APA MAGAZINE The Magazine for the Polygraph Professional November/December 2016 Volume 49,6 52nd Annual APA Seminar August 27 - September 1, 2017 YOU NEED Contributors to this issue Bakhtiyar Aliev George Baranowski ACCESSIBLE Gary F. Davis Steven Duncan Donnie Dutton Mike Gougler AND PROVEN Mark Handler Lisa Jacocks Said R. Khamzin Vladimir Kniazev POLYGRAPH Donald Krapohl Sabino Martinez Raymond Nelson Patrick O’Burke Stanley M. Slowik SOLUTIONS Gordon Vaughan Deadlines This issue closed on December 11 Deadline for January/February 2016 issue is January 30 LAFAYETTE Submission of Articles INSTRUMENT The APA Magazine is pub- lished by the American Poly- graph Association. All views, DELIVERS opinions and conclusions expressed in this magazine are those of the authors, and Contact our experts to find out how! do not necessarily reflect [email protected] the opinion and/or policy www.lafayettepolygraph.com of the APA or its leadership. Tel: (765) 423-1505 References in this maga- zine to any specific commer Contents Contributors to this issue Bakhtiyar Aliev Membership News George Baranowski Gary F. Davis 4 APA Board of Directors Steven Duncan 5 Editor’s Corner: Important News About Upgrading Donnie Dutton from Associate to Member Mike Gougler Mark Handler Training & Seminars Lisa Jacocks Said R. Khamzin 7 APA New Mexico Seminar Program Vladimir Kniazev 8 Polygraph Examiner Training Schedule Donald Krapohl 9 NPA Annual Seminar Program Sabino Martinez 11 APA Annual Seminar Program and Update Raymond Nelson 101 Polygraph Schools Accredited by The APA Patrick O’Burke Stanley M. Slowik From the Board Gordon Vaughan Deadlines 19 President’s Message 22 Board of Directors’ Reports This issue closed on 27 APA Files Amicus in Support of Polygraph Admissibility in Alaska Supreme Court December 11 29 APA Antitrust Compliance Program Deadline for January/February Regular Features 2016 issue is January 30 Submission of Articles 45 Polygraph Abroad - Azerbaijan by Bakhtiyar Aliev and Said R. Khamzin The APA Magazine is pub- 75 Polygraph Abroad - Republic of Belarus by lished by the American Poly- Vladimir Kniazev graph Association. All views, opinions and conclusions Special Features expressed in this magazine are those of the authors, and 49 Practical Polygraph: Managing the Cardio Cuff Sensor During the Pretest Interview by Raymond do not necessarily reflect Nelson the opinion and/or policy 55 Detection Deception: Ancient Lie detection of the APA or its leadership. Trickery by Donald Krapohl and Donnie Dutton References in this maga- 67 Advancing Diversity in Law Enforcement by zine to any specific commer Stanley M. Slowik 81 Five Minute Science Lesson: Measurement Theory and Lie Detection by Raymond Nelson cial products, process, or service by trade name, trademark, man- ufacturer or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute or imply en- dorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the APA or its leadership. Appearance of advertisements in this magazine does not constitute or im- ply endorsement, recommendation or favoring by the APA and the APA makes no warranty, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, complete- ness, or usefulness of any information, product, process or service made a subject of such advertisement. Advertising and Editorial address is [email protected]. Subscription address is: APA, P.O. Box 8037, Chattanooga, TN 37414-0037. The APA Magazine is published six times per year and is available in electronic for- mat only. Address and e-mail changes/updates should be sent to: APA, P.O. Box 8037, Chattanooga, TN 37414-0037, or manager@polygraph. org. E-mail notification is sent to subscribers when the latest publication is available. The APA webmaster is not responsible for issues not received because of improper address information. Submission of polygraph-relat- ed articles should be sent to: Mark Handler, [email protected]. Advantage! We are often asked: “Why do we do, what we do?” The answer is simple, your signals will look better and interpretations of your charts will be easier. CPSpro Advantages: • No Re-Centering! No lost data! You will be able to pay more attention to the examinee and allow the state-of-the-art software take control of the channels • 7-Year warranty • FREE Software support & upgrades • Ability to record up to 13 channels • Skin C onductance or Skin Resistance. Our competitors record one or the other; with us, it’s you choice! • 24-bit analog-to-digital conversion circuitry • Medical grade LEMO and Luer inputs and connectors • Cardiograph supports up to 215 mm Hg • The only company that offers Skin Potential, Voice Events, Electronic Pneumos, and EDA with Laboratory-Style Finger Contoured Ag-AgCl Electrodes We can truly stand by the notion that we have the most advanced polygraph system available with an intuitive, user friendly design. For more information, visit us at www.StoeltingCo.com Stoelting Co. 620 Wheat Lane, Wood Dale, IL 60191 • 1-800-860-9775 • [email protected] APA BOARD OF DIRECTORS 2016-2017 M President Director 7 Patrick O’Burke Gary F. Davis e [email protected] [email protected] m President - Elect Director 8 b Dan Violette Jamie McCloughan e [email protected] [email protected] r s Ex Officio Members Chairman of the Board h Walt Goodson National Office Manager i [email protected] p Lisa Jacocks P.O. Box 8037 Director 1 Chattanooga, TN 37414-0037 N Barry Cushman [email protected] e 109 Middle Street Portland, ME 04101 Assist Office Manager w [email protected] Stephanie Prairie s [email protected] Advantage! Director 2 Raymond Nelson Treasurer [email protected] Chad Russell We are often asked: “Why do we do, what we do?” [email protected] The answer is simple, your signals will look better and interpretations of your charts will be easier. Director 3 General Counsel George Baranowski CPSpro Advantages: Gordon L. Vaughan 1912 E. US Hwy 20, Suite 202 111 S. Tejon St., Suite 545 • No Re-Centering! No lost data! You will be able to pay more attention to the Michigan City, IN 46360 examinee and allow the state-of-the-art software take control of the channels Colorado Springs, CO 80903-2245 [email protected] • 7-Year warranty [email protected] • FREE Software support & upgrades Director 4 • Ability to record up to 13 channels Seminar Chair Sabino Martinez • Skin C onductance or Skin Resistance. Our competitors record one or the other; Michael Gougler [email protected] with us, it’s you choice! [email protected] • 24-bit analog-to-digital conversion circuitry • Medical grade LEMO and Luer inputs and connectors Director 5 Editor-in-Chief • Cardiograph supports up to 215 mm Hg Steve Duncan Mark Handler • The only company that offers Skin Potential, Voice Events, Electronic Pneumos, [email protected] [email protected] and EDA with Laboratory-Style Finger Contoured Ag-AgCl Electrodes We can truly stand by the notion that we have the most advanced polygraph system available Director 6 Managing Editor with an intuitive, user friendly design. Darryl Starks Nayeli Hernandez [email protected] [email protected] For more information, visit us at www.StoeltingCo.com Stoelting Co. 620 Wheat Lane, Wood Dale, IL 60191 • 1-800-860-9775 • [email protected] 4 APA Magazine 2016, 49(6) EDITOr’s COrnEr By Mark Handler s w e Important news about upgrading from N Associate to Member Dear APA Membership, p i h Last seminar the association voted to amend s the bylaws as they apply to membership r e status. We have had several requests from the b membership asking for clarification on the m process. Our president and president-elect asked me to send an email to help clarify the e new requirements and as a reminder to those who still would like to advance M their member status from Associate to Member, before the January 1, 2017 deadline. Between now and January 1, 2017, if you have been an Associate Member for at least three years, completed a minimum of one hundred eight (108) hours of continuing education in topics directly related to polygraph testing, if you can document conducting 200 polygraph examinations, if you have attended at least one APA seminar, and if you pass the APA qualifying examination, your membership status will be upgraded to Member. If you are an Associate Member with a four-year degree, you can upgrade between now and January 1 without taking the qualifying examination, so long as you meet the other requirements to upgrade. After January 1, 2017, you must have been an APA Associate for two years before being eligible to upgrade. To take advantage of this please email Lisa and provide your name and a good email address. President-elect Jamie McCloughan will send you a link to take the upgrade exam. This will be especially important if you do not have 60 hours of college credit because after the first of the year you will be 5 APA Magazine 2016, 49(6) required to do so and cannot take advantage of this grandfather clause. After January 1, 2017, there will be two paths to becoming a Member. Both paths will require two years of membership in the association as an Associate. 1. For those Associates who possess a 4-year college degree, you must attend one APA seminar, have 60 hours of continuing education and document that you have completed 200 polygraph examinations. 2. For those Associates who have at least 60 college credit hours, you must attend one APA seminar, have 60 hours of continuing education, document that you have completed 200 polygraph examinations, and pass an APA qualifying examination. 6 APA Magazine 2016, 49(6) AMERICAN POLYGRAPH ASSOCIATION (APA) CONTINUING EDUCATION SEMINAR CO-SPONSOR – NEW MEXICO SOCIETY OF FORENSIC POLYGRAPHERS ADVANCED REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED APA FED ID # 52-1035722 TOPICS THURSDAY - SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 2-4, 2017 Thursday 1:00 pm – 5:00 pm Friday and Saturday 8:00 am – 5:00 pm GREG MILLER, ESQ. and MARK HANDLER, APA Editor s ISLETA RESORT & CASINO From Frye to Daubert & Beyond r 11000 Broadway Blvd SE a Albuquerque, NM Courtroom Testimony: Pitfalls to Avoid To make Hotel Reservations: n Call the 1-877-747-5382 or 505-848-1999 Daubert Hearing Demonstration i Room rate: $99.00, SINGLE/DOUBLE, plus taxes, be sure to m Q&A mention Group Code #SFP0217 e Complimentary WI-FI, valet and self parking and shuttle service to WALT GOODSON – APA Chairman of the Board and from the Albuquerque International Airport S Countermeasurers All reservations must be guaranteed by a major credit card or advance deposit in the amount of one night’s lodging. Reservations not Screening Examinations & guaranteed will be automatically cancelled at the cut-off date. CUTOFF DATE for hotel reservations is 1/12/17 Individual Administering Defensible Examinations g departure dates will be reconfirmed upon check-in. (5 DAY CANCELLATION notice required) ESS n REGISTRATION FEE: Pre-paid by December 30, 2016 CONTINUING EDUCATION HOURS i $250 APA Member/Applicant When you attend this seminar, you receive up to 20 CEHs n $250 NMSFP Member* (Continuing Education Hours) approved by the American i $275 Non-Member Polygraph Association and the Federal Certification Program for a Continuing Education and Training. REGISTRATION FEE AFTER December 30, 2016 r $275 APA Member/Applicant .Tax Deductions: T $275 NMSFP Member* All expenses of continuing education (including registration fees, $300 Non-Member travel, meals and lodging) taken to maintain and improve professional skills are tax-deductible subject to the limitations set *must be a paid up member of NMFSP forth in the Internal Revenue Code. (The registration fee includes professional instruction, AMERICAN POLYGRAPH ASSOCIATION seminar materials, AM and PM Refreshment Breaks) P O BOX 8037 CHATTANOOGA, TN 37414 APA Cancellations Refund Policy: 1-800-272-8037 or 423-892-3992 Cancellations received in writing prior to 12/30/16 will receive Fax 423-894-5435 a full refund. Persons canceling after 12/30/16 will not receive a refund but will be provided with the handout material NAME BUSINESS PHONE ADDRESS__________________________________________ E-MAIL _____________________________ CITY/STATE ZIP NAME BADGE (CALLED BY) ADDITIONAL $50.00 FOR WALK-INS ( ) CHECK MADE PAYABLE TO: AMERICAN POLYGRAPH ASSOCIATION is enclosed ( ) CHARGE $_____________ TO MY: VISA ( ) MC ( ) AE ( ) Card number _________________________________________________________ (CVV2)___________EXP:___________ (CVV2 is a 3 digit number found on the back of your VISA or MC card or a 4 digit number on the front of the AE). SIGNATURE______________________________________________________________________ CES-Albuquerque, NM (Feb. 2-4, 2017) We can not possibly reach everyone who would be interested in taking part if this seminar. Please help us by making copies of the page for your co-workers and business associates. Thank you for your assistance. AMERICAN POLYGRAPH ASSOCIATION (APA) © Polygraph Examiner F CONTINUING EDUCATION SEMINAR o to CO-SPONSOR – NEW MEXICO SOCIETY OF FORENSIC POLYGRAPHERS lia Training Schedule L ADVANCED REGISTRATION IS REQUIRED L C A T PHAU FRESDD IADY #- S5A2T-1U0R3D5A7Y2,2 F EBRUARY 2-4, 2017 TOPICS / kas Thursday 1:00 pm – 5:00 pm to Friday and Saturday 8:00 am – 5:00 pm GREG MILLER, ESQ. and MARK HANDLER, APA Editor ISLETA RESORT & CASINO From Frye to Daubert & Beyond T 11000 Broadway Blvd SE r Albuquerque, NM Courtroom Testimony: Pitfalls to Avoid a To make Hotel Reservations: Call the 1-877-747-5382 or 505-848-1999 i Daubert Hearing Demonstration n American Polygraph Association Room rate: $99.00, SINGLE/DOUBLE, plus taxes, be sure to mention Group Code #SFP0217 Q&A 52nd Annual Seminar/Workshop i n Complimentary WI-FI, valet and self parking and shuttle service to WALT GOODSON – APA Chairman of the Board August 27 - September 1 g and from the Albuquerque International Airport Las Vegas, NV Countermeasurers An accurate, non-invasive technology All reservations must be guaranteed by a major credit card or advance that detects lies by analyzing eye behavior. & deposit in the amount of one night’s lodging. Reservations not Screening Examinations guaranteed will be automatically cancelled at the cut-off date. Continuing Education Seminar • Pre-employment screening, such as LEPET CUTOFF DATE for hotel reservations is 1/12/17 Individual Administering Defensible Examinations Co- Sponsor New Mexico Polygraph • Monitoring or periodic evaluations, such as PCSOT S departure dates will be reconfirmed upon check-in. (5 DAY Association e CANCELLATION notice required) ESS Frebruary 2-4, 2017 (Albuquerque, NM) m REGISTRATION FEE: Pre-paid by December 30, 2016 CONTINUING EDUCATION HOURS $250 APA Member/Applicant When you attend this seminar, you receive up to 20 CEHs $250 NMSFP Member* (Continuing Education Hours) approved by the American National Polygraph Association i n $275 Non-Member Polygraph Association and the Federal Certification Program for Continuing Education and Training. Continuing Education Seminar a REGISTRATION FEE AFTER December 30, 2016 January 16-18, 2017 (Las Vegas, NV) $275 APA Member/Applicant .Tax Deductions: r $275 NMSFP Member* All expenses of continuing education (including registration fees, s $300 Non-Member travel, meals and lodging) taken to maintain and improve professional skills are tax-deductible subject to the limitations set National Polygraph Academy *must be a paid up member of NMFSP forth in the Internal Revenue Code. Basic Examiner Courses: (The registration fee includes professional instruction, AMERICAN POLYGRAPH ASSOCIATION seminar materials, AM and PM Refreshment Breaks) April 3 - June 9, 2017 (Richmond, KY) P O BOX 8037 web: converus.com June 5 - August 11, 2017 (Amarillo, TX) CHATTANOOGA, TN 37414 APA Cancellations Refund Policy: phone: +1-801-331-8840 1-800-272-8037 or 423-892-3992 Cancellations received in writing prior to 12/30/16 will receive Sept 11 - November 17, 2017 (TBA) email: [email protected] Fax 423-894-5435 a full refund. Persons canceling after 12/30/16 will not receive a refund but will be provided with the handout material PCSOT Courses: NAME BUSINESS PHONE June 12-16, 2017 (Richmond, KY) ADDRESS__________________________________________ E-MAIL _____________________________ August 14-18, 2017 (Amarillo, TX) CITY/STATE ZIP NAME BADGE (CALLED BY) Attention School Directors Advanced Continuing Education (ACE) ADDITIONAL $50.00 FOR WALK-INS Courses:March 20-22, 2017 (Lafayette, IN) ( ) CHECK MADE PAYABLE TO: AMERICAN POLYGRAPH ASSOCIATION is enclosed If you would like to see your school’s course dates ( ) CHARGE $_____________ TO MY: VISA ( ) MC ( ) AE ( ) listed here, simply send your upcoming course schedule to [email protected] Card number _________________________________________________________ (CVV2)___________EXP:___________ (CVV2 is a 3 digit number found on the back of your VISA or MC card or a 4 digit number on the front of the AE). SIGNATURE______________________________________________________________________ CES-Albuquerque, NM (Feb. 2-4, 2017) We can not possibly reach everyone who would be interested in taking part if this seminar. Please help us by making copies of the page for your co-workers and business associates. Thank you for your assistance. 8 APA Magazine 2016, 49(6) SCHEDULE SPEAKER S Sunday, January 15, 2017 Dennis Westerman: Lieutenant West erman has 30 years of Law FUTURE SEMINAR REGISTRATION Enforcement, and currently serves as Lieutenant and Quality Assurance for one of Texas Department of Public Safety (DPS) Criminal Investigations 1:00 pm Open NPA Board Meeting TOPICS National Polygraph Association, Inc. DLaivwis Eionnfo’sr Pceomlyegnrat pPho lUygnriatsp.h H Sec hiso ocul rarnedn thlays t hines Ctrouocrtdedin faotro rA fPoAr ,T AeAxaPsP D aPnSd Members urged to attend numerous other Federal and State organizations and associations. He was P.O. Box 460672 recognized as the 2012 Texas Association LE Polygraph Investigator of the Monday, January 16, 2017 Name: _____________________ Papillion, NE 68046 Year. The National Polygraph Association, Company: ____ ______________ Matthew Mull: Lieutenant Mull has served over 20 years as a 7:45 am Open Remarks Texas Trooper and for Texas DPS. He graduated from Texas DPS in 1995 Phone: (402) 238-5528 and served in Special Crimes/Criminal Intelligence. He is a former 8:00 —10:00 Persuasive Pre-Test Inc., is dedicated to providing an Address:_______________ _____ csionocred 2in0a0to7r. fHore DcuPrSr eLnatwly EsenrfNvoersc eamat DenPttS P hoielyaogdrqaunpahrst eaarns da lnhdas i si nas Ltriuecutteedn athnet rien 10:00—10:30 Stoelting Vendor Presentation E-mail: the DPS Polygraph unit. 10:30—12:00 Persuasive Pretest (cont) Annual Seminar targeted to deliver City/State/Zip: _______________ [email protected] Gregg Mrochko: Lieutenant Mrochko received his B.A., 12:00—1:00 Lunch the highest quality of speakers and Telephone:_____________ _____ Athdem Nionristhtreaatsiot nC oouf nJutesrtdicreu Pgfr oPmolo ytghreal Uphny iPvregorgsirtayrm o f( NaPiCttTspCbu) rihngh 2 a0 n0d4 ,g raduated 1:00—3:00 Persuasive Pretest (cont) Website: administering polygraph examinations since that time. He is an adjunct 3:00—4:00 Putting Out Your Shingle instructor at (NCTC) and has instructed at NCCA. He is the Board presentation topics to our members. Email:_______h_tt_ps_:/_/w_w_w_.n_at_io_na_lp_ol_yg_ra ph.org President for the Polygraph Law Enforcement Accreditation organization and has provided advanced instruction to Senior Examiner courses in the 4:00 pm—6:00 pm Social Reception: Hosted If you have a subject topic or speaker PCSOT Training: Yes No U.S. Association by Complete Equity, Inc. Mark Holtsmaster: Sergeant Holtsmaster received his B.A Registration Cost: Economics from University of Scranton. He has served with the Tuesday, January 17, 2017 you feel would benefit the Pennsylvania State Police since 1993 and an examiner since 2008. He is an adjunct instructor at the NCTC Polygraph Program and instructed at Member: $150.00 (advance) Current Board Members NCCA. Mark has also taught advanced instructions at Senior Examiner 8:00-10:00 Federal Zone/Federal You Phase membership, please make an $175.00 (at door) Cthoeu Prseensn isny ltvhaen Uia. SS2.t aS0tien 1Pceo 7l2ic0 e1S 1s,u ehpeem rsveirisvninesga amsr othr ee& tPho aBlny g2ur0a psphoi lCnyogoreardpsihn sat or for 10:00—10:30 Lafayette Vender Presentation opportunity to speak with any of the Chairman of The Board examiners across the State. He is aMlso ea meetmibner gof the Polygraph Law 10:30—12:00 Federal Zone/Federal You Phase Enforcement Accreditation (PLEA) organization, accrediting LE polygraph 12:00—1:00 Lunch Nonmember: $ 350.00* Chip Morgan programs in the U.S. 1:00—3:00 General Business Meeting Association Board Members during Credit cards accepted only on NPA website Patty Odum, RN, MSNJ,a FnNuP-aBrCy. P1a6tt,y 1 i7s a, b1o8ar,d 2 c0er1ti7fie d Family 3:00—5:00 Plethysmograph (PLE) President Nurse Practitioner. She graduated Summa Cum Laude from Western University of Health Sciences with a M.S. in Nursing. She graduated the seminar. *NOTE: If you join thGea Nry FP. ADa vpisr ior Magna Cum Laude from the University of C olorado with a B.S. in Nursing. to the seminar you can registe r at the Mcorms.p Oredhuemns hivaes c2a2rG ey eaoasr lasd noefu nrnsuer sNpirnaugc tegixtgipoeenreiter niHnce Io nantteder nplar ol& vMi deCeddiac isnien, Oon cology, Wednesday, January 18, 2017 Vice President Geriatric and Hospice. She is currently an instructor at Marston Polygraph member price. Annual Dues are Academy in Pharmacology anLda Csh eVmeicgala Cso,u nNteermveaasdurae s. 8:00—10:00 AFMGQT & Scoring $100.00. (Application oJno stehpeh NGaPrcAia Clehctiupr eMr oprrogvainng: iCnshtirpu citsio an nfoart ioovnera 3ll5y yreeacros gant pizoelydg rtarpahin secrh oaonlsd, national 11o0::0300——1102::0300 LAiFmMeGstQonTe & V Sencodreirn Pg r(ecsoenntt)a tion website, nationalpolygraph.org. Thank You Secretary training seminarFs oanrd H coollteegel sR therosuegrhvoautt itohen Us .SC. aClaln a1d-a8 a0nd0 -M3e3xi1co. 12:00—1:00 Lunch Chip is a 1975 Backster school graduate and served as a Detective, Criminal Theodore Parker Polygraph Exam-in5e7r.3 H1e a mnadin tmainesn at itohrniv itnhge p rNivaattei oprnacatlic Pe. o Hlye -is the 1:00—1:30 Axciton Vendor Presentation past president of the National Polygraph Association, International 1:30—5:00 Pharmacology & Chemical Brotherhood of Police Officers, Boise Police Association, Idaho Fire & Mail registration and checkTr etaos:u rer Arson Investigatgorrsa apnhd sAevsesraol coithaetri oprno f2es0si1on7a.l Rasseosceiartvioantsi. o Cnhsip is a Countermeasures Court Certified Expert in Idaho and California State Courts and the US 5:00 Closing Remarks Bryant Crosby Federal Court Symsteumsst. bHee hmasa bdeeen b ay c eDrtifeiecde Inmstrbucetorr s1in6ce, 1980 and is National Polygraph Association a published author. Wednesday, January 18, 2017 P.O. Box 460672 2016 to receive Seminar Rate. Directors Melanie Javens: Melanie began employment at Complete Equity (Dedicated PCSOT Training) Papillion, NE 68046 Markets in 1988S asa rteucredptaioyn iastr.r Sihvea qlusi cakrlye m liamde ihteerd w.a y up the ranks Merion Classroom John Odum first as a word processor and then as an administrative assistant. She Erik Abel obtained her pro perty/casualty and Life/Health insurance licenses and 8:00—12:00 Peak of Tension in PCSOT began her career in sales over 25 years ago. She currently underwriters Professional LiabTihlitey 2fo0r 1S6af eStey mPrionfeasrsi oannadls ,B Puolsyignreapshsi sMts e&e Ftionregn sic 1200—5:00 PCSOT Consultants andw isi Pllr ebseid henetl dof athtr tehe eri sGk opludrcehna sNinug gggroeutp Hs. o tel & Casino, Las Vegas, Nevada. Rooms rates for the seminar is $ 59.00 per night (Sunday-Friday) excluding any applicable tax and energy surcharge. In addition the hotel charges a $20 resort fee which in- cludes many amenities normally incurred as additional charges. 9 APA Magazine 2016, 49(6)
Description: