That Alluring Land (Ta zem vabna) Which They Both Have Never Seen: Imaging and Imagining America in the Words of Timrava and Virginia Woolf Verita Sriratana Verita Sriratana is a recipient of the Anandamahidol Foundation Scholarship under the Royal Patronage of HM the King of Thailand. She is also currently a recipient of the National Scholarship Programme of the Slovak Republic for the Support of Mobility of Lecturers and Researchers at the Department of English Language and Literature, Faculty of Education, Comenius University in Bratislava. Verita has published articles on Virginia Woolf and the weather, on Woolfs spatial metaphors and concept of "atmosphere", and on Woolf and the Theravada Buddhist concept of "the middle path". She has recently been interested in Slovak feminist and postcolonial modernism, particularly in the works of Boiena SlanEikovd "Timrava". Abstract: Boiena SlanEikovci "Timrava" (18 67-19 51) and her British contemporary Virginia Woo!f(l882-1941) wrote scathingly about America without having visited the place. Timrava's 1907short story "ThatA lluring Land" ("Tci zem vcibna17a nd Woo!f's 1938 essay 'Xmerica, which I have never seen " expose the workings of the "technology of place:' The term "technology': which means ''coming to presence" and "concealing" in Martin Heidegger's sense, is appropriated as part of this paper's proposition that the America imaged and imagined by both writers is a result of negotiations between the ''concrete place" of the senses, both writers' socio-cultural constructs, and the "abstract place" of the imagination. The myth of America as the promised World Symphony", ushered in a sense land of freedom and opportunity, a of optimism and utopian exaltation in melting pot of gold, has been prevalent America's industrial and technological in the collective consciousness since progress. Unlike the case of DvoFdk the Age of Discovery, or around the who composed his masterpiece in fifteenth to seventeenth century, 1893 during his actual visit to his until the present day. The Turn of "new world'', America is featured in the Century (1890-1914), which the works of those who have not even culminated in Antonin Dvoi6k's "New touched its soil. The Slovak writer ARS AETERNA Boiena SlanEikovi (1867-1951), as well as the effects of remigration on known by her nom de plume "Timrava", the lives of the people living in small and her British contemporary Virginia villages in Slovakia. In the case of Woolf (1882-1941) wrote scathingly Virginia Woolf, as I shall illustrate, her about America without having visited textual representation of America, as the place. I propose in this paper that well as the accompanying illustration Timrava's short story That Alluring by the American artist C. Peter Helck Land (Ta' zem vcibna), which appeared (1893-1988) of Woolf's article in in 1907, and Woolf's short essay Hearst's International Combined with America, which I have never seen, Cosmopolitan (1938) which is based on published in 1938, expose the workings her words and which is also transgressed of what I term "technology of place''. by her words, can be said to be shaped The word "technology", which means and stimulated by the alternative reality both a finished product and an ongoing Woolf had wished upon her world. For production process, a mode of both Woolf, America stands as a symbol of "coming to presence" and "concealing" an alternative space where women in Martin Heidegger's sense, is used as writers come to forge an alternative part of this paper's proposition that voice or even a new language which America in the works of Timrava and can liberate them from the confines Woolf is a result ofconstant negotiations of dominant male writers' vocabulary between the "concrete place" of the and patriarchal mindset. America, for senses-both writers' socio-cultural Woolf, is also an alternative place for constructs; and the "abstract place" of a new world order, where Britain's the imagination-both writers' dreams socio-cultural, economic and political and visions of the "alluring" unknown. supremacy as well as hegemonic claims I wish to demonstrate in my paper how after the First World War are put into words shape and complement images question. and how images shape and complement Before analysing the chosen literary words. I argue that the intertwined texts, I shall begin by briefly explaining connection and rich interaction between Heidegger's concept of "technology" in "words" and "images", or between my "technology of place" theoretical textual and visual culture, can be seen framework. Often read and regarded as reflected in my analysis of "technology an anti-technology and anti-modernism of place" in Woolf and Timrava's (re-) statement, Heidegger's essay entitled creation of words on and images of the The Question Concerning Technology America they have not seen or visited. In (Die Frage nach der Technik), first the case of Timrava, as I shall illustrate, published in 1954, nevertheless can her textual representation of America be said to suggest that technology's can be said to be shaped and stimulated deconstructive tendency can lead to the by the reality of her time, namely, that questioning of preconceived notions of the early twentieth-century Slovak and values. According to Heidegger, emigration to and migration in America, much as the use of modern technology can dangerously reduce humans to Boiena SlanEikovA "Timrava" was "Bremer und Freiburger Vortrage", or born in 1867 to a family of a Lutheran "functionaries of enframing" driven pastor in a small village called Polichno, only by the desire to get the most out BanskA Bystrica Region, Slovakia. She of their resources without thinking, was the author of many works which technology can also manifest itself as a depict village life, notably exploring "saving grace" in that, particularly when the relationships between landowners certain technological devices break and peasants, between the burgeoning down, humans can be moved to question middle class and the working class, and their "illusions of power" over natural between men and women in the advent resources, or "standing-reserve", and of modernization. The most famous also contemplate upon what it means to among her short stories is The Tapdk "be" in the world as Daseins. Quoting the Clan (?apa'kovci), published in 1914. The lines of the German lyric poet Friedrich ?apdk Clan is a story of a family trapped Holderlin: "But where danger is, grows/ within a traditional and conservative The saving power also" (1977, p. 28)) way of life, stubbornly refusing to adapt Heidegger asserts: to new changing conditions of society. If the essence of technology, Enfra- The large GpAk family lives together in ming, is the extreme danger, and if there one house: is truth in Holderlin's words, then the Four brothers with their wives and rule of Enframing cannot exhaust itself children-the fifth brother, MiSo, the solely in blocking all lighting-up of every youngest, was still a bachelor. There revealing, all appearing of truth. Rather was one daughter, AnEa, thirty years precisely the essence of technology old and an old maid because she was must harbor in itself the growth of the crippled ... The whole bpAk family lived saving power (1977, p. 28). together in one house. When they all "Technology of place" is therefore got together, there was scarcely room a mode of constructing a myth or an on the benches (Timrava, 1992, p. 171). understanding of place, "enframing" or The family's cramped and suffocating "setting" the mind in ways that lead it to house serves as a metaphor of the subscribe to or propagate the "imaged", family's narrow-mindedness which or represented, as well as "imagined", or resists any form of change. Only Il'a, (re)invented, place. At the same time, the wife of the eldest brother in the however, "technology of place" can also family, ventures to go against the be a mode of questioning and reading patriarchal regime and the family below that spatial construction. custom of complacency by imagining In light of my concept of "technology an "abstract place" of healthier living of place" as a mode of constructing and and by suggesting that they expand the deconstructing one's understanding of "concrete place" of their family house. oneself and one's place, I shall begin Only Il'a dares to speak up and urge this paper's textual analysis by offering the family to embrace a more informed an overview of Timrava and her works. and "modernized" outlook and lifestyle. ARS AETERNA Her "modern" opinion, of course, comes the people living in small villages in with a price. The family bestows upon Slovakia is revolutionary. The tragic her an insulting nickname "Queenie" and, at the same time, satirical ending and mocks her for her different views: of The Tapcik Clan demonstrates her [Nlone of them [the other members of modernist transgressive tendency to the Taphk family] liked Il'a; she felt she put into question and revise the "old" was too good for anyone else because traditional ways of thinking and writing she was in the community service. She whilst remaining within and utilizing was the village midwife! Since taking the discursive tools of the very social a course in Rimavskh Sobota for two system she criticizes in her works. months, she had put on airs as if she no Therefore, it can be said that her oeuvre longer belonged to a peasant's family, goes beyond folk narratives, bordering but to a gentleman's. Now nothing and between the trope of realism and the no one in the Taphk house pleased her. trope of modernism. She lectured them, bossed them, and America, for Timrava, is an imagined tried to destroy all the old customs land. However, it is nevertheless rooted for ages in their household. constructed upon the "concrete place" (ibid., p. 172) ofthe grim reality of political oppression Though a , not without pain, of her time: the Magyarization Policy successfully persuades her husband and the formation of an independent Palb to physically remove themselves Czechoslovakia. Poverty, forced from the overcrowded "concrete place" denationalization and socio-economic of the Taphk family house as well as inequality prompted a vast amount of mentally relocate themselves to a new labour migration. Signs of social unrest "abstract place" of a more promising can still be seen in post-indepedence future, Timrava depicts how the rest of Czechoslovakia from the year 1918 the obstinate Taphk clan returns to their onwards: sense of complacency by making fun of The country itself was threatened the changes which Il'a and her husband by an invasion of Slovakia by Hungary have embraced at the end of the story: and by the short-lived proclamation of The third brother made a small joke, an independent Slovak Soviet Republic. leaning against the corner of the old The Sudeten German minority refused house: "Well, well, what a yellow castle allegiance to the new Republic and our Queenie's built-I'd be embarrassed sought a solution of its grievances in to live in it." an alignment with Austria. Finances "Oh, we can build one like that too," were in chaos, due to the enormously said the mistress Zuza disparagingly, inflated old Austrian crown. The war "when MiSo comes home from the army." had all but derailed the economy; coal Everyone felt pleased with himself. production had dropped drastically, and (ibid., p. 212) transportation was in disarray. Lack Timrava's endeavour to capture of food aggravated social unrest, and and portray the reality of the lives of the working class, suffering most, was radicalized by Communist agitation. pay for his newly acquired land: "So that Peasants were hungry for land. Strikes alluring land crept into Jano's thoughts spread like wildfire, and attempts to again, the New World across the ocean, seize land erupted around the country. which gave a man everything good, and (Korbel, 1997, p. 43) which could ease from his shoulders the ThatAlluring Land (Tci zem vhbna) was pressing debt" (Timrava, 1992, p. 109). published in 1907, the year when the He also wishes to go to America in order Hungarian Apponyi Laws were drafted to escape from his domineering mother and passed, granting the government as well as his "mundane" and frustrated official rights to turn all Slovak life in his small village: elementary schools into Hungarian and The closer he got to the house, the decree that the Slovak language was more despairing he felt and the more only to be taught one hour per week as he yearned to go to that land for which a foreign language. The impact of the Privoda [Jano's friend] had again fanned Hungarian aggressive acculturation his love. The golden threads stretching regime on Slovak education, for from America and pulling him to herself example, was tremendous: grew stouter. That land over there could [A111 teachers, whether in state or not only ease the debt off his shoulders, church schools, were to educate their but also take away this burden he was pupils to love the Magyar Nation and always carrying in his heart. He didn't the Hungarian State. The state was know if otherwise he could ever throw authorized to change even Slovak it off. (Timrava, 1992, p. 122) church schools to Magyar schools if they Upon hearing about his son's fervent included a minority of Magyar pupils. desire to leave home, Jano's mother Teachers who neglected to teach the complains: Magyar language could be summarily "How could you go off to America? dismissed, and for the same cause the How could I let you? Your father's ill- state had the right to close down a school he won't last till spring, so what will entirely. The school became the most become of us, and of the farm? Why did potent weapons of denationalization. we buy the new field if you're going to (Lettrich, 1955, pp. 36-37) leave? America is across the ocean, you Timrava's story is about a 26-year- can get sick there, you can die there, my old young man named Jano Fazul'a who son! Two years! By that time I'll lay my belongs to a peasant family. Jano is old bones down, too, ifyou leave!" (ibid., worried about his father, who is dying. p. 106) He has also been feeling frustrated about While Jano is still deciding whether his wife, whom he does not love but was to leave or not to leave his home, he is arranged by his mother to marry. The persuaded by his friends who are also family has just bought new land next to planning to go and work in America to the family's farm, for which Jano needs pay off their debts. He and his friends, to pay and clear his debt. Janow ishes to who usually drink at the local pub go to America to earn enough money to and talk about "that alluring land" ARS AETERNA called America, are ironically and you catch him, like I caught VySovan scathingly referred to by the locals as when he stole my sausages, and nothing "the Americans". The village's other happened to him because 1 didn't have young men, who do not have the means a witness. In America, brother, if you or luxury to leave their homes, also take even one broken needle, you'll be join "the Americans" in the collective hanged at once!" Here he looked at Palb dreaming and imagining of the land Privoda. "That's what I heard." (ibid., pp. they have never seen: 118-19) Then, while they drank, they talked It is interesting to note how the word about that wondrous land across the "here" is starkly contrasted with "there". ocean which provided mankind with Compared with the laws in Jano's such blessings. It had four harvests village, where people can get away with a year with no taxes, and money petty theft, the laws in America are fell everywhere like dust. That land thought or imagined to be stricter-a glittered magically before their eyes. It guarantee of a better life. However, the was covered by luxuriant ears of grain hopeful voices of aspiring young men strewn with the dollars that rained who dream their collective dreams of down abundantly upon the working America are nevertheless cracked and man and jingled together like music. broken by some comments which have (ibid., p. 117) the potential to expose and challenge This collective image of America the fabricated myth of America in these as a land of milk and honey, a land of villagers' minds: abundance, is described through the "But really, men, the laws about words they know, through farming women are strict there." Jano Krajec was imagery of crops and harvests. This a young man whose appearance and extract therefore demonstrates how speech were so proper that he had just the "technology" of place-making is been elected as sacristan for the new based on or "enframed", to appropriate year. "Men can't even stand and joke Heidegger's term, within the context of with a woman, or play a little, or even the dreamer or the imaginer in the same wink at her-to jail at once! He looked way that it "enframes" or propels the toward the smiling, handsome face of dreamer or the imaginer to propagate Privoda, observing it sadly, since people the myth of place in his/her mindset. said Privoda was a passionate admirer Here, Jano and his friends are all of women. peasants trying to conjure up the image "Oh, no!" The young men groaned at of America as utopia and cornucopia. the speech of Jano Krajec. This image of America as a Slovak "Excuse me, but none of this is true." farmer's El Dorado is also reinforced by Privoda still spoke coolly. the image of America as a land of justice "Just nonsense! Don't worry, Janko and freedom: Fazul'a." "Over there it's not like it is here, "No getting drunk there, either. where nothing happens to a thief. Here Imagine! My father-in-law said they take drunks to jail at once," said Palb and jingled together like music" (1992, AmbriS from the upper village. p. 117) is shattered by the "concrete" "Now what kind of freedom is that?" reality of industrial America, or the Jano GuSka, despite his abruptness and reality of coals, hot furnaces and hard contrariness, always wanted another labour. The ending of the short story glass (ibid., p. 119). is tragic in that Timrava demonstrates, As Jano GuSka has questioned, "what with wry humour, how people tend to kind of freedom is that?" (ibid., p. 119) hold on to the myths and images they when there are so many restrictions. only want to see and believe in. The Freedom, of course, comes with a price. myth of America as "that" alluring land Timrava plants such witty dissonance superior in every way to "this" alluring in her text so as to induce her readers land of one's own "concrete place" of to be sceptical of her characters' myth home or homeland, of one's reality ofthe of America. here and now, will still be propagated as To Jano Fazul'a's delight, his mother truth when people believe in it without comes to believe all the rumours about questioning: "that alluring" land which she has never When this information [in Jano's seen and finally agrees to let him go letter] reached Jano Hlbzo, he went to and work in America. After Jano and his visit the BubuEka family next door to friends leave their hometown, a letter the Fazul'a house. He enjoyed making up from Jano reaches Slovakia. It reads: stories and upsetting people with them "Here it's not like people at home whenever he could. said it would be. Just don't believe it's There he said, "Did you hear the latest? so good. It's very difficult here, very In Libov5 someone just came back from hard. True, we get three dollars a day, America. He said Jano Fazul'a fell into but we work by the open furnace where the boiler where they melt the asphalt. the iron ore is melted. Just the two of Ah, that's the truth! Old Ondro Mihal'ko us-old our0 Tankel' didn't last there was in the city yesterday, and he heard even two days and had to quit. Now about it from the Libov5 men who were he's working by the train hauling coal sawing wood at KoH's place." in a wheelbarrow for the engine. He "Oh-h-h!" BubuEka was so shocked said he's going home as soon as he gets she almost fainted. enough money for the ticket. Srnec went In an hour, the story had spread down into the mine because he didn't around the whole village that Jano last by the furnace either. We work in Fazul'a had fallen into the boiler and leather gloves so the flames won't burn was cooked to pieces. Only a few bones our hands, and we have glasses over our remained of him. Vr5beEiEka [Jano's eyes." (ibid., p.129) mother], when they had revived her The image of America as a land from her faint, grabbed a scarf for her "covered by luxuriant ears of grain head. She ran out just the way she was, strewn with the dollars that rained greasy from cooking. Weeping aloud, down abundantlyupon the workingman she ran all the way to Libov5 to ask that ARS AETERNA American if it was really true about hometown, he [Pavel SlanEik] studied Janko. (ibid., p. 129) in Oid'any, Keimarok and Banska The haunting, vivid image of Jano's Stiavnica, from where he graduated. He mother weeping and rushing out of her went on to study theology in Bratislava. house in panic serves as a reminder Then, in 1857, he went to Halle. He of the destructive outcome of one's married, at the age of 28, 16-year-old unscrupulous subscription to the myth Eva Miria Honktzy (1847-1923), who of an imagined place. was daughter of the pastor of Kyjatice Timrava, who grew up and lived in an in Gemer. The marriage produced 11 isolated village, has long been regarded children. Among whom that survived as a folk writer whose genius and to adulthood were Pavel, Irena, Boiena theme of writing transcend her village and Bohuslav (who were identical ways of life, resisting the patriotic twins), Izabela and Maria ... In 1863, trend of writing prevalent in her time. Pavel SlanEik co-founded the Matica Four years before Timrava's birth, the Slovenski in Martin. (Obecnf urad Matica Slovenski, Slovakia's prominent Polichno, 2011)2 cultural and scientific institution However, unlike the works of Slovak whose objectives were "to foster Slovak nationalist writers, most notably the education, to encourage literature and poet laureate Pavol Hviezdoslav (1849- the arts, and to improve the material 1921) and Martin KukuEin (1860-1928), welfare of the nation" (Lettrich, 1955, Timrava's works deal with simple plots. p. 34)) was established in the city of Her emphasis is on the character's Martin on 4 August 1863: interior conflict, or "landscape of the And when the Matica Slovenski mind", rather than on a didactic and constitution of 21 August 1862 had propagandist agenda, which was the been approved, the first general trend of her time. In 1907, in the same assembly took place almost a year year that ThatAlIuring Land appeared in later, on 4 August, in Martin. The print, KukuEin published a play entitled assembly, attended by around 5,000 Komasdcia: Obraz zo slovenskej dediny v people, was the largest in the history Styroch dejstvdch (Land Consolidation: of events in Slovakia in that time. It Imagef rom a Slovak Village in FourActs), was an exceedingly solemn incident which was Slovakia's earliest realist play. that might have impressed even the KukuEin's prioritization and promotion biggest sceptics. On this occasion, there of the political message of land was no shortage of false expression of protection and consolidation through sympathy towards the Slovaks artfully flat and almost "lifeless" characters and calculatingly dispatched from the serves as a stark contrast to Timrava's Emperor. (Mriz, 1963, p. 39)' prioritization of in-depth exploration Timrava's father, Lutheran priest of her fictional characters. The issues of Pavel SlanEik (1833-1906)) was one of labour migration and of land acquisition the institution's co-founders: in Timrava's short story are explored on In addition to the primary school in his a more personal level and through the point of views of the neglected "other", Also, it is the changes which these or the men and women who are left by returned "Americans" made to the the exodus heroes to carry on with their community that persuade Jano's mother lives and who are also the culprits in to agree to let him go: "VrAbel'tiEka propagating the myth of imagined place, [Jano's mother] sat down beside him unconsciously sustaining the inequality at the table and began to speak. 'Well, embedded within the social class and Janko, it's true-people really do have economic system: "When even the rich it good who have been in America. are going off to America, what can poor Even Mi50 Kruphr in Libovri brought people like us expect?" (Timrava, 1992, back a lot of money, and he was there p. 123). only a year and a half."' (ibid., p. 123). I thus agree with Norma Rudinsky, Timrava, living in her microcosmic who aptly points out that Timrava's "concrete place" of Polichno, must have short story "presents immigration as witnessed the phenomenon of massive emigration" (1992, p. xiii). I also wish to labour migration and remigration. propose that Timrava not only portrays According to the statistics of migration the conditions of early twentieth- between the United States and Europe century Slovak emigration to and in the years 1908 to 1923 in Wyman's migration in America, but also offers Round-trip to America: The Immigrants insights into the effects of remigration. Return to Europe, a staggering number The men from Jano's neighbouring of 225,033 Slovaks migrated to the town of Libova who had gone to work in United States. 127,593 Slovaks (a total America and returned to Slovakia with of 57% of all migrants) remigrated from their earnings not only transform the the United States, returning to their physical landscape of the town but also home country or moving to other places contribute to the shaping of the myth of in Europe (1993, p. 11). America in the minds of the people they As outlined at the beginning of this have left behind: "'Well, it's America paper, Timrava was not the only writer that made Libovh rich!' Exclaimed who wrote about the "allure" ofAmerica Srnec. 'Without her they couldn't have without having actually visited the built those palaces"' (Timrava, 1992, place. Timrava's junior contemporary p. 113). It is their "remigrated" stories from England, Virginia Woolf, also of America that propel the aspiring engaged in a mental journey to America 'Rmericans" in Jano's town to pursue without physically leaving the British their dreams: "'Listen, brother,' Srnec Isles. To point out the similarities and spoke up proudly, then puffed on both differences between the two writers, I cigars at once. 'bur0 Hrib from Libovi shall offer an overview of Woolf's life told me that even men who just sweep and works in connection with Timrava's streets in America get four dollars a day. life and works. You know what one dollar will pay for! Woolf was born to a literary family Oh, what we're going to get!' (ibid., p. in the year 1882, in London, England. 116). Her father, Sir Leslie Stephen (1832- ARS AETERNA 1904), was the first editor of the records and syllabi at King's College Dictionary of National Biography and Ladies' Department between the years one of the eminent Victorian men of 1897-1901, when she was between letters. Around the time when Timrava the ages of 15 and 19, Virginia Stephen was writing The Tapcik Clan, Woolf was was officially registered for courses in writing Melymbrosia, a story about English and Continental History, Greek, a young English woman travelling Latin and German. Unlike Timrava who abroad and undergoing an emotional died at the ripe old age of 84, having and sexual awakening. Melymbrosia is lived until the year 1951a nd witnessed dense with blatant social commentaries the atrocities of both World Wars, Woolf on colonialism, the suffrage movement committed suicide in 1941. She died at and homosexuality. Though modified the age of 59, right before the outbreak and toned down by self-censorship, the of the Second World War. Melymbrosia unpublished drafts would To complete this comparative study, later form her first published novel The we now turn to Woolf's essay which, Voyage Out (1915). With the exception like Timrava's That Alluring Land, is a of her last unfinished novel Between the product of a writer's attempt to "image" Acts, which centres on a village pageant, and "imagine" America. "America, Woolf, unlike Timrava, did not produce which I have never seen, interests me folk stories or write extensively about most in this cosmopolitan world of village life. However, Woolf shares today" was first published in April 1938 Timrava's keen interest in charting out in Hearst's International Combined with the characters' interior landscapes. Cosmopolitan Magazine. It was written Both of their works deal with interior in response to a question put to a monologues and negotiations between succession of writers, with J.B. Priestley the "concrete place" of reality and (1894-19841, for example, billed as next the "abstract place" of dreams and in line: "What interests you most in this imagination. Another striking similarity cosmopolitan world of today?" (2002, p. between the two writers lies in the 56). Woolf is described in the headline fact that both were contented to be across the article page in Hearst's as referred to and regarded by the public 'Ruthor of 'The Years"', which was her as "autodidacts" who did not receive best-selling novel in America. Her reply, formal education. However, their claims 'Rmerica, which I have never seen, are not entirely true. While Timrava was interests me most", is accompanied by "[s]chooled mainly at home" and "read C. Peter Helck's montage illustration, sporadically in European literature which is composed of a bird's-eye view (Czech, German, Magyar, Russian)" of Manhattan and its skyscrapers, of the (Rudinsky, 1992, p. x), she nevertheless Statue of Liberty and a gigantic native attended a boarding school for young American, of cars and traffic, and of ladies at the age of fifteen "to improve cocktail bars and factories (1938, p. 21). her German and Magyar" (ibid.). The article begins thus: Likewise, according to her enrolment
Description: