PRESENCE OF MIND IN NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL PROCESSES PRESENCE OF MIND IN NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL PROCESSES Lawrence Goldie and Jane Desmarais First published in 2013 by Karnac Books Ltd 118 Finchley Road London NW3 5HT Copyright © 2013 by Lawrence Goldie and Jane Desmarais The right of Lawrence Goldie and Jane Desmarais to be identified as the authors of this work has been asserted in accordance with §§ 77 and 78 of the Copyright Design and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A C.I.P. for this book is available from the British Library ISBN-13: 978-1-85575-885-8 Typeset by V Publishing Solutions Pvt Ltd., Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain www.karnacbooks.com CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS vii EDITOR’S PREFACE ix INTRODUCTION xiii PART I: THE PRINCIPLE OF COMPLEMENTARITY CHAPTER ONE Attention and inattention 5 CHAPTER TWO Epilepsy and the unconscious 19 PART II: HYPNOSIS CHAPTER THREE Hypnosis and trauma 41 v vi CONTENTS CHAPTER FOUR Hypnosis and dynamic psychology 55 PART III: COMPLEMENTARITY IN PRACTICE CHAPTER FIVE Complementary approaches in the general hospital 77 CHAPTER SIX Complementary cancer care 91 CONCLUSION 119 POSTSCRIPT 123 REFERENCES 127 INDEX 131 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We wish to thank Lucy Shirley and Rod Tweedy at Karnac Books for their patience and assistance in bringing this book to publication. A huge debt of gratitude goes to Lawrence’s son and daughter, Boyd Goldie and Helena Goldie for supporting this project in its final phases. This book is dedicated to them, and to Lawrence’s wife, Silvia. Some of the material included in this book has been published else- where and we would like to thank the BMJ Publishing Group, Taylor Francis, Karnac, and Cambridge University Press. Chapter Two includes material from L. Goldie and J. M. Green (1961), “Observations on Episodes of Bewilderment Seen during a Study of Petit Mal”, Epilepsia, 2(4): 306–312, and L. Goldie and J. M. Green (1959), “A Study of the Psychological Factors in a Case of Sensory Reflex Epi- lepsy”, Brain, 82(4): 505–524. Chapters Three and Four include material from L. Goldie (1956), “Hypnosis in the Casualty Department”, British Medical Journal, 2: 1340; Goldie (1958), “Hypnosis in the General Hospital”, Proceedings of the Dental and Medical Society for the Study of Hypnosis; and Goldie (1959), “Spontaneous Traumatic Reactions to Hypnosis”, British Journal of Medical Psychology, 32(2): 124–132, with permission of the BMJ Publish- ing Group. vii viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Chapters Five and Six are based on material in L. Goldie with J. Desmarais (2005), Psychotherapy and the Treatment of Cancer Patients: Bearing Cancer in Mind, London: Routledge, with permission from Taylor & Francis. The epigraph in Chapter One is from Albert Einstein and Leopold Infeld (1938), The Evolution of Physics, and appears cour- tesy of Cambridge University Press. EDITOR’S PREFACE The basis of creativity is freeing the mind so that it can voyage within and create new ideas and views. I am trying to formulate a description of thinking which is complementary. It is a serious matter because it may be that there is an inability to think if the oscillation of complementary thinking is not possible. I urge doctors to be oscillating between a medical description and the creative examination of an individual. The extreme irritation associated with the lymphoma makes it difficult to write. The book, will it ever be written? —Lawrence Goldie, Notes to JD, October 2011 To come upon the personal notes of a friend who has just died is a breath- taking experience. It is a powerful reminder that we will never again be able to answer his questions or pursue conversations. The question Lawrence posed above about finishing the book, almost seven months before he passed away—“Will it ever be written?”—was semi-rhetorical at the time, but it reminds me of the two principal concerns he had in putting this book together. One was whether he would be well enough ix