Complex Egalitarianism: a review of Alex Callinicos, Equality Erik PDF
Preview Complex Egalitarianism: a review of Alex Callinicos, Equality Erik
:msinairatil axgeElpmoC ,socinill axCe lfwAoeiv ear ytilauqE esuohgi ryBrr adH ntahgi rnWi lkOirE 1h0 c0r2aM s’socinilla CxelA Equality 1 fmoelbo re p hnktoo olbufthguo hd tnganigag n nse,ai :seuss if osretsul cnia mevi fhti wyllapicnir pslae dt I.ytilauqen idn aytilauq ecimonoce 1. The empirical facts of the matter tnec e nrdiegna hyctilauqe n fisonrett aepv awh o:h ?segna hecse hstnialp xtes etba hdw nsaedaced 2. ehT yaw eht tfeL syalhlano itthigduaorhtt tuobaytilauqe yranoitulov ehrt oebv aw ho:h ?ytilau q femoelbo rep hdtootsred nyullanoitida rsttarcom eldaic ods nsatsixraM 3. laci hspeoussosliih Pni gnikn ithutoybtailauqe n as iytilauq eya sen ona cesne stah wn i: f odni kemo so tdettimmo cyllaro me btfe Leh tdluoh syh W?ecitsu jlaico sf olaedi ?dnef etdf eeL hdtluo hmssinairatila g fetor otsa h dw? nmAsinairatilage 4. The Politics of equality today yllaicep s,eseitr alpacitil orpetnec-fo-tf eelv awh o:H rie h otwd o?Hlae d n isayatilau q femoelbo rep httsac e,rria lyBn orTed n”uruob awLeN“ ?tcejo rnpairatila gngeanicnav dr aosftcepso re p hnrtoa esbeicilop 5. :sc int aisiltr oca rpetelo pihaf,slTcdoa iergadwpeaerner ssicitil oftpor otsahW ?ylsuoir emssinairatila gleacid a frtocejo rep hetk a ot,tnia geac n,o stif eeL h ftdiedeen eswwoll otfa h nw.Iy a osstgni httnatrop mdi nganitseret nsi ashocinill asCcip oetse h fthoc aneO froebm usansucs inde hdt nsacip oetse h fthoc are osftnemug rlaartn esc iwheiv eyrlfei rlbliw e.Wnoitalumrof esrde e tneire hsweca l rptonemug rea h ntsip aeg reare hlte e efhwci h nwsiyaw me hgtnihs u fpto u,bsesyla nsa’socinill a fCtosur hltartn eec hgtnikcat t fatoiri pes h ntti osni hotd forward. 1 ,socinilla Cxel A Equality )00 0,2sse ryPtil o:Pegdirbma C( xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 2 1. ehT stcaF fo ehtrettam rfeotp athsc reihfT Equality yranidroart xee h fteoti p ns,itsr i:Fsmia leclpicni rop wsttnemuc od saniam eyrtrev o,pyrutn efcl aths ae phndtiessent is wadhlr oe whtta hhttwo rcgimonoce ;seirtnu ohcc ier h ntnie vde nealo hsadwalr oew h nthit o,belpo e fpsoess arm oyftila eertarepsed neewt epb aeg h ftsomr e nthit onbia g,asra etynec e nryilpra hnswo rsg ayhtilauq e, ndinoc edsna seirtnu odcepolev ee dhntiht iywtilauqe nciimono cfeeoerg ee dhd tnsaeirtnu orco od pnhacir mo ryfn a,msecru o fseogn aerd i nawsoeil esrocnill asCtni oepse hhtsilbat s oe.Tsevlesmeht e htta h styilgnicnivn oscwo h estha h.Wstrop etrnemnrev olgaicif fdo nsaraloh cesvitavresnoc .stc aef htt itf osne oydtinutrop peovisnap xde nyatirepso r fpeo gnaedl ow g efaenoga meilpmis et ael hltit nsu07 9y1lr aee hmto rdfoir eep h ntyitilauqe n fihotwo regviss aem hetlihW eerara e,hsteirtn uroec hrfteo ob d m,n aeuKa,hnUstet adteSt i enenhUlitbanoitseu qssn0iu991 doir espi h nteirutcur tcsimono cde nnaoitubirts iedmoc n nisiegna hec h ftsoeruta e ffroebmun :socinill aydCbetnese rtpa hnta hxtelpm oecr otmahwem oysro te shetk atmaht fsomr enntia hrtehta re(musn oycllaut cealpo etpa hfswomr eltairet a,mtcer inddierusa ef.mI)1( e h ntnie vdeoir espi hrte vdoevorp meiv arho oep h ftgoniv i flsodradna tlsaut cea h)tsgninrae y nyallautr ievk aut o fy.Its oem hntwo rsg ayhtilauqe nhici hnwiht iywrtnu oec h,tseta tdSetinU . c,e–tshertenoitid nr,oiscatel irooto d,ns ir, as,cVsTrotareg isr ef–lebra rruedmu s tnfsooicl s ashgni hetse hn two ohnwoitubirts iedmoc ne ihf% to0m2ott oe bhnetilpo efepogatnecrep r eepca pgsniv i fltoe eefrau q fsroebm uen h.Tsra eyytri htts aep hrte vyoltnacifing idsesaercni emfhoott t eodthbeatsaer c snyaichnatce pex fe.idLesaer c sneailhp ore opgonp onmoasrep neimoc naitip arc esperusa eem n fo,ieromrehtr u.Fp oet h stlal e swnaoitubirts iedmocni xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 3 s aehmoc naitip arc e,p)emoc ndilohesu orh enpe v resoeg alwaudivid nnia hrtehta rs(dlohesuoh .denilce dsa hezi sylima fecni snoitubirtsi democn ieh tf omotto beh tt anev eyltnacifingi snesir eseh tro fnoitidno cyrassece nasa wytilauqen in iesaercn ievissa meh ttah tseilpm isih tf oenoN syitilauqe n nieisaerc nei htta hytlp mti osne oydlniatr e tcdi n,amott oeb h tteaf i nlsitnemevorpmi ta httnempolev ecdimono cfdeon ie khtta hetzingoc eotrtnatrop mstt iiiu.Belbatpec cyallarom sefe0hod2ta ceee drt dhsenetahirltru cscaoh ht ntinemevorp mliairet a tmhit itwhguo rybrutn ec .noitalup oep hott nyilpe eydlri atfn etwa hgtniv i flsodradnats nwo rsg ayhtilauqe nlilare veoli h,wytilauqe neimoc n fisonrett a npsiegna h fcsomr e. nt)I2( n i”pa gredneg “eh t:denilce dsa hytilauqen if onoisnemi dtneila sen o,s079 1ylra eeh tecni sylprahs sb o fjnooitagerg ersedn e.Gerehwes lde nsaeta tdSeti neU h ntdienilc eydltnacifing iss ashgninrae seunitno cereh telih W.snoitiso plairegana mleve lrehgi hn isbo jredne ggnidulcn i,denilce dosl asah taa hetcnedi vkea eywlri asefire hsteta tdSeti ne Uhnttisa et,laytiroht un”aip argedn e eogabt“ .tsi x oesteunitn ogcnili escsa llgaer 2)detim if lir(alucitr ae pn,oredn eotgtceps ehrt itwsa etlA ro ftluciffi dero ms it itah tsnae mylpmi st if I.en oyrepp2il sas i”gnilie cssal geht “f oaed ieh T ssa ldgeredn enage h,tseihcrare ilhanoitazinag r fosolev epl ohtca e ornt erm onfa hntemow egwnili escsa l yg fbti u.Berehwes lde nsaeta tdSeti neU h nttisi x oesteunitn oyclniatr egcniliec hci hnwoitomo rlpacitr e ovstelcats b fomoets ynasaem yetsia sennriectnnii psuev oe mnsoa evitale rnamo waf oytilibabor peh tn iecnereffi deh thcih wn imetsy sa,erofereh tdn a–seihcrareih seire h SteU h ntnie hl–tev ehlt iswesaerc ntix een h otltev eel nmoo rdfetomo rgpni en b aoamt ni lkOi reE esseus seise h ftnooissucs iddednet x nera o.Fgnili escsa lggnor tras oefcnedi veelttil fyodu tesvitarapm o:acsisehtop ygHnili esCsa leG hgtnitse T,“retx anBeen adJ ntahgirW ,”ailart sdyunaAaw r,osNet adteSt ie,nhnUTedewS 0 0,0y2t eri ec&donSeG . For a debate over retx aoeBtsnopse R,“smaill I.eWLnitsir hd Cnnaotti r.aBMn ae De,srep aspi hfstotnemug reaht ”,thgi rdWna rey dtdneneiaGcoS denear rxe rFaa rM;y8M08- 4:008 0r0e2bme c )e46D1( ”,thgi rd Wnraetx aoeBtsnops e:Regatnavdas ieDvitalum ud Cnyatilauq E,“ahtsayakr uaPnadnaB rey dtdneneiaGcoS eh T,“retx anBeen ad Jntahgi rnWi lkOi r;E318- 9 :0:080 0r2ebmec e) D64(1 .”,sciti r oCytlp e:ARsisehtop ygHnili esCsalG rey dtdneneiaGcoS :r -0e440b 110m)82e6c(eD 821. xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 4 dezila egrni e obrteso l scy–icarcotir enmi he–tlpicni r”pytinutrop p foyotilauq ee“ h ftmorof yadot naht eerh tsedaced.oga 3 e hfstonoitamrofsna re th,tsgninr ad eneamoc nfniooitubirts ie dhfntooitse ue qhdtnoy e.B)3( naa hxtelpm oecr ooms l saeirutcur ttsnemyolp mee h ntsib o fjsoep y ftyotilauqe n fieorutcurts noisnap xeegr ael htta h steiga mrialup oep n.Otsegg udslu oswise hyttilauqe nginisaerc neilpmis e h ytdbeziretcara hnce esb ash09 9y1lr aee hetcn isseta tdSeti neU h nttinemyolp mfeo rotc eescivr edsi aypld a fbnooisnap xee hdt nsaeiroget abc odjelli kgsniy alpl e fwnooitcurtsed e hdt nsaeirtsudni-ot uda nlaee tes h nttinemyolp m fenooitcud eer h ft soeiga mciino cei h.Tsboj .tnemyolp mdeo otfs a ffnooisnapxe ylpm iesga msii h,t09 9e1cn iesrutcur tbs oej h ntsiegna hec h ttlaiat e ndkio o elfwI deniarg-en iyflri aeafk a:tswoll o sfearutcur tbs oej hetnif e sdtu e.Ldl oth’nseod lanoitapucco nda n ta nisieiroget a0c 0t1uo bhat iewmeh cnsoitacifissalc ro tcciemsonoce hti wnoitacifissal c ek isleiroget ascedulc ntinemenif e frloev esli h ttealbair alvanoitapuc c no.Aseiroget a 0ct2uoba ek islnoitagerg gdaao ryblpm insa hrteh t” a,rsrevi rkdcur td“ n”a,stsinihca m”“,sesr udneretsiger“ tnempiu qneoitatropsna rd tn,asrotare peonihc admelli k,sslanoisseforp-im eesrac-htlaeh lanoitacu dd en,aeda retlaselo h,wgnirutcafun aemlbar ussdagni hhtc uesdulc nsirotc e.Ssrotarepo 3 “y B thin ,hci hswnoitis oopt neilpo e fpnooitacol l famoets ynasa e em”wycarcotir em ta ehtemit of allocation str ols lhat itwnetsisn o scyicarcotir enmi h.Ttir e fmsois aeb h nteolpo espetubirts i,d .noitse u nqsib oej hrt osfnoitacifila ueq hgtnini a ngeic aeflpo espegatnavdas ifdo kcihT , e hgtniriuq c naeic aeflpo espegatnavdas iydl neo htta hsteilp m,itsartn o nc,iycarcotirem kci hd tnnai hhtt o.Bstnel altarut aoe ntusdegatnavdas ie drsanoitis or posfnoitacifilauq fnooitacol lnao ptunebmuc nsidraw enyritilauqe nfeioerg ee dhntoitse ut q ooyndcarcotirem ,ese hfhtot o.Bserudeco rnpoitacol le ahfstosenri ae fhsetius syil ne oh;tsnoitis ooeptlpoep hc i”nhyiwtinutro pyfptooila upqee edde“m rteehbt gti amhh twdiewtsart n eoeo,rtbcearofereht denoits esueqvlesm e eh)rtsab osjn(oiti sdooetphca tstdara w eeyfhrtotilauq eefneoir geehdt .stnel altarut a fnsoeitilauqe n fisotcef fee hetzilartu e onstke eystinutrop p foyotilau qpee eedcnis xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 5 n.Ixirt armotc e ysnboitapuc c 00ox 20e1gr asli h ntsill eec h steapyt-b oeajnif e sdtu e.Lsecivres egr ayl r geanvi s.Usepyt-b otjnereff i0d0 0t2uo byallaitnet oe preare h,terofere h,txirt asmiht ne hn tae,cwelpo efspodnasuo hfstoderdn ufshoeta tdSeti ne Uhnetilpm aescr orfob allanoitan e hhtt iewpyt-b oe jhosttgninr aneaid etmsehg ie hhhtt iewp ye thmto rsfepyt-b oejse hrted rkonar deredro-k neasr ephut onr eg nh,eatgwcnire dkr nosa irghnt i.ssUgnin rnaaei dtesmewol e h ftgoninnig eeb h tttanemyolp mleau qeev ahhci hswretsu lnc eott n.ie. is(elic eodt nsieirogetac doir egpn oel hgtnir undoisnap xbe otj een h ftnooitubirts ied hetnima xnee hdt n)anoisnap xbeoj er1u gdnieiFtnes e ersrptalu s ee.hrsT0 9 eh9fht1otw ocrigmon ofcoe 4 . b oej h ntnioitaziral o fpsoseco rdapeed n sieire htta h steitacid nsitlus eerse httahW erutcurts – eht tseb dna tsrow seliced fo eht boj er uettcuubritrstno ceht tsom ot eht latotboj fsoelic eeder hp toe thndtietartnecn oecr osnmioisnap xb eoe jhltlare vtoa hots lt nau–obisnapxe )sb o fjnooisnap xte een h ftfol ayhlra ern otfnuoc cyalevitcell ohccih we(rutcur ttsnemyolp meeht elpm inasa hxtelpm oecr o smtia hetrutc isa,pine h,tev a ehtwa h.Wselic emdott oeb h ntniaht t o,np oet h ttdaethgi eywtilauqe nbi o njeisaerc n ni sa ti:ierutcur tbs oej h ntyitilauqe n nieisaercni .erut ctun remt mos eytf hotoetlohpbtme erdholt frxoewlp mse oer acsoromephte gsontoitavre slbaore neee grehs teghntikaT s’socinill a yCdbetsegg u ssnia hsttnempolev eydraropmetn o fceouqiti rncairatila gleacidar s aywtilauqe ntia hst agwninepp ash atwa hlt l fa.Iytrev odp nyatilauqe ngininepe e fdtoiartrop enb a,celbair alvanoitapuc cdoenif esrs etlah4wem ogasni s,ustlus eerse h ftnooissucs irdell uAf b o fjsonrett a:penihc asMb onJacire meA h, Tr“ey wlDehc adR ntahgi rnWi lkOi r nEdinuof ” s h s 0d te0n9newh6i9ahot91tr1g wei vneoRtsoB nsaedulc nois lraep atpa h.T00 0r2ebmec e,D nosirapm oda cn,asrekr oewm ittr a,pnoisnap xbe oej h ntsinrett arpedn edg nlaaic a frsoisylana .s06 9e 1hfntooisnap xe ehhttiw xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 6 ezilib o omrteis a ee,bspahr e,pdlu o twnie h,tgnisaerc nyilpra hnsoitaziral odp nganinepeed .sdne retse hgtnicudo re prhaci hswecitca rd pnsaeicil oe p hoettgnell a dhancih esbecr orfalupop laireta mn iesaercn idesab-daor bylria fa) 1hti wgnol agninepee ds iytilauqen itah ttca fehT mott oeb h nteilpo eep h fttonemg etsnacifing igasnidulc n,ielpo etps o fmgoniv i flsodradnats b oej h nteigna h )acd3 n,aytilauqe nriedn e ngsienilc e )d,2noitubirts isdgninr aee h ftsoeliced seitinutrop ptonemyolp mfneooisnap xleaitnatsb ussu lnpoitaziral oynpboitaziretcara hecrutcurts ese h.Ttluciff iedr onmoitazilib ohmc ussek a,merutcur ttsnemyolp mee h ftdori hpt oet hnti nek aettbs uyme hd tn,asnoisul lt ioe nrsanoitidn occimono cfneooitamrofsna re t hfstoerutaef .tcejo rnpairatila ge ehttuo bganikni hr tunnoioitaredisn ooctni 2. The Left and the problem of equality . evitamr odnetcej esr a thtia hmtsixr alManoitida r ftmosiciti rec hytlsuoir essek astocinillaC ,sre h dt,nosaa rneaGm rho tNsiewe r.egtHanemir t senotd eti sesab ihth at dh,ntyaro elhatcitilop ,swe ilvacihte-at enmekats id maeehhsuac e,bhguoht leacits ufyjoro e hhat tidwetare pxor atMaht reh td on,astsixr a.Mecits ufyjoro e )haetv adhluo hr sod (aethha hetveil et bod niedh d n,aecits u fjyoroe hpatolev e,dsocinill a oCgtnidroc c,ats usmtsilaic oeslbisnops eyrllautcelletni nairatil aygrearopmet nkfo ro c eogohwnttidne tssyt iibathut ogbnaikn ithrt aeotcts atl speehbt .ecru otsa hmto rdfenra een lbatca hewtartsnom eoskdtio oe bhfm toilaart n .eAsclarebil we irv u no,i snioitida rltareb inlairatila gee httuo bya a osst ashocinill atCa h fwtosoM e h ntyilr aseek a emnhoitida rltareb iel h ftmosiciti rec n soeire htt u.Bevitis o,pyletairporppa tae r otdtedn esta hn“oitida rltareb iel htta hsteug rsaocinill a.Ccitamelbo r splie e efhwci hkwoob xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 7 ”rehto nea nhot itwcilfn o ncyilirassec e snmaodee rdf nyatilauqe 5eva hslarebi lnairatilag edn a, socinill a,Cnoitpmus ssai httsni a. ggAnikni hrtie h otdtnuorgkc a sabnaoitpmus ssai hdtlehpu dlu oshesiranoitulo vte arshetugra noisserp xse’rabil a nBdieidob maee dei hetsrodne “ .”étrebilage yllatnemadnu fer aytilauq edn aytrebi ltah tsiseh teh tsmriff aaed isih t,ero cst itA rie ht ta,h std“r osw’rabil anr,Bioni oecm ae shfstoed ioswt snoisnetxe .lacitned iylirassece nera e htta h,tylnia ltt piuopT snoitautis ”.em aes hytlirassec een rtanes b ratonese r sphic aheci h nwi 6 d nyatilau qneeewt enboital elranoitcn uef htta hsteveil esbocinill atCa httsegg usstnemug reasehT nhit otbcerroc n sisiocinill atCa hetveil e eb.W Ae2rug i nFdieyartr ompr orfaen iel hstek ayttrebil er o,md nnaoitida rltareb iel h ntyitilau qde nyatreb inleewt eebgakn iel h ftgonidnatsred nsuih .snoisnem iod wetse hnteewt enboitcenn olcanoitcn uef h ftnooitaziretcara hsc i nh,iyltnatropmi ,tcilfn o ncei ryatilau qde nyatreb itla hntoitpmus slaareb illanoitida ret hgtninrecnoC e h fttonemtae rst’sl w f anoRoitaterpret nsi i nhrior reevitcurts ndi nnaomm osacek asmocinillaC o w ftsomr e ntmielbo rspi hstetalumr osflw a.R”ytrebi ld“ n”aytilauq en“eewt epbihsnoitaler ye keh T.”ecitsu Jf oelpicnir Pdnoce Seht “dn a”elpicnir PytrebiL “eh tslla ce hhcih w,selpicnirp feolpicni rdPnoc eeS hrte veolpicni ryPtreb ieL h ftyotiroi rep h ftnooitres ssa’slw a sReir eehussi fyotilau qreia fs“eriuq eercits utja hate dsi’slw a sReicits u fjeolpicni rdPnoc eeS h.Tecitsuj e rfa flol etwsa eel httifen e obntwo h esnb ahcci hsweitilauqe nyil ntoa hrtehtr udf n”aytinutroppo cisa btah tseugr aelpicnir Pytrebi Leh T.)”elpicnir pecnereffi dnimixam “suoma feht (elbatpecca ytreb iel h ft”oytiroi reptulosb ae“ httuo bmaia lec h.Tl l oadtetubirts iydllau q eetbs usmeitrebil 5 ,socinilla C Equality, p.23 6.22 .,psocinill a nCdieto uQ xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 8 ,ytinutrop p foyotilau qrei aefrus n oentek asterusa e,myroe hst’slw a nRtia hstna esmu hetlpicnirp tsa eel h fttoifen eeb h otdtegnar r easbeitilauqe ntia httnemeriuq eer httnemelp m oidtna ssai hstterpret nsiocinill a.Cseitreb iclis albau qee hhtt itwcilfn otc otns udmegatnavda laico sdn amodeer flaudividn ineewte btcilfno can ifeile blarebi llanoitidar teht ‘gnicudorper ’remr oe ]fhr gtonfitp od [n,aytilauqe 7 . fyotiroi rep h.Tnoitis osp’slw a fRsonoitacilp mei h ftnooitaterpret nniekats i samsiihT re vyotreb ir loefcneref e tranpeserp et rosne oedlpicni rdPnoc ee Shrte veolpicni ryPtreb ieLht hci hrwed nsunoitidn oscetalupi teslpicni rdpnoc eeS h.Tsffo-eda ret reare hnte hywtilauqe e h.Tdegatnav dtasa ee lhfttoifen ee bhodttegnar re aryae htta h:telbatpec ce arsaeitilauqeni gniht o:nytilau qeetomo r opetn o edyb atma htwim idleed nsie oedlpicni ryptreb ieL h ftyotiroirp sniartsn oycldnuofo r tp,iyltnacifing iesr otm u.Bseitreb iclis aeb hstetalo itva hetn o edybam inecnereff ied hyttilauqe n fieoerg eed h otttim idlelpicni r op sneire h,teno lganit c.Aytilauqe e httifen e obntwo h esdblu oychtla eywlsuolub aeflpo eepm ogsnik a fm.Iwol ldalu oewlpicnirp seitilauqe nhic utsa hyt adslu oewcits u fjeolpicni rdpnoc ees hftles t yinbe h,tyteic o nsfi ftosrow otna hsterus n teeicn i,sytilibiss ospi hstkco leblpicni ryptreb iel h ftyotiroi rep h.Tdeifits uejrew seirutcir tssi h.Tseitreb iclis aeb h ftyotiruc ees hntetaer hdtlu oywe h ftdiettimr eep rsaeitilauqeni ria fs‘droc csalw a,Rset osnocinill a sC,aesuac erbaep ptasr i tftahg inma hntairatila geer onmeve e h ntdiedulc nwi o sneirusa esmi h,tet otn osne o e dsh,ad nsaeitreb illacitil oep h ot’teulav sna eemul arvi aefsuac e.Bselpicni rop wet h fttonemeta tlsacinon aec h nteilpicni ryPtrebiL e rhatla edw neamoc n fisoeitilauqe nliaitnatsb uessuac edb n’aeul alvauq e o‘etso lgcnihtemos 784. p,socinilla C xmeslipnmaoiCratilagE 9 , seilpicni ryPtreb ieL h ftyotiroi rep h,t tsidnatsred nsulw a sRyatilau qleacitil ohpt iewlbitapmocni .ecits u fjyoroe het h fttocep snaairatila gyellairet a,amsoirane ctss onmi 8 seitreb iclis albau qe ehtta httc ae f hn,toesru of,cosdnep esdlw afgRonidnatsred nsuihT si h.Tkciz oeNk islnairatreb i,lelpma xr eo, fydbetres syatrepo reptavi rotpthg igrnor te shetdulcxe , teik iglnihty n ratohg itra hetdulc n,islw arR o,ft o onsdeitreb iclis albau qee hetsuac e,ben isfi and for good reasons. .ytreb idl nyatilau qneeewt etbcilfn oeclbiss oep h fteous sliaren eeg h otntrut e srtu ewloN nsiyaw le aryatilau qd enyatreb it la sh–etse hetse hfrtoeh te ohre toneoso hod ctae hnfoI ta heter gdalu oen wwe rh–ethteg odtednet xeyebl nn oayctilau qd enyatreb itla hr,totcilfnoc t .sn)oIsml wd al sRu,orosta wue , ptsrpiae a(m n renarohihe fttt htent ahiue eltrrsrtoiemht e ht.t umBodee rnfam u fheopo ces hetcnah nyetilau qre osfelggur t,ssecnatsmucr ilcacirotsih noisserp xee hrted nruabil a yBdbesopo raplumr oeflpmis étrebilage r o,fyrotcafsitas nous lsai yrev en itah tenigam io tgnidaelsi ms it idn a”ytrebil “f omelbor peh tf ostceps ayna mer aereht odteed n.Iytreb ifslotcep sl a lftaonemecnah n noetatnelaviu qsteicejo rnpairatila ge ehttcepser ,eta lsrsuraapabiei tplospataB ,o dt aehrte het rsaff oo -nseidar t o,ted atvoen , eovt leonsoerfo .ecitca rypranoitulov ed rnyaroe hltacitil ohpt onsbinoitse ulqartn eecht 9 oe tryatreb id lnyatilau qneeewt esbffo-eda retlbiss od pnpaihsnoital ee rhw to,hesru ofcO ek a sttu e.Ldenif eed ryatreb idl nyatilau qhet owb o nhyoltnacifing issdnep eddootsred neub 8 ,esuohgi ryBrr ae Hetsnemug rsai hfntooitaroba lnr eaoF ",ssenri aseFacits unyJitilau qlEacitiloP" lacihposolihPseidutS , lov ,68 .on ,2 yaM ,7991 ..p4p81-551 9 ,tfi wmSa de Aessffo-eda re t hfntooissucs itdnage lnre aoF Liberty, Equality, Community: an se tna oudsidn rt aaeecrrmtuogisdfrrioePnrditnMnUI .)gnimochtr o,fytilo P(
Description:The list of books you might like
