Международный конгресс психологов в Америке (1-7 сентября 1929 г.)

17 Pages·12.028 MB·Russian

by  Лурия А.Р.

ME)KJlYHAPOJlHbII1 KOHrPECC nCI1XOJIOrOB B AMEPHKE
(1-7 CeHT516p511929 r.)
A. P. JIypUfl
Me)!{)I.YHapa)I.HbIH xonrpecc no nCHXaJIarHH B HbIO-X3BeHe non-
raTaBJI51JIC51)I.aJITa. Euie sa ron 6bIJIH rosno YCTaHaBJI'eHbl cpoxn H
MeCTa, H orpoxaoe l.fHCJIaHCCJIe)I.aBaTeJIbCKHXYl.fpe[)!{)I,eHHHH aT)I,eJIb-
HbIX nCHXOJIaraB naJIYl.fHJIH npHrJIaWeHH51. 3Ta 6bIJI nepasnt xonrpecc,
YCTpoeHHbIH B AMep'I1Ke (see socexs nepnux MHpaBblx xonrpeccos
no nCHXOJrarHH 6bIJIH B Esponey--a aMepHKaHCKa51nCHXaJIarHl.feCKa51
aCOO~Ha'l(H51rrocrapanacs, l.fTa6 3TOT xonrpecc CTaJI caMbIM 60JIbWHM
saxe-
no KOJIHl.feCTBY;Yl.faCtHHKOB, KaJIH1IeCTBY C.lI:eJIaHHbIX)I,OKJIa)I,OH,
HOCTH 3aTpoHY;TbIX npo6neM.
3TO oeccnopao Y)I,aJIaCb opranaaaropaa ci.eana, H xapaxrepn-
3YIOIII.I1e xonrpecc ~I1(PPbI aCTaBJI51IOT)I,aJIeKO aa c06aH CTaTHCTHKY
scex npeaorax nCHXOJIOrHl.feCKHXxonrpeccos: 1050 tIJIerHaBnpHHHMaJIH
B HeM Yl.faCTHe; OKOJIO)I,ByxcaT H3 HHX npO)I,eJIaJIH )I,OBOJIbHO)I,JIH-
rensnoe nyreurecrmre, H aa TOBapI1Iu.eCKHXscrpesax BO ,lI.Bape Hens-
cxoro YHHBepCHTeTa MO)!{HO6bIJIO BCIOHe,ll.eJIIOxonrpecca Ha6JIIO)I,aTb
O)!{HBJIeHHble 6eCe)I,bI WBe'H~apCKHX nCHXOJIOrOB C 5lnOHCKHMH, CO-
BeTCKHX Y1IeHbIX C nCHXaJIOraMH, npaexasunora HS I1H,lI.HH H KI1.Ta51;
6bIJIH npe)I,CTaBJIeHbI nCHXOHeBpaJIOrH I3paSHJIHH H HOBOH 3eJIaH-
]J.HH,WBeH~apHH H I1TaJIHH, KaHa)I,bI IIi Hcrramta. JlBa)I,~aTb socexs
CTpaH npHCJIaJIH CBOHX)I,eJIeraTaB, H 450 )I,OKJIa)I,OB6bIJIO sacayurano
na SaCe)I,aHH51Xaroro orponaoro H HHTeHCHBHO pa60TaBWerO, He-
CMaTp51aa HCKJIIOl.fHTeJIbHYIO)!{apy, xonrpecca.
O)I,HO nepexacnenae 'ceK~HH, nOCB51llJ,eHHbIXOT)I,eJIbHbIM npa6JIe-'
MaM cospeaeaaoa nCHXOJIOrHH, 3aH51JIO6bI )I,JIHHHbIH CTIHCOK;3)I,eCb
6bIJIH 3aCe)I,aHH51,rrocaamennue nCHXaJIarHH )!{HBaTHblX H npHKJIa)I,-
HOH ncnxooormr, reoperacrecnoa H 3KCne'PHM'eHTa'JIbHOHnCHIXOJIOI'HH
H H3Yl.feHHIOxapaxrepa, HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHbIM TeCTaM H np06JIeMe MbIW-
JIeHH51, Ca~HaJIbHOH H cpaBHHTeJIbHOH nCHXaJIOrHH, np06JIeMe JIiI1l.f-
HaCTH H MOTHBOB, nCI1XaraJIbBaHHl.feCKoMY perpnexcy H H3Yl.feHl!1.l0
)I,BH)!{eHH51rnaa npa l.fTeHHH. nCI1XaJIarH caxux pa3JIHl.fHbIX CTpaH
6*
81 A.P.J[YPH5J
.lI,aJIH snecs pe3YJIbTaTbI CBOI1X I1CCJIe.ll,OBaHI1H,11 pacnasuraacs aa
p5IA TeMaTI14eCKI1XCI1Mn0311YMOBCbe3.l1,npe.ll,CTaBJIHJI.lI,eHCTBI1TeJIbHO
xouraoe spenmue Me)!(.lI,YHapO.ll,HOHHaY4HOH xoonepauaa.
GOBeTCKa5I,lLeJIerail1.l151I rrpaexana B HbIO-tlOPK aa HeCKOJIbKO.lI,HeH
.lI,OOTKpbITI1H KOHrpeCCa 11I1MeJIa .lI,OCTaT04HOBpeMeHI1, 4T06bI CO-
CTaBHThCe6e npeztcraaneuae 0 TOM 06lll.eM tpoae, aa I<OTOPOMnpo-
TeKaJIa BCHpaoora Cbe3,ZI,a.
B .aKa.ll,eMI14eCKOH)!(H3HI1 <lMepI1KaHCKOrO YHI1BepCI1TeTa ncaxo-
JIOrl1H 3aHI1MaeT 04eHb 3Ha411TeJIbHOeMeCTO; ee paCCMaTpl1BaIOT KaK
,lLI1CH,l1nJIHHY,.lI,aIOlll.YIO 06lll.YIO rrO.ll,rOTOBKY HapH.lI,Y C 6110JI0fl1eH,
<p113110JI0fl1eH,COl1.I10JI0fl1eH;C npyron CTOPOHbI-Ha aee CMOTP5ITKaK
na rrpaKTI14eCKYIO HaYKY, HenOCpe.ll,CTBeHHOCBH3aHHYIO C aana-raxa
BOCllI1TaHI15I.3TO onpeneaaer cosepureaao cneuadiauecxoe rrOJIO)Ke-
Axepaxe:
uae rrCI1XOJIOfl1HB oaa pa36HTa na .lI,Ba OT.lI,eJIbHbIXMac-
CHBa, J{a)K.lI,bIHH3 KOTOPbIX3aHHMaeT B aMepHKaHCKOHHaYKe H )K113HI1
3Ha411TeJIbHOeMeCTO, HO 06a H30JII1pOBaHbI zrpyr OT npyra, senyr
He3aBI1CHMOecyurecrsoaanne H xapaK'I'epI13YIOTCH BrrOJIHe caMOCTOSI-
l1eJIbHbIM pa3BI1TUeM. [1CHXOJIOrHH, KaK CPI1JIOColcpcKaHHaYKa (npa
TOM caMOM lllHPOKOM 'rrOHHMaHI1I1 CPHJIOCOCPI1Hx,axoe npWIHHTO 11
B repMaHCKI1X YHI1BepCHTeTa:x), BKJII04a,eT B CBOH COCTaBace JIa6o-
paropao-reoperasecxae H3bICKaHHHnaz; )KI1BOTHbIMH11JIIO.lI,bMH;neaa-
rornuecxas rrCHXOJIOfl1HCTaBHT CBoeH sanasea 06JIer4aTb 11 pauao-
HaJIH3HpOBaTb npouecc BocnHTaHH5I, BHOCHB Hero sees TOT KOMrrJIeKC
npaeaos TeCTl1pOBaHI1H }[ npaKTI14eCKOro H3Mepe'HI1H HHTeJIJIeKTa,
KOTOPbIfI Y Hac BKJII04aeTCH B nporpaMMbI ne.ll.OJIOrl14eCKHX 06cJIe-
.lI,OBaHI1H;npa OTCYTCTBHI1nenoaoraa KaK Cne!l1.l1aJI'bHO'H,njIiCll.l1nJI'H-
HbI-BeCb 3TOT KOMnJIeKC sonpocos COCTaBJI5IeT B AMepI1Ke< npo-
rpaavy nenaroravecxoa nCI1XOJIOfl1H.
3TH .lI,Ba cexropa HBJI5IIOTCSIOCHOBHbIMIf M0lll.HbIMIi MaCCI1BaMI1
nepaua
aMepl1KaHCKOHrrCI1XOJIOrI1H; H3 HHX C03.l1.aJIpSI.lI,Cnel1.HaJIbHbIX
TeOpeTI14eCKHX HaCTpOeHI1H (3TO CJIOBOnonxoznrr K aMepHKaHCKOH
nayxe 60JIbllle, 4eM CJIOBO«Te4eHHe»), H B n~pBYIO 04epe.ll.b-6 Hx 3-
B110 P113M; BTOPOH pa3BI1JI He06bI4aHHYIO no CBoeH OpraHI130BaH-'
HOCTH H CBoeMY Ma'ClllT3I6y pa60TY no nCHXOJIOr.!1,4eCK'HM .113-
Mep eH1151M, OXBaTI1Bllll1M TbICH411 lllKOJI H .lI.eCHTKHBa)KHeHlllHX
rrCHXOJIOrH4eCKHX06JIaCTeH. 11 O.ll.HaKO3TIi zraa MaCCHBaCYlll.eCTBYIOT
B AMepHKe 6e3 BC5IKOrOn04TH KOHTaKTa'.lI.pyr Cnpyroa, 4aCTO HrHO-
pHpyH B3aHMHoe"CYlll.eCTBOBaHHe.B Hsro-Hopxe, aa 120-H YJIIil1.e, aa
Teppl1TOpHH KOJIYM6HHCKoro YHHBepCHTen, CTOHT.lI,Ba3.l1,aHHH:[1CI1-
.XOJIOrH4eCKHH HHCTHTYT C ero I1HTepeCHbIMH JIa60paTOpH5IMHI rro
r.
1 B ee cocras BXOilIiJlIi: I1. Hi Lllnaasp eaa, B. M. 50pOBCKH", C.
I' eJIJIepill Tej;j H H A. P. JI YPHs.
ME)f(.D.YHAPO.D.HbJP! KOHrPECC nCHXOJlorOB 85
06~eii:, npHKJIa)I:HO'ii:H CpaBHHTeJIbHoii: nCHXO'JIOrHHH Teacher's col-
lege-c. 3HaMeHIiTbIMH pa60TaMH Top H,Uaii:Ka no nCHXOJIOrHqe-
CKHM H3MepeHH5!M, 60raTbIMH TeCTOJIOrHqeCKHMHH. nelI.arOrHqeCKHM!H
zipyr-a,
HCCJIe.lI.OBaHH;5!M,H3..lI.aHH5! CT05!T .lI.pyr nporns H H3 OKOH
zrpyroro:
O.lI.HOrO BH.lI.HbI OKHa HO pa60THHKH nCHXOJIorHqeCKOrO
HHcTHTyra HaBp5!.lI.JIll xorzta 3arJI5!.lI.bIBalOTB Teacher's college, KOTO-
PbIii: no H{CMHeHHlO3aHHMaeTC5!npUKJIa.lI.HbIMHTeCTaMH, a He HaCT05l-
me'ii: nCHXOJIOme'ii:; pa60THHKlI Teacher's college OOBCe'MHe mrrepe-
CYlOTC5ITeM, qTO npOHCXO,UHTB nCHX'OJIOrHqeCKOMHHcTHTyTe, 3aHH-
MalOlll.eMC5I sonpocaaa He-)!{H3HeHHbIMH, qJl1JIOCOCPCKHMHa,6CTpaKT-
HbIMH. Me)!{.lI.Y 060HMH cexropava-vpeaxaa rpaunua, H MHe npHXO-
.lI.HJIOCbBH.lI.eTb 3T)' rpaHHU;y BO scex YHHBepCHTeTaX (J.1eJIbC~OM,
rapBa.lI.CKOM, npHHCTOHCKOM), C nCHXOJIOmqeCKHMlf HCCJIe,ZI:OBaHH5IMH
KOTOPbIX MHe npHllIJIOCb 3HaKOMHTbC5!: Psychology H Educational
psychology BXO.lI.51TB pasnue CHCTeMbI.lI.HCU;HnJIHH,pa3BHBalOT CBOH
pacryr zrpyr
MeTO.lI.bI, He3aBHCI1MO OT .apyra.
51
He CKa3aJI 6bI, qTO aMepHKaHCKHe nCHXOJIOrHqeCKHe HHCTHTY-
TbI (BXO.lI.51lll.HeB COCTaB CPHJIOcocpCKoro HJIH aHTpOnOJIOrHqeCKOrO
IJ;HKJia .lI.HCU;HnJIHH)He HMelOT csoero JIHu;a. MHe npmUJIOCb 6bITb
B u;eJIOMP5!.lI.eTaKHX HHCTHTYTOB,H TO ooiuee, qTO 51suaec H3 3THX
noceurenajr, YKJIa,ll,bIBa'eTc5IB H3BecTHYlO KapfJ'HHY,HeCOMHemIO xapax-
'repuyio .lI.JI5IopraHH3aU;HH aMepHKaHcKoii: nCHXOJIOrHH HHCTI1TYTOB.
Ilpescae
BcenQl-3Haql'rreJIbHa'51 qaCTb 3THX HHCTHTYTOB HeCOMHeHHO
51
npoHHKHYT3 nacrpoennew 6HX3BHOpI13Ma. He pellIHJIC5I ObI rosoprrn.
06 aMepHKaticKoM OHX3BHOpJ13Me,KaK 0 llIKOJI'e, KaK 0' HanpaBJIe'HHH;
Y 6HX3BHopH3Ma reneps HeT caoero oprannsauaoauoro uearrpa,
csoero U;eHrpaJIbHOfO MeTO.lI.a, CBoeR 3aMKHYTaH H O.lI.HOP0.I/..HoiC1:H-
CTeMbI H H.lI.eii:; ysensre, csnrarounre ,ce6516HX3BHopHCTaMH., B KOH-
KpeTHbIX HCCJIe.lI.OBaHH5!XfOBOP5!T na pa3HbIX 5!3bIKaX, npanepxor-
BalOTC5I pa3HbIX CPHJIOCOCPCKHBX3fJI5I.lI.OB,BH.lI.51Tnepe.n nCHXOJIOfHeii:
pasaue sana-m. YOTCOHa (Watson), XeHTepa (Hunter), Beii:/c-
Ca (Weiss) H 313 1lIJIH (Lasch ley), KOHeqHO, HH npa KaKHX YCJIOBH5IX
HeJIb35! npHqHCJIHTb K O.lI.HOMYTeqeHHlO. ECJIH qTO 06be.ll.HH5!eT HX-
3TO He llIKOJIa, a 06JIaCTb HCCJIe.lI.OBaHH5HI HCCJIe.lI.OBaTeJIbCKHena-
CTpOeHH5I.B OCHOBepa60T Ka)!{.lI.OfOH3 HHX JIe)!{HT COrJIaCHe B TOM,
qTO He C03HaHHe H cy6beKTHBHbIii: MHP, a' noseneane 5!BJI5!eTC5nIpen-
MeTOM HCCJfe)l:OBaHH5!.ll.JI5! nCHXOJIOfa. K 3TOMY sneumeay nose-
.ll:eHHlOOH MO)!{eT.nO,UXO,UHTbC JIlo6bIMH MeTo,UaMH, nepeuocs crena
H OnbIT 300nCHXOJIOfHH, H MaTepHaJIbI crapux nCHXOJIOfHqeCKHX
HCCJIe.lI.OBaHHii:,nOCKOJIbKY OHH HMeJIH .lI.eJIOH C 06beKTHBHoii: CTO-
Ilpa
POHOii: nOBe,UeHH5!(cp. «BbIpa3HTeJIbHa51 MeTO,UHKa»By H,UTa).
scex 3TOM-OH .ll.OJI)!{eH OCTaBaTbC5I HCCJIe.lI.OBaTeJleMnOBe.ll.eHH5I,
06beKTHBHbIX peaKUjHM q'eJIOBe'Ka,YCJIOBHii:, orrpenensnoumx HX pas-
86 A. P.JIYPlffl
BHTHe" BOCrrHTaHHe,YCTaHOBJIeHH5IHaBbIKOB, rrOCT05IHHbIX«CTaHAapT-
HbIX)) peaKIJ,HH:opraaaaaa (reaction pattern). Bee 3TO He C03AaeT
HarrpaBJFeHH5I(H60 3AeCb euie ner 0611J,HOCTlIB Pa3PeIII eHHH arax
sanas), HO onpeneaser Kpyr, 06JIaCTb HCCJIe.lIJOiBaHHH1,1 aror Kpyr
HCCJIe)l.OBaHHHM: bI acrpesaex B 3HaqHTeJIbHOM q11CJIeaMepHKaHCKHX
nC11XOJIOr11qeCKHXHHCTHTYTOB.HH O)I.HHH3 HHX He HBJIHeTCHHHCTH-
ryTOM, lJ,eJIHKOMCTOHIIJ,HMaa n03HIJ,HHXKaKOH:-HH6Y)I.b,IllKOJIbI; «)I.eMO-
,
KpaTH3M)) aMepHKaHCKHX nayuaux yqpe)K)I.eHHH: qallJ,e scero CBO)l.HTCH
K HaHBHOMY nOJIO)KeHHIO, qTO HaYKa )I.OJI)KHa HBJIHTbCH CHCTeMOH:
nOJIO)KI1TeJIbHbIX 3MrrHpHqeCKHX 3HaHHH:, B KOTOPbIX npanuanaans-
nue, CPHJIOcocpCKaeYCTa'HOBKHBHlOCHTJIlIIllb Bp!e'.lI;'HbrAarrpaopaae:
orpoxace 61~bIllHHCTBO aMepilfKaHCKHX nC'lfXOJI'Of'OB-i1'C'CJIe)I.OBaTeJIeit
CqHT·aIOTce6H «CBo60)I;HbIM'Hl)01' KaKOr,o-JFH6o,onpenexenaoro CPHJIO-
corpcxoro B3fJIHACl',OT npHHa'AJI'e)KHOCT11K KaKOMY-H116Y)l.bnCH'XOJIO-
rHQeCKOMY HarrpaBJIeHHIO,-H B aMep11KaHCKHX 11HCT11ryTaX MO)KHO
HaH:THrrpe)I.CTaBHTeJIeH:COBepIlleHHO pa3JI11qHbIXYCTaHOBOK11n'acrpoe-
HHH; O)l.HaKO-B 60JIbIlIHHCTBe lI3 HHX npoi6JFeMbI nO~Be:AeHHHC1'OH1'
B OCHOBepa60TbI; ana-nrrem.naa qaCTb pa60THHKOB (qTO oc06eHHO
xapaxrepno )I.JIH aMepHKaHCKHX HCCJIe)I.OBaTeJIeH:)rrpOBO)l.HT CBOH
pa60TbI O)I.HOBpeMeHHOH na qeJIOBeKe H aa )KHBOTHbIX; JIy.•.I•lIHe axe-
pHKaHCKHe HCCJIe)I.OBaHHH(nanp. pa60TbI no HaBbIKaM JI3IlIJIH 11XeH-
Tepa) 6bIJI11rronyxenu HMeHHOTaKHM MeTO)I.OM,npa K01'OPOMrpaanuu
300nCHXOJIIOrHH11nCHXOJIOr'J11qHeJIOBeKa CrJIa)KHBaIOTCH,H ncnxocrorna
nepepacraer B 06IIJ,yIO nayxy 06 06'beKTHBHbIX MexaHH3Max nose-
AeHH5I.
PH.ll.OMC 3THM MaCCHBOMpa601', 4HC1'O HCCJIe.ll.OBaTeJIbCKHXr,eo-
peTHqeCKHX B CBOHX OCHOBax, CTOHIIJ,HXaa rpanane nCHXOJIOrH'H:H
6HOJFOrH4eCKHxHaYK,-c He06blqaH:HOH:opraHH30BaHHocTbIO pa3BHJICH
H BTOpOH:orpoxaua MaCCHBaaepasaacxax nCHXOJIOrH~eCKHXHCCJIe-
AOBaHHH,C1'OJIb»ce xapaxrepaun AJIHaMepHKaHCKOH:npaKTHKH, CKOJI:b-
KO nepsun xapaxrepen AJIH axepaxaucxon reopaa,
IlCHXOJIOrHH He06blqaH:HO IlIHPOKO 3aXBaTHJIa B AMepHKe pHA
npaKTHqeCKHX, nenaroranecxnx 06JIaCTeH:. Ka)KAa51 IllKOJIa rrbITae1'C51
paIJ,HOHaJIH3HpOBaTb, nCHXOJIOmqeCKM oriocaoaars CBOH:nezarorase-
CKHHnpouecc: aasonu nexoropsrx IlITaTOB (nanp. MaCCaqY3eTc) npen-
nHChIBaIOT BbI)I.eJI51Tbocooue rpyrrriu )I.JIHyqeHHKOB, np05lBJI51IOIIJ,HX
onpeAeJIeHHYIO crerreas OTCTaJIOCTH,nepexO)I.51IlJ,YIOqepe3 YCTaHoB-
neaasre )l.JI51HHTeJIJIeKryaJIbHOH: HOPMbI rpanauu. 3TO orrpezreaaer
He06xo)I.HMOCTb nCHXOJIOrHqeCKOrO06CJIe)I.OBaHHHBO BCeH:cera IIIKOJ,I
H HaAO 3aMe1'H1'b, qTO TaKa51panora oprauaaoeaaa B AMepHKe HC-
KJIIOqHTeJIbHOxopouro. HeCKOJIbKO JIeT TOMy Ha3a)I., xorzta 3TO )l.BH-
)KeHHe 6bIJIO eure nHOHepCKHM,-3a)I.aqH npOH3BO)I.H1'b TaKHe 06cJIe-
.ll.OBaHH516bIJIH nopysenu CnelJ,HaJIbHbIM <<flepe.ll.BH)KHbIMKJIHHHKaM)),
Mf;/KD,YHAPOD,HbIU KOHrPECC T1CI1XOJlorOB 87
'e3.l1.HBIllHMH3 ropo.aa B ropon H npOH3BO.ll.HBIllHMHHTeJIJIeKryaJIbHOe
oocaenosanae .lI.eTe'HCOi()lTBeTCTBYIOIIr;HuXrxoor, B Te'IeHHe' nOCJIe.n:;iHlX
,JIeT nOJIO)l{eHHeH3MeHHJIOCb,H nO'ITH npa Ka)l{.lI.OHIllKOJIe H Ka)l{.lI.OM
.lI.eTCKOMyspeacnenan cyurecrsyer «nCHXOJIOr», aa .lI.OJIexoroporo
.JIe)l{HT TeCTHpOBaHHe ncex jI.eTeH, onpeneaeuae HX YMCTBeHHoro
n.
YPOBH5I, IllKOJIbHOH npHrO.ll.HOCTHH T.
COBepIlleHHO nOH5ITHO,'ITO TaKHe IllHpOKHe aanaxa lIOTpe60BaJIH
H cepsesaoro HaY'IHOrO 060CHOBaHH5I np06JIeMbI n CHX0 JI0r H'I e-
P
CKHX H3Me eHHH, iIf M'O)l{HOCKa3aTb, 'ITO HILr.ll.esra rrporineaa He
naurna TaI{KX IllHPOKHX CPOPMyrJIy6JIe'fLHOHpa3pa60TK.H, KaK BaMepH-
KaHCKOHnenarornsecxon nCHXOJIOrILIL nOCJIe pa60T Top H.lI.a'HKa
M'O)l{HOcxaaam., 'ITO aMepHl<:aHCKa5rIrCIiXOJlOrH5IB 3Ha'IHTeJIbHOHCBO-
eH 'IaCTH 5IBJI5IeTC5IH3M'ep5IIO~le'iI nCHx'OJIOrneH. Heotiu-
'IaHHO TOHKHe MeTO.ll.bI Ii3MepeHH5I nCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX CPYHKlI,HH,IHX
nO.ll.p06HblH H TO'IHbIH MaTeMaTH'IeCKHHaHaJIH3,npaxeaenae crannap-
TH30BaHHblX TeCTOBaa orpoxmoa MaTepIfaJIe H nrapoxoe HCnOJIb30Ba-
HHe KOppeJIaTHBHOro H3Y'IeHH5I nCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX npOll,eCCOB,-BOT
'ITO CTaJIOOCHOBHbIMH Cnell,HcpH'IeCKHM.lI.JI5Isroro lI,HKJIaavepaxan-
,CKHXHCCJIe.ll.OBaHIiH1.13Mep5IIO~a5InCHXOJIOrH5Ipacnpocrpanana CBOH
narepecu H .lI.aJIeKOsa npenensr H3MepeHH5I IiH'T'e'JIJIeKTaH oaapen-
HOCTH.Y'IeCTb see rpaxropu rrenarorusecxoro npouecca, Bblpa3HTb
HX B TO'IHbIX uarppax, YCTpaHHTbcoBceM CJIY'IaHHble, HeY'ITeHHble
cpaKTopbI H CTPOHTb socrraraaae C OTKpbITbIMH rJIa3aMH If TO'IHO
aazta-nr,
,y'ITeHHbIMH YCJIOBH5IMH-BOTOCHOBHble CT05I~He nepen 3TOH
nCHXOJIOrHeH,-H ee .lI.aHHble HaIllJI.H eerie npaaeneuae B illIiJPOKOH
nenaroraxecxoa npaxrnxe. B anepaxancxax (KaK H BO BC5IKHX)IllKO-
zrax npouserana 3K3aMeHbI, HO B 3K3aMeHe OCTaBaJIaCbncer.aa Macca
HeY'ITeHHOro, CJIY'IaHHoro. 113Mep5IIO~a5I npHKJIa.ll.Ha5I rrCHXOJIOrH5I
rrOCTaBHJIa aonpoc 06 H3MepeHHH TPY.ll.HOCTHnpe.ll.b5IBJI5IeMbIX na
3K3aMeHe sonpocos H-rrpOBe.ll.5I 60JIbiliHe CJIO)l{HbleHCCJIe.ll.OBaHH5I-
npem-aanse-
nOJIY'IHJIa lI,HCPPbI,crporo xapaxrepasyioutae TPY.ll.HOCTb
MbIX na 3K3aMeHe sonpocos. CTaH.lI.apTH3all,H5Ine.aarornxecxoro Ma-
repnana KocHYJIaCb H rrpaBOITHCaHH5I,H OTPbIBKOB.lI.JI5I'ITeHH5I, H
aana-r,
MaTeMaTH'IeCKIiX H B pe3YJIbTaTe scero aroro lI,HKJIaHCCJIe.ll.O-
rreztaroraxe-
BaIIHi1 auepaxanuu pacnonararor Terrepb 3Ha'IHTeJIbHbIM
·CKHMMaTepHaJIOM,pacnOJIO)l{eHHbIMB crporo MaTeMan{'IeCKH ouenea-
HOM nopazxe TPY.ll.HOCTH.
3TH .lI.BalI,HKJIa COCTaBJI5IIOT.lI.BeBa)l{HeHiliHe rpynnu axepasaa-
-'CII:HXnCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHXHCCJIe.ll.OBaHHHK,a)l{.lI.a5IH3 H'HX HMeeT CBOH,
.xapaxrepaue .lI.JI5IaMepHKaHCKOH HayKH YCTaHOBKHH .lI.OCTH)l{eHH5I;
-ooe OHH COCTaBJI5IIOT06~HH CPOHaMepHKaHCKOHHaY'IHOH MbICJIH.
HeCKOJIbroo B C110pOHeOT 06~errCHXOJIOrH'IeCKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBaHHH
,CT05IT aMepHKaHCKHe pa60TbI no rrCHXorraTOJIOrHH.TaK ace, KaK H
•
88 A. P.JlYPHfl
Ka)l{.ll.a51H3 YKa3aHHbIX JIHHHH HCCJIe.ll.OBaHHH,aMepHKaHCKa51nCHXO-·
na:TOJIOrH5I pa3BlfBaeTCSI CaMOCTOSlT'eJIbHOHI nOlITH He CBH3aH<l HH
Oaa
C 06meH, HH C nenar-ornaecxoji nCHXOJIOrHeH. nOqTH He 3aHM-
crsyer HHqero OT 3KcnepHMeHTaJIbHO-nCHXOJIOrnQeCKHX HCCJIe.ll.OBa-
HHt'I (H B 3TOM OHa 3HaqHTeJIbHOorcraer OT HeKOTopbIX eBponeHCKHX
nCHXOnaTOJIOrHqeCKHXJIa60paTopHH), OHa npHMeH5IeT xacro npaxra-
xoropsre asrparioransr
xecxae MeTO.ll.bI, B TeCTOJIOflH"feCKO'Hnpaxrnxe,
HO CneQH¢HqeCKHM .ll.JISIaMepHKaHCKOHnCHXOnaTOJIOrHHSlBJI5IeTCSHIe
3T1O..l1,n::eSI lICHXHqeCKOH rarnensr, HCCJI·e.ll.0BaHl15lKOHKpeTHOH
JIHqHOCTHH 06pa30BaHHSI xapaKTepa--BOT TOT Kpyr np06JIeM, KOTO-
pue
60JIbllIe scero 3aHHMaIOT axepaxaacxoro nCHXOnaTOJIOra. 3.ll.eCb
HCnOJIb3yeTcSI B 3HaqHTeJIbHOH CTeneHH TeopHSI nCHXOaHaJIH3a; HO'
na aMepHKaHCKOHnonse OHa nperepnesaer saasarensnsre H3MeHeIHH5I;
ee nbITaIOTCSICBSl3aTbC llIHpOKHMH 6HOJIOrHqeCKHMH0600meHHSlMH,
060CHOBaTb ¢H3HOJIOrHqeCKH, C6JIH3HTb C HCCJIe.ll.OBaHlH5IMH¢H3lH'O-
JIOrHH a¢¢eKTOB, p'a60TaMH, CBSl3aHHbIMHC H3yqeHHeM .ll.eSlTeJIbHOCiH
aBTOHOMHOHHepBHOH ClfCTeMbI,--H B rpynax aMeplfKaHCKHX ncaxo-
nepepaoaruaaercs,
naTOJIOrOBnClfXOaHaJIH3 nepepacraer B llIlfPOKYIO.
6HOJIOrHqeCKYIO H HeBpOJIOrHQeCKH-o'6ocHoBaHHYIO CHCTeMY 3HaHlfH
o JIlfqHOCIlf.
DO)l{aJIyH--3THM lfCqepnbIBaIOTCSI OCHOBHbleJIHHHHrex avepaxaa-
xoropue
CKHXnCHXOJIOrlf.qeCKHXHCCJIe.ll.OBaHlfH, ynHpaIOTCSI B reope-
rnuecxae, oouienayuuoro 3HaqeHHSIBbIBO.ll.bI1. 11 HHTepeCHO: B HaYKe
o JIlfqHOCTH, B aanaue npocnennrs ee passarae, ee xapaxrep, ·ee·
.ll.eSlTeJIbHOCTbB 06meCTBe,--B 3TOH HaYKe C6JIH)l{aIOTCSInee 3TH rpa
oropsaunuua
06JIaCTlf, npaxrnsecxn 6bIBllIlfe COBepmeHHO .ll.pyr OT
npyra, opraHlf3aQHOHHO He lfMeBllIlfe .ll.pyr C .ll.pYroM naxaxoro KOH-
Bupacraer
TaKTa. H.ll.eSl06be.ll.lfHeHlfSl 3THX .ll.HCQlfnJIlfH B O)I.UHKOM-
nJIeKC--KOMnJIeKC HayK 0 QeJIOBeKe, H C03.ll.aHlfSlTex opraHH3aQHOH-
HbIX yCJIQBlfH, npn KOTOPbIX3TOT KOMnJIeKCMor 6bI 6bITb scecropoaue
If CHHTeiJiQeC~H:li3YQeH. l1ieJIbCKlfH Y:HlfBepc.lfTeT, Ka)l{'e'T'C5I,nepBblH
H3 YHHBepCHTeTOBAvepaxa, KOTOPbIH BCTaJI na 3TOT nyrs. Ha ero
yxce
reppnropaa CTPOlfTCSI60JIbllIOe anaane HHCTHTYTa cosepurenno-
nosoro rnna, KOTOPbIH .ll.OJI)l{eH.ll.aTb YCJIOBlfSl.ll.JISIpa3BHTHSI 3TOH
ClfHTeTlfQeCKOHnayxn o QeJIOBeK'e.Institute of Iiuman Relation-e-rare.
, Ha3bIBaeTCSI3TOT HOBbIHlfHCTlfTYT (MbI naex ero 3CKH3 ua pHC. 1),--
I
OH .ll.OJI)l{eH6Y.ll.eT 3aHSlTbCSIlf3YQeHlfeM JmQHOCTHco scex OCHOBHbIX
r
ee cropon: nClfXOJIOrHQeCKHHIf reHeTHQeCKHHOT.ll.eJIbI(n-pa 33 eJIJI
H .llon zc) 6Y.ll.YT 3aHSlTbI 3KCrIepHMeHTaJIbHOH xapaxrepacrnxon
B3pOCJIOro If peceuxa: OT.lI.eJInCHXOOlfOJIOrHlf (.II.-p 113PKC) oY.leT
1 Mbi He OCT3HaBJIIIBaeMClI3J\eCb na aaepnxaacxon nCHXOTeXHHKe,HMelOlllelt TaM
cosepuremro cneuaoasecxue <jJ0PMbl.
MEJKD,YHAPOll,HbIH KOHFPECC nCHXOJIOFOB 89'
HCCJIe.II.DBaTbnDBe.II.eHHe aHTpDnDH.II.HbIX D6e3b5lH, ':)TDH npen-crynenn
lJeJIIOBeKa, a -COUHDJIDrHlJeCK.HJ1D:T.II.eJI 3aHMeTC51.II.aJKe CDUHOJIDr.HlJe-
CKHMH np'06JI'eMa'MH. K 3TOMY HHCT'IHyry, KOTDpbIH Y)f{e CeHlJa'Cpac-
noaaraer aecswa 3HalJHTeJIbHhIM
K anHT aJI0 M- 0 K 0 JI 0 14000 000 ~-------- ..-.--.-.~-..-.--
.II.OJIJIaPDB, npHCDe.II.HH5IeTC5IueJIa51
rpynna BcnDMDraTeJIhHbIX YlJpe)f{.II.e-
HHH, CB5I3aHHhIX npexoie ncero C
erD nCHXHaTpHlJeCKHM H HeBpDJID-
rHlJeCKHM DT.II.eJIDMH CDCTaBJI51IO-
llJ,HMTO, lJTDHDCHT B 3TDH CHCTeMe
«Human Welfare grDup» (npoexr
3THX lJaCThIO Y)f{e nocrpoenaux
3.II.aHHH MbI .II.aeM na pHC. 2.) BC51
CHCTeMa B ueJIDM CD3.II.aeT cosep-
ureno HCKJIIOlJHTeJIhHhle no 6DraT-
CTBY y~JIDBH51.II.JI51H3YlJeHH51lJeJID-
BelJeCKDH JIHlJHDCTH,H MhI 6Y.II.eMC
HHTepecDM D)f{H.II.aTh,KaK pasoaser-
C513TD HDBDe 6DJIhWDe HalJHHaHHe.
O.II.HaKD MD)f{HD JIH TeM caMhIM
"t.;;:;:===---~-_..,.../;~.~
ClJHTaTh, lJTD rrD.II.JIHHHD HaYlJHOe
H3YlJeHHe lJeJIDBelJeCKDH JIHlJHDCTH ~~---. .
XDTh CKDJIhKD HH6Y.II.h oriecnexeno PIIC. 1
B AMepHKe?
Onem. cepseauue H rJIy6DKHe npHlJHHbI 3aCTaBJI51IOTHac CHJIbHD
CDMHeBaTbC5I B 3TDM. CDBepweHHD nDH5ITHD, lITD CHHTeTHlJeCKa51
HaYKa 01 JIHlJHDCT'HMD)f{5T pa3BHBaTbC51'fIOIJIbKIQBI nJIalHOBOM!lDP05l.II.Ke,
Pllc.2
TDJIbKD B CHCTeMe, lJaCTH KDTDPDH cnaauu e.II.HHDi1D6llJ,ei1 MeTD.II.DJID-
mei1. MbI BnDJIHe MbICJIHJIH pa3BHTHe TaKDH HayKH B YCJIDBH51XHa-
urero CDI03a, H TDJIbKD lITD 3aKDHlJHBWHHC5IBceCDI03HbIH Cbe3.II. no
nDBe.II.eHHIOxenoaexa .II.eMDHCTpHpDBaJI,HaCKDJIbKDnJID.II.DTBDPHDBHe-
•
90 A. P. JIYPHfl. .
ceune
e,lI,HHOH:HaY4HOH: MeTO,lI,OJIOrHH-MaTepHaJIHCTH4eCKOH: ,lI,HaJIe~
THKH-B HayKH, 3'HLI1MalOw.HeC5ILIeJIOBeK:OM.
YiMeHHo 3THX YCJIOBHH:e)lHl-IO}1 MeTO)lOJIOrHLIeCl<OH:OCHOBbI HE
B COBpeMeHHOH: aMep1HKaHCKOH:HaYKe. IlparMa11I13M, HaCKB03b npe
mlTaBWHH: see aMepIIKaHCKHe HCCJIe,lI,OBaHH5(IMbI rOBopHM 0 rex 11
HHX, K0110pble TaK HJIH I1HaLIe CB5I3aHbl C nCHXOJIOnreH:), OCTaBJI5IE
qmJIOCO<pCKHeYCTaHOBKH H 06W.YIO MeTO,lI,OJIOrHlOna «JIHLIHOeYCMC
rpeane» Ka)!{,lI,OrO pa60THHKa. «<PHJIOC0<pH5I-3TO Moe LIaCTHoe ,lI,eJI<
M0I1 y6e)!{,lI,eHH5I He BJIH5IIOTna MOIO HaYKY»-C TaKHMH YTBep)!{,lI,{
HH5IMI1MHe npHWJIOCb BCTpeLIaTbC5ILIYTb JIH He B Ka)!{,lI,OH:anepaxai
CKOH:JIa60paTopHH. MHe BCTpe4aJIHCb Y4eHble, C Y,lI,OBJIeTBOpeHHe
rOBopHBWHe, -rro OHH «3KJIeKTI1KH», ,lI,YMa513THM no.a-repxnyn., 4r
OHI1 CBo60,lI,HbI OT BC5IKOH:npe,lI,B351TOCTHB HaYLIHOM I1CCJIe,lI,OBaHHl
COBepweHHO nOH5ITHO, LITO npn TaKHX YCTaHOBKax Ka)!{,lI,a51naoop:
TOpH5I npespauraercs B ll.HKJI MaJIO CB5I3aHHbIX,lI,pyr C .il.PyroM Tel
06be,lI,HHeHHbIX paase npaKTHLIeCKHMH 3a,lI,aLIaMH,,lI,a euie TOH neoco:
HaHHofl-H rrJIOXOH-<pI1JIOCO<pHe}l, KOTOpa51 CTHXHHHO npOHHKaeT
Ka)!{,lI,Oe HCCJIe,lI,OBaHHe.YiMeHHo 3TO OTCYTCTBl1e e,lI,HHOHMeTO,lI,OJI<
rH4eCKOtl YCTaHOBKH, KOTOpa51B YCJIOBI151XrOCrrO,lI,CTBYIOW.eHB OKP;
)!{eHHH 6yp)!{ya3HOH: <pHJIOCO<pHl1HeH36e)!{HO sener K rrpOCaLII1BaHI1
Hal1BHbIX 11,lI,eaJIHCT114eCKHKXOHll.enll.HH:,-HMeHHO 3TO C03,lI,aeTYCJlOBII
xpaitne
BHyTpeHHe He6JIarorrpH5ITHble ,lI,JI5I CHHTeTHLIeCKOHHayKI1
LIeJIOBeKe, rrOCTpoeHHOH aa nO,lI,JIHHHO HaYlfHOM <PYH,lI,aMeHTe. M
OXOTHO sepav, LITO 3,lI,aHHe, Pl1CYHOK xoroporo Mbl rrpHBeJIH 3,lI,eC
CTaHeT TOp)!{eCTBOMHaY4HOH TeXHHKH 11BepXOM nneumero 60raTCTJ
JIa60paTopHbIX YCJIOBl1H:,O,lI,HaKO Mbl He BepHM, LITO 3TO BHeWH{
60raTCTBO C03,lI,aCT4TO-H116Y,lI,b,lI,pyroe, LIeM BHeWHee 06be,lI,HHem
nozi
O,lI,HOH:KpbIWeH: LIaCTHbIX HCCJIe,lI,OBaHl1H:x,oropue Be,lI,YTC5I0
,lI,eJIbHbIMH rrpl1BJIeKaeMblMl1 ryna Y4eHbIMl1. B YCJIOBH5IXxarnrran:
crnxecxof opranasauna Mbl He BH,lI,HM nepcnexrna ,lI,Jl5IrrpOH1I1KH
BeHl151C03HaTeJIbHO nOCTpoeHHbIX 11rrO,lI,JlHHHOnay-msrx 06W.HX MeT
,lI,OJlOrI14eCKHXxonuerruna B LIaCTHble MeTO,lI,HKH OT,lI,eJIbHblX I1CCJI
.lI.OBaHI1H:H, B 3TOM MO)!{HOppe,lI,yra,lI,blBaTb BHYTpeHHIOIOHI1w.eTY3TO
04eHb HHTepeCHoro H 60raToro HaLII1HaHH5I.
Mbl O'lepTHJlH B caMOM 6erJIOM' 3CK113eOCHOBHble JlI1HHH axep
IX
KaHCKOtI ncaxonornuecxoa HaYKI1. Ha ee <pOHenpourerr Me)!{.zj
naPO,lI,HbHl :rrcI1XOJIOrI14eCKl1H:xoarpecc.
TaK xce, KaK 11BC5I aMepl1KaHCKa51HaYKa, xonrpecc 6bIJI Jll1W
uenrpansnux BbI,lI,Bl1HYTbIXB IIJlaliOBOM nopszn.e TeM; B 113BeCTH
Mepe OH 6bIJI JIl1WeH H BHYTpeI-IHero IIJlaHa, T. K. cexuna HaMe4a
He CPOJIbKOBHYTpeHHI1H nJIaH, CKOJIbI<Ore 06JIaCTI1, np06JIeMbI, I
Topble HaWJII1 ce6e MeC110aa xoarpecce.
npouecc.c-xonrp:
O,lI,HaKO, KaI< 11Ka)!{,lI,bIH:CTI1Xl1}IHOBblPOCWHH:
•
ME)f{PYHAPOPHblU KOHrPECC nCJ1XOJIorOB 91
HeCOMHeHHOOTpa}!{aJI OCHOBHbIeJIYlHI1Y1pa3BYlTYlHaMepYlKaHCKOHHayKYl
H OCHOBHblerrp06JI,eMbI, soxpyr K01'Op'bIX BeAeTCH HaM60JI'ee rOpH4a51
pa60Ta COBpeMeHHOH MYlPOBOll rrCYlXOJIOrHYl.
HaM Ka}!{eTCH nenpasaasnsra nyrex OCTaHaBJIYlBaTbCHB KpaTKoM
C006I.IJ:eHI1IYHl 3 soex (I1JIH XOTH 6bI rviaauux) ,lljOKJIaAaX cses.aa, Apyr
sa ,lI.pyrOM rrepe4l1CJIH5II1X rrOJIO}!{eHYlH;MbI OCTaHOBI1MCH3AeCb JIYllllb
na .HeMHorYlX ,lI.OKJIaAax, 4aCTO BbIAalO~YlXCH, HO 4aCTO-p5IAOBbIX 11
JIYllllb TI1rrYl4HbIX AJI5Irex YlJII1YlHbIXTeH,lI.eHl.(YlI1B: COBpeMeHHOll HaY4-
HOI1:MbICJIYl.
Ka}!{,lI.bIll CKJIOHeH BYl~eTb B 60JIblllOM Ma'11epUaJIe 'Po, lITO<eMY
rrOKa3aJIOCb ocorieuno Ba)KHbIM, 6bITb Mo~eT - TO, K BOCrrpH5ITYllO
4ero IOH6bIJI MaKCI1MaJIbHIOrrOJJ,rOTOBJIeH.Ilanryuraa 3TI1 CTpOKI1BOC-
rrpYlH5IJI Cbe3JJ,KaK JJ,eMOHCTpaI.(l1lOIOCHOBHbIXrrpI1HI.(YlrrYlaJIbHbIXYCTa-
HOBOKCOBpeMeHHoro aMepYlKaHCKOro 6YlX3BYlOpl13Ma Yl KaK CTI1Xl1llHO
co scex CTOPOHpacryutae 11HaMe4alO~YleCH TeHAeHI.(YlYlrrpeOJI.OJIeHI151
ero rrpYlMI1TYlBHbIXB3rJIHAOB, ero MeXaHYlCTYlqeCKOrOMYlPOB033peHYlH1.
TYlrrYl4HbIM ,lI.JI5I pa60T cospeaeanoro 611X3BYlOpYl3Ma5IBJI5IeTCHYl3-
Y4eHYle 4eJIOBeKa YlJIYl }!{YlBOTHOro, acxo.aauree Yl3 rrOJIO}!{eHYlH, qTO
CJIO}!{HeHlllYle CTOPOHbIrrOBeAeHYl5IBblpacTalOT Yl3 npocrux nyrea no-
crenenaoro YlX YCJIO}!{HeHI15I,nyrea BOcrrYlTaHYl51Yl3BeCTHbIXHaBbI!{OB.
3TYl HaBblKYlMoryT 6blTb socnaraxu JIYllllb na oase BpO}!{,lI.eHHbIX<pOpM
noseneaaa, Yl aaysenae KaK HaBbIKOB, TaK 11apoacnemrux <pOPMrro-
BeAeHYl5I CTaJIOOAHOH Yl3 OCHOBHbIXTeM COBpeMeHHOHaxepaxancxof
rrCIIXOJIorYlYl. O,lI.HaKO aMepYlKaHCKaH rrCYlXOJIorYl5IHe TOJIbKO onncsr-
saer, OHa npezcne scero H·H3Mep5IeT; H aanaxa H3yqeHU5I HaBbIKOB H
BpO}!{JJ,eHHbIXpeaxuaii rrpespatnaercs B 3aJJ,a4YH3MepeHH5I I1X ycroji-
qIIBOCTH, HX CHJIbl.
Coaepurenno He CJIyqaHHO rr03TOMY, qTO rrepBbIM AOKJIaAOM, no-
Mew,eHHbIM B rrOBeCTKe xonrpecca H rrp04HTaHHOM na 3aCeAaHHYl cex-
I.(IIM rro noaeneumo )!<HBOTHbIX,6bIJI ,mOKJIa.rrn,porp. Yo pn eHa (War-
den-Columbia) '06 H3MepeHHH MOTI1BOB rrOBeJJ,eHI15I y }!{H-
BOT H0 r o. 3TY 0pYlfl1HaJIbHYlO aanaxy aBTOp ocy~eCTBJIHJI CJIeAYlO-
U.(YlM 06pa30M·: }!{eJIaH H3MepHTb CHJIY, C KOTOPOll AeHcTByeT na }!{Yl-
BOTHoe (KPbICy) MOTHBrOJIo.n.aHH5I,OH caxcan ee B rrOMeII.(eI1He,BAP'Y-
rOM KOHI.(e xcroporo 6bIJIa rrOJIO}!{eHa rnnna, K KOTOPOH }!{HBOTHOe,
04eBYlAHO, CTpeMHJIOCb; Me}!{,lI.y }!{YlBOTHbIM H rrauieii 6bIJIH CAeJIaHbI
cneuaansnue MeTaJIJIYlqeCKYlerrOJIOCKH,sepea xoropsre }!{I1BOTHOeHe-
1136e}!{HO.lIiOJI}!{HO6bIJIO npocerart, H OT KOTOPbIX rrOJIY4aJIO CI1JIbHble
3JIeKTpYlQeCKYley.aapu. 3aAa4a 113MepemI5I CYlJIbIMOTMBOBCBO,lI.YlJIaCb,
6JIaro,lI.ap5! TaKOll YCTaHOBKe, K aanaue Yl3MepeHYl5Iroro, CKOJIbKOpaa
1 Ilonpooaee na aTOM51OCTaHaBJIHBaIOCbB crarse «0 nyrsx COBpeMeHHof:!nCHXO-
norHH» - «ECTeCTB03HaHHeH MapKCH3M».
92 A. P. JJYPH51
xpuca neperieraaa K nmue, H'eCMOTp51na nOJIY4aeMbIe eio 3JIeKTpOl{Q)K-
nue
lllOKH. CTaB5IOnbITbI Ha'~ rOJI'O.U9M,)f{a)f{,ZI;OHn,OJIOBbIMM'liCTHl-IKTOM
H MHCTMHKTOMMaTepHHCTBa (B nOCJIe~HHX ~BYX CJIY4a5lXMeCTOnaunr
3aHHMaJIa CaMKa HJIM ~eTeHbIlll), Vopnen OKa3aJIC5IB COCT05lHHM113-
MepHTb CHJIY3THX MOTHBOBH paCnOJIO)f{HTb HX B Onpe~eJIeHHOH no-
CJIe~OBaTeJIbHOCTHp5l~.
MbI rrpHBeJIH 3TOT ~OKJIa~ KaK THnH4HbIH npnvep xopourero axe-
pHKaHCKorO HCCJIe~OBaHH5I, rrOCB5Iw.eHHOrO H3MepeHHlO BpO)f{~eHHbIX
cpOpM nOBe~eHH5I; OTBJIeKa5lCbOT cneuarpasecxoa CTPYKTYPbI xaxcnoro
H3 npaaeneanux HHCTHHKTOB,-6HX3BHOPHCT C4HTaeT HC4epnaHHOH
H peureauon np06JIeMY, eCJIiYfeMY y~aICTC5Iaupaairn, ee B O~.H'03Ha4-
HbIX, rrOJIY4eHHbiX B O~HHaKOBbIX YCJIOBH5IX,UHcppaX; cosepurenao no-
H5ITHO, 4TO 3TH BblBO~bl TOT4aC )f{e nepeHOC5ITC5I aa 4eJIOBe4eCKOe
06lUeCTBO, H npotineva MOTHBaUHH4eJIOBe4eCKOrO nOBe~eHH5I C4l;lTa-
eTC5Iycneumo peureunoa, eCJIHHCCJIe~OBaTeJIlOy~aCTC5IH3MepHTb a6-
COJIlOTHYlOCHJIYOT~eJIbHbiX «HHCTHHKTOB»Y nO~OnbITHbIX. )KHBOTHbIX.
Cosepurenuo TO ace KaCaeTC5IH BTOPOH'H3 HaMe4eHHbIX HaMH npo-
6JIeM-rrpo6JIeMbI HaBbIKOB. 3Ta np06JIeMa 51BJI5IeTC5I,nO)f{aJIYH, ca-
MOHTHnH4HrOHnp06JIeMOH .L\JI5IaMepHKaHCKOH nCHXOJIOrHHnOBe.L\eHH5I.
Ilpaxenenae MeTO~a YCJIOBHblXpecpJIeKCOBH cneuaansno supaooraa-
HOrO .L\JI5I3TOH uemr MeTO.L\aJIa6HpHHTOB rrOKa3aJIO, 4TO HaBbIK 51Bo'l5l-
eTC5I pe3YJIbTaTOM CJIO)KHOHCHCT€'Mblnp106 H OlllH60K, npn KOTOPOH
y~a4HbIe peaKUHH nO~KpenJI5IlOTC5I H OCTalOTC5I,a neynaxaue-e-rop-
M0351TC5IH HC4e3alOT. I'onu HCCJIe~OBaHHHYKpenHJIH B aMepHKaHCKHX
asropax y6e)f{.L\eHHe, 4TO HMeHHO B 3THX repvauax aCCOUHaU"15l
~BH)f{eHHH, rrO~KperrJIeHH5I H TOpMO)f{eHH5IMO)KeT 6bITb supaaceu BC5I-
KHt'I HaBbIK, H 4TO HaBbIK Y 4eJIOBeKa B CYlUHOCTHHH4eM npHHUHnH-
aJIbHbIM He OTJIH4aeTC5IOT HaBbIKa Y )KHBOTHoro. MexaHHCTH4eCKHH
B3rJI5I~ na noseneaae 4eJIOBeKa nOJIY4HJI CBOlOnp04HYlO OCHOBY B
aMepHKaHCKOH nCHXOJIOfHH nOBe~eHH5I, H 6bIJI crpaacen na xonrpecce
B ueJIOM pane ~OKJIa~OB.
O~aKO, HM'eHH'O3TOT B3rJI5I)I;na MexaHH4eCKYlO OCHOBYHaBbIKOB
1 1
• 6bIJI nO~BeprHYT caMbIM cepseanua COMHeHH5IMaa xonrpecce, H HH-
TepeCHO, 4TO 3TH npaKTH4eCKHe COMHeHH5IHCXO~HJIHOT xpynaemuero
nCHXOJIOra, aaecurero B csoe BpeM5I ocooeuno MHOrO B Y4eHHe 0 Ha-
BbIKax,-lopH.L\aHKa.
TopH~aHK c~eJIaJI ua xonrpecce OOJIblllOH .ll.OKJIa~ 06 OCHOBHbIX
cpaKTopax 06Y4eHH5I. nBe OCHOBHbIeero MbICJIHCBO~HJIHCbK KpHTHKe
nsyx OCHOBHbIXnOJIO)f{eHHHcrapoii reopaa o6Y4eHH5I. Ilepsas 3aKJIlO-
4aJIaCb B KpHTHKe POJIHnOBTOpeHH5I~JI5I06Y4eHH5I, BTOpa5l-B KpHTH-
xe cooTBeTcTBeHHoH POJIHHaKa3aHH5I.KaK HarJI5I~HOH aa sxcnepaaen-
TaJIbHOM xarepnane nOKa3aJI TopH~aHK, nOB"fIOpeHHe MO)f{eT H He
urpart. OCHOBHOHp'OJIH~JI5I06pa30BaHH5I HaBbIKa. 13bIBalOTCJIY43H, K8-