A Companion to Anglican Eucharistic Theology Volume 2: The 20th Century to the Present PDF
Preview A Companion to Anglican Eucharistic Theology Volume 2: The 20th Century to the Present
A Companion to Anglican Eucharistic Theology Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig A Companion to Anglican Eucharistic Theology Volume 2: The 20th Century to the Present By Brian Douglas LEIDEN•BOSTON 2012 Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig Thisbookisprintedonacid-freepaper. LibraryofCongressCataloging-in-PublicationData Douglas,Brian(BrianE.) AcompaniontoAnglicaneucharistictheology/byBrianDouglas. p.cm. Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindex. ISBN978-90-04-21930-4(v.1.:hardback:alk.paper) 1.Lord'sSupper–AnglicanCommunion–History.2.Anglican Communion–Doctrines–History.I.Title. BX5149.C5D682012 234'.163088283–dc23 2011040698 ISBN9789004221260(hardback) ISBN9789004221338(e-book) Copyright2012byKoninklijkeBrillNV,Leiden,TheNetherlands. KoninklijkeBrillNVincorporatestheimprintsBrill,GlobalOriental,HoteiPublishing, IDCPublishers,MartinusNijhoffPublishersandVSP. Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproduced,translated,storedin aretrievalsystem,ortransmittedinanyformorbyanymeans,electronic,mechanical, photocopying,recordingorotherwise,withoutpriorwrittenpermissionfromthepublisher. AuthorizationtophotocopyitemsforinternalorpersonaluseisgrantedbyKoninklijkeBrillNV providedthattheappropriatefeesarepaiddirectlytoTheCopyrightClearanceCenter, 222RosewoodDrive,Suite910,Danvers,MA01923,USA. Feesaresubjecttochange. Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig CONTENTS PART1 INTRODUCTION .AnglicanEucharisticTheology? .................................... 3 IsThereanAnglicanEucharisticTheology? ....................... 3 TheIntegrityofDiscourseintheAnglicanEucharisticTradition 16 RealismandNominalismandtheAnglicanEucharisticTradition 20 TheProblemofUniversals.......................................... 25 RealismandNominalismAgain.................................... 28 StatesofAffairs...................................................... 34 StatesofAffairsandtheEucharist.................................. 36 FurtherAnglicanReflectiononRealism........................... 39 RealismandtheScriptures ......................................... 47 TheQuestionofTruth .............................................. 51 ATheoreticalModeloftheAnglicanEucharisticTradition....... 55 ModerateRealism................................................ 55 ImmoderateRealism............................................. 57 ModerateNominalism........................................... 58 ImmoderateNominalism........................................ 59 TheModelintheDiscourseoftheAnglicanEucharisticTradition 60 PART2 CASESTUDIES .TheEarlyTwentiethCentury....................................... 67 Overview............................................................ 67 Themes .............................................................. 67 Realism........................................................... 67 Sacrifice........................................................... 71 ImmoderateRealismDistinguishedfromModerateRealism.. 74 HeightenedandEnhancedEfficacyofElements................ 75 Transubstantiation ............................................... 76 AdoringChristintheEucharist ................................. 77 Nominalism...................................................... 78 Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig vi contents TheCaseStudies .................................................... 80 Anglo-CatholicCongresses......................................... 81 ConferenceHeldatFulhamPalace,October,................ 102 NathanielDimock .................................................. 107 DoctrineintheChurchofEngland,.......................... 119 HerbertEck ......................................................... 132 AustinFarrer........................................................ 137 CharlesGore ........................................................ 148 WilliamHenryGriffithThomas.................................... 158 NugentHicks........................................................ 168 EdmundArbuthnottKnox ......................................... 177 ClaudeBeaufordMoss.............................................. 178 HandleyCarrGlynMoule.......................................... 186 WilliamCharlesEdwardNewbolt.................................. 195 OliverChaseQuick ................................................. 202 ArthurMichaelRamsey ............................................ 210 WillSpens........................................................... 215 WilliamTemple..................................................... 224 EvelynUnderhill.................................................... 235 PhilipNapierWaggett .............................................. 254 FrankWeston ....................................................... 268 DarwellStone ....................................................... 270 .TheLaterTwentiethandTwenty-FirstCenturies.................. 275 Overview............................................................ 275 Themes .............................................................. 275 ModerateRealism................................................ 275 Sacrifice........................................................... 283 Nominalism...................................................... 288 Transubstantiation ............................................... 292 Change ........................................................... 293 MultiformityNotUniformity.................................... 294 TheCaseStudies .................................................... 295 Anglican-RomanCatholicInternationalCommission(ARCIC) 297 DavidBrownandAnnLoades ..................................... 313 PeterCarnley........................................................ 319 ChristopherCocksworth ........................................... 326 MarcusDonovan.................................................... 353 RobertDoyle........................................................ 358 Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig contents vii GregoryDix......................................................... 379 DavidFord .......................................................... 387 GabrielHebert ...................................................... 392 RoyHerbert......................................................... 395 InternationalAnglicanLiturgicalConsultation(IALC)........... 397 PeterJensen ......................................................... 408 PhillipJensen........................................................ 413 DavidBroughtonKnox............................................. 416 DiarmaidMacCulloch.............................................. 426 JohnMacquarrie .................................................... 433 EricMascall ......................................................... 460 JohnOulton......................................................... 472 JamesInnellPacker ................................................. 481 MartinParsons...................................................... 493 CatherinePickstockandJohnMilbank ............................ 497 KeithRayner ........................................................ 529 DonaldWilliamBradleyRobinson................................. 532 JohnArthurThomasRobinson..................................... 536 MasseyShepherd.................................................... 542 KennethStevenson.................................................. 547 AlanStibbs .......................................................... 555 JohnStott............................................................ 561 StephenSykes ....................................................... 569 ThinkingabouttheEucharist........................................ 586 RowanWilliams .................................................... 605 PaulZahl ............................................................ 624 AnglicanEucharisticLiturgiesofthethandstCenturies.... 632 Catechisms.......................................................... 717 PART3 RAMIFICATIONS .DialogueandtheAnglicanEucharisticTradition.................. 733 Overview............................................................ 733 Dialogue:TowardsCriticalInterest ................................ 734 HabermasandtheTheoryofCommunicativeAction............. 737 RamificationsfortheAnglicanEucharisticTradition ............. 743 SacramentalTheologyafterHabermas............................. 751 Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig viii contents Dialogue—OtherPerspectives ..................................... 756 DialogueandtheAnglicanTradition .............................. 760 Index ................................................................... 773 Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig PART1 INTRODUCTION Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig chapterone ANGLICANEUCHARISTICTHEOLOGY? IsThereanAnglicanEucharisticTheology? IsthereanAnglicaneucharistictheologyandifsowhatisitsnature?This bookseekstoexploreandpromotedialogueonthisquestionthroughthe provisionof case studies of Anglican eucharistic theology and through contemporaryphilosophical reflection on the Anglican eucharistic tra- dition.Thisexplorationaimstoprovidegreaterintegrityforthediscourse of the Anglican eucharistic tradition, such that the discourse is really talking about whatit saysitis talking about. Insodoing thisbookalso aims at providing access to what many theologians, theological state- mentsandeucharisticliturgieshavesaidabouttheEucharistintheAngli- cantradition. Perhaps the answer to this specific question: ‘Is there an Anglican eucharistictheologyandifsowhatisitsnature?’canbestbeapproached by looking to the more general question of the nature of Anglicanism itself.JohnWhalearguesthatAnglicanismwillremainmultifarioussince “it taps multiple sources, in the present as in the past”1 with the main sources being scripture, tradition and reason. Each of these sources, arguesWhale,attractsitspartisans,whovalueonesourceovertheothers. ThePrefacetotheBookofCommonPrayerhintsatthispartisanship withintheAnglicanismwhenitspeaksofthetaskofliturgicalrevisionas onewhichseeks“nottogratifythisorthatpartyinanytheirunreason- abledemands”.2Thissuggeststhatthereisadifferenceofemphasisamong Anglicansonsomeofthemostfundamentalquestions,suchthatAngli- canswilldivide intovariousinterests.RowanWilliams,theArchbishop ofCanterbury,inspeakingofmembershipoftheAnglicanCommunion 1 JohnWhale,TheAnglicanChurchToday:TheFutureofAnglicanism(Londonand Oxford:Mowbray,),p.. 2 ThePreface,TheBookofCommonPrayer(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversity Press),p.viii. Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig chapterone asanimportantpartofAnglicanismheritage,3alsopointsout,forexam- ple,thatsomewithintheCommunioninthepursuitoftheirparticular interestsaremorecommittedto federalism andpluralism thanothers.4 Some Anglicans, he argues, instead place greater value on the seeking ofstructuresthatworktowards“mutual recognisability,mutualconsul- tation and some shared processes of decision-making” as expressions of “mutual responsibility”.5 It is within these different interests that the Archbishoprecognisesthepossibility“ofa‘two-track’model,twoways of witnessing to the Anglican heritage”6 whilst at the same time argu- ing that any “competitive hostility between the two would be one of theworst possibleoutcomes,andneeds to be clearly repudiated”7 even thoughatthesametimeheacknowledgesthatthereare“differentvisions oftheAnglicanheritage”8whichresultin“thedifferentneedsandprior- ities identified by different parts of our family”.9 Williams, it seems, is acknowledgingtheexistenceofdifferentinterestswithintheoneAngli- can tradition and suggests that on some of the fundamental questions relatedto being anAnglicanCommunionthereismorethanonetrack tofollow.MorepragmaticallyWhaledescribesthesedifferencesininter- estsamongstAnglicansas:“lowchurch,highchurchandbroadchurch; individualism, authority and latitude; Evangelicalism, Catholicism and the middle way”.10 Ian Bunting provides details of these party group- ings11whichhetermsEvangelical,CatholicorLiberal,andMarkChap- man12 doesmuch thesame as heanalyses what he calls Evangelicalism andAnglo-CatholicismwithintheAnglicanCommunion.Itseemsthat within Anglicanism there is a recognition of difference which often is reducedtoparticular interestsorpartynames.BruceKayereferstothis 3 RowanWilliams,Communion,CovenantandourAnglicanFuture,Reflectionson theEpiscopal Church’sGeneralConventionfromtheArchbishopofCanterbury fortheBishops,ClergyandFaithfuloftheAnglicanCommunion,July,,para- graph . Online at: http://www.archbishopofcanterbury.org/. Accessed July, . 4 Ibid,paragraph. 5 Ibid,paragraph. 6 Ibid,paragraph. 7 Ibid,paragraph. 8 Ibid,paragraph. 9 Ibid,paragraph. 10 Whale,TheAnglicanChurchToday:TheFutureofAnglicanism,p.. 11 IanBunting,CelebratingtheAnglicanWay(London:HodderandStoughton,). 12 MarkChapman,Anglicanism:AVeryShortIntroduction(Oxford:OxfordUniversity Press,),pp.–. Brian Douglas - 978-90-04-22133-8 Heruntergeladen von Brill.com02/19/2022 09:20:28PM via Universitat Leipzig
The list of books you might like
