Literature Series: Bird of a Different Feather (with Sam Supalla) Signs for Me Basic Sign Vocabulary for Children, Parents & Teachers (with Joe Dannis) My ABC Signs of Animal Friends (with Joe Dannis) A Journey into the DEAF–WORLD Cover art: Discovery of Language ___________________ by Harry R. Williams As a Deaf boy, the artist struggled to understand the connections between words and images. His discovery of language came when he grasped that the fingerspelled word “b-a-l-l” matched the picture of a ball, and the door of enlightenment opened for him. Before, his mind was a desert. After, his vision was transformed by the primary colors—red, blue, yellow—which were to change his life. The flower in full bloom is Williams’ rendering of the moment of discovery: “I understand!” L. K. Elion My Eyes are My Ears; Homage to Harry R. Williams A Journey into the DEAF–WORLD HARLAN LANE ROBERT HOFFMEISTER BEN BAHAN DAWNSIGNPRESS SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA A Journey into the Deaf–World Copyright © 1996, Harlan Lane, Robert Hoffmeister, Ben Bahan. All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. No part of this book (except brief quotations to be included in a review) may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted by any means, electronic, mechanical photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without written permission from the publisher. Editor: Corona A. Machemer Editorial Services Producer: Joe Dannis Sign Illustrator: Paul Setzer Manufactured in the United States of America. Published by DawnSignPress. The paintings of the abbé de l’Epée on his deathbed, by Peyson; of the abbé de l’Epée giving a lesson, by Privat; and of Sicard and Massieu, by Langlois are from the collection of the library of I’Institut National des Jeunes Sourds, 254 rue St Jacques 75005 Paris. The information contained in this book is intended to be educational and not for diagnosis, prescription, or treatment of health disorders, whatsoever. This information should not replace competent medical care. The Authors and Publisher are in no way liable for any use or misuse of the information. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lane, Harlan L. A journey into the deaf–world / Harlan Lane, Robert Hoffmeister, Ben Bahan. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-915035-63-4 (paper: alk. paper). — ISBN 0-915035-62-6 (hardcase: alk. paper) 1. Deaf—Social conditions. 2. Deaf—United States—Social conditions. 3. Deaf—Means of communication—United States. I. Hoffmeister, Robert. II. Bahan, Benjamin J. III. Title. HV2380.L27 1996 305.9’08162’0973—dc20 96-19522 CIP Quantity discounts for the print edition are available for schools and bookstores. For more information please contact: DawnSignPress 6130 Nancy Ridge Drive San Diego, CA 92121 619-625-0600 V/TTY 619-625-2336 FAX Order Toll Free 1-800-549-5350 For our parents and the Deaf people who have led us on the journey Contents Acknowledgments Authors’ Note Part I: In the Center of the Deaf–World Chapter 1 Welcome to the Deaf–World Chapter 2 Families with Deaf Children Chapter 3 The Language of the Deaf–World Chapter 4 Form and Function in ASL Chapter 5 Deaf Culture Chapter 6 The World Deaf Scene Part II: At the Borders of the Deaf–World Chapter 7 Disabling the Deaf–World Chapter 8 Educational Placement and the Deaf Child Chapter 9 Language and Literacy Chapter 10 Bilingual and Bicultural Education for Deaf Children Chapter 11 Evaluating Deaf People Chapter 12 The Hearing Agenda I: To Mitigate a Disability Part III: When Two Worlds Collide Chapter 13 The Future of the Deaf–World Chapter 14 The Hearing Agenda II: Eradicating the Deaf–World Chapter 15 The Deaf Agenda: Enriching the Deaf–World Chapter 16 Journey’s End Notes References About the Authors Acknowledgments Many of our colleagues have greatly assisted us in preparing this book and it is a pleasure to acknowledge their help: Thomas Allen, Yerker Andersson, Elliot Aheroni, Douglas Bahl, Charlotte Baker-Shenk, Donald Bangs, Sue Burnes, John Campton, Kathee Christensen, Oscar Cohen, Dennis Cokely, Janis Cole, Betty Colonomos, Jay Croft, Amy Czisk, Kristin Diperri, Lindsay Dunn, Gilbert Eastman, L.K. Elion, Karen Emmorey, Kathy Girod, Neil Glickman, Debra Guthmann, Michael Harvey, David Hays, William Isham, Trudy Schafer-Jeffers, Jerald Jordan, Debbie Kneisell, Michel Lamothe, Jessica Lee, Ruben Leon, Ella Mae Lentz, Ceil Lucas, Alan Marcus, Marina McIntire, Paula Menyuk, Betty G. Miller, Ilene Miner, Elizabeth Monaco, William Moody, Elissa Newport, Carol Padden, Peter Paul, Hal Rosenblatt, Susan Rutherford, Al Santoro, Carol Santoro, Jerome Schein, Brenda Schertz, Michael Schwartz, Ginger Smith, Theresa Smith, Jim Tourangeau, and Clayton Valli. We want to record particular gratitude to our gifted editor, Corona Machemer, who has been an invaluable advisor, collaborator and critical reader; to Lynn Stafford, our copyeditor; and to the skilled and dedicated team at DawnSignPress.